Buzz
Wars remain a grim reality of human existence. What's worse, even if you're against war, you might find yourself compelled to participate through military conscription. Numerous countries mandate men (and occasionally women) to serve in the armed forces during wartime or even peacetime. While active conscription may not exist everywhere, all male US citizens and certain male immigrants aged 18 to 25 are required to register with the Selective Service within 30 days of turning 18, potentially subjecting them to a future draft. So, what options do you have? Fear not, as there are several avenues – some lawful, some not – that can help you avoid military service.
Actions
Consulting Legal Experts
Seek advice from a reputable attorney. Dodging mandatory military service constitutes a criminal offense with severe repercussions. For instance, in a recent incident, an Australian citizen was apprehended and imprisoned in Israel for draft evasion; she had resided there during her teenage years. Prioritize seeking legal counsel before taking any steps. Lawyers can apprise you of pertinent laws and provide guidance on your available courses of action.
Examine Past Cases. Work alongside your legal counsel to investigate recent instances of military service avoidance. In countries like the US, notable cases have emerged in the past decade, where individuals refused to comply with military duties. Some attempted to flee to Canada but faced deportation, landing them in legal trouble. While these individuals are technically considered deserters, not draft evaders, their experiences can offer valuable insights into your options and the potential repercussions of evading conscription.
- Recently, Polish citizens have relocated to Britain to evade conscription in their homeland, where the penalty is up to three years of imprisonment. This migration has been facilitated by the relatively unrestricted freedom of movement within the European Union.
Evaluate Your Alternatives. You're on the brink of making a significant and potentially life-altering decision. Thoroughly assess all available options with the guidance of legal experts. Stay informed about recent legal precedents. Ensure that you're making an informed choice and have contingency plans for every possible scenario.
- Consider whether you hold dual citizenship in a nation not engaged in warfare. Exploring such possibilities could provide an avenue for relocation. Are you a member of the LGBTQ+ community? Many armed forces exclude individuals belonging to these groups from military service.
- Do you affiliate with a religious denomination with a longstanding tradition of pacifism, such as the Quakers, Mennonites, or Jehovah’s Witnesses? If so, you might qualify for conscientious objector status, indicating your opposition to war or violence on religious grounds.
- Do you have any physical or mental health conditions that could render you unfit for conscription? Document these conditions meticulously. Even minor ailments, like asthma, should be regularly recorded by a medical professional. Regardless of your condition, comprehensive documentation is crucial.
Applying for Conscientious Objector Status
Submit a Formal Application. Many countries excuse conscientious objectors from military duty. In the US, these exemptions extend not only to members of pacifist religious groups like Jehovah’s Witnesses, Quakers, Mennonites, and Amish but also to individuals who genuinely and sincerely oppose participating in warfare or bearing arms due to religious beliefs. Conscientious objectors fall into two categories: Class 1-O and Class 1-A-O. The former comprises individuals who object to any involvement in war, while the latter object solely to combatant roles.
- The application process typically commences with the submission of a formal application, accompanied by comprehensive documentation of your beliefs. You must demonstrate to the reviewing authorities the authenticity of your convictions and the absence of ulterior motives. Evidence of your active participation in a religious community, ethical or moral studies, and other relevant factors will be scrutinized.
Participate in Interviews and Hearings. Expect to undergo interviews as part of the conscientious objector application review process. You may be required to converse with a psychologist, a military chaplain (representing your religious faith), and ultimately, an investigating officer during a hearing. These individuals will assess the genuineness of your beliefs and the credibility of your claim. Be prepared to provide detailed insights into your convictions, religious affiliations, and personal history. Third-party testimonies may also be solicited to support your case.
- Keep in mind that your interviews are not confidential, meaning that questions may be posed to individuals who have prior knowledge of you, such as a chaplain. In such instances, request an interview with a different chaplain to ensure impartiality.
Await the outcome of the informal inquiry. Following the interviews, the investigating officer will compile a dossier on your case. This typically includes statements, hearing documents, witness testimonies, assessments of your objections' foundation, and recommendations regarding your classification as a conscientious objector. Subsequently, the entire dossier undergoes scrutiny by a military judge advocate before reaching the ultimate decision-making authority.
