Buzz
Essay prompt: Write an argumentative essay analyzing and evaluating a 10th-grade literature poem titled 'Kite'
Outline and sample essay Writing an argumentative essay analyzing and evaluating a literary work
A. Topic 1. Analysis and Evaluation of 'Island Soldiers Singing Love Songs on the Island,' by Tran Dang Khoa
I. Outline for Analysis and Evaluation of 'Island Soldiers Singing Love Songs on the Island,' by Tran Dang Khoa
1. Introduction:
- Introduce the author and the work.
- Express general impressions and emotions about the poem.
2. Body
2.1. Analysis and evaluation of themes and content:
a. Themes and main inspirations:
- Theme: imagery of island soldiers.
- Main inspiration: affection, praise for soldiers.
b. Depiction of island soldiers, represented by:
* Harsh life amidst waves and winds:
- Makeshift, rudimentary:
+ Stage floor is coral.
+ Chicken coop made of tin sheets.
- Hardships, scarcity: scarce fresh water.
- Harsh nature:
+ Wind blowing fiercely.
+ Sand flying wildly like a flock of wild birds.
* Image of island soldiers:
- Appearance: bald heads.
- Always cheerful, optimistic, and loving life:
+ Not afraid of natural obstacles 'Just let it be. Hey, comrades'.
+ Teasing, calling each other 'teacher'.
-> These soldiers have made life on a remote island rich and vibrant through their own creativity.
- Pure, rich emotions:
+ Longing for love like all ordinary people.
+ Always hold the homeland in their small hearts.
2.2. Analysis and evaluation of artistic forms:
- Familiar, pure imagery.
- Simple, understandable language.
- Free verse poetry, playful, humorous tone.
- Use of techniques: comparison 'Sand flying like a flock of wild birds', aphorism 'Sing out for'.
3. Conclusion:
- Reaffirm the value of the poem.
II. Sample Essay: Analysis and Evaluation of 'Island Soldiers