- Given the shift towards a voluntary military enlistment in the US and the requirement to pledge an oath upon induction, attaining conscientious objector status is challenging. Essentially, you must demonstrate a shift in your views on warfare post-taking the military oath.
Initiating a Refugee Application
Evaluate the viability of your case. Securing refugee status to evade conscription poses significant challenges. International law lacks clarity on this issue – refugees fleeing military service are neither explicitly covered nor necessarily excluded from the Geneva Conventions. Your case's prospects partly hinge on your legal and civil standing in your home country. Prior to embarking on the uncertain path of seeking refugee status, consult with legal counsel to assess the merits of your case.
- The UN identifies five scenarios wherein refugee status may be warranted: persecution for conscientious objection; objection to military activities constituting atrocities or breaching international law; refusal of military service under conditions tantamount to torture or inhumane treatment; evasion of recruitment by non-state entities amid state incapacity to offer protection; or resistance by minors to unlawful recruitment.
Select your destination country wisely. Should you opt for a refugee claim, exercise caution when choosing your host nation. It's imperative to seek refuge in a country unwilling to extradite you to your country of origin. For instance, the days of seeking refuge in Canada as a US military objector are long gone. While legal interpretations remain murky, deserters and similar individuals risk arrest and deportation for trial under existing extradition treaties. Countries less inclined to deport US citizens include Ecuador, Russia, and Venezuela.
Submit your application. The subsequent step involves formally submitting an application for refugee protection. If you're outside your target nation, you'll likely apply for refugee status at the nearest embassy or consulate; if already within the country or at a point of entry, you'll seek asylum. Your application must be accompanied by substantiated evidence supporting your persecution claims.
- Seek legal guidance at this stage, if feasible. Legal professionals can assist with navigating the often intricate application procedures.
- Prepare for protracted processing times. In Canada, for instance, wait periods can extend up to 36 months.
- You may face restrictions on employment during the waiting period, if granted entry. In the US, asylum seekers must endure a 150-day waiting period before applying for work authorization.
Qualifying for Exemption, Deferring Service, or Objecting
Apply for an exemption. Most nations offer exemptions from military conscription under certain circumstances. For instance, until recently, Israel granted exemptions to religious students. In the United States, exemption from a potential draft is granted under various conditions: familial loss due to military action; potential family financial hardship; religious ministry or studies; or immigrant or dual citizenship status.
- Note that the US currently lacks an active draft. Exemption claims can only be filed in the future, upon receiving draft orders, at the nearest Selective Service office.
- Some countries, such as Turkey, still prohibit the service of LGBTQ+ individuals. In such cases, individuals may need to provide proof of their sexual orientation, leading to potentially traumatic and humiliating experiences.
- In certain countries, individuals may have the option to pay an exemption fee to avoid military service. However, such fees, as in Turkey, can be prohibitively expensive and accessible only to affluent families.
Request a deferment. If you do not qualify for an exemption, you might still be eligible to postpone military service. Many countries grant deferments for educational pursuits. In the US, high school students can defer service in a future draft until graduation or reaching the age of 20. College students can defer until the completion of their academic term. Individuals pursuing a career in ministry can also defer until the conclusion of their studies.
- In the United States, the law allows for appeals to draft classification. Filing for a classification change automatically grants a deferment until the claim is processed.
Opt to refuse service. This represents a final recourse. However, refusal carries severe consequences. In the US, individuals have faced imprisonment for refusing military induction during both wartime and peacetime drafts. Notably, Muhammad Ali refused induction during the Vietnam War, resulting in a five-year prison sentence, the loss of his boxing titles, and legal proceedings.
- Under current US law, failure to register with Selective Service, for a potential future draft, constitutes a criminal offense. Penalties may include prosecution, denial of federal benefits like student aid or government employment, and, for eligible immigrants, withholding of US citizenship.
Pointers
Important Reminders
- Acquire information promptly to enable timely action.
- Take well-informed actions promptly.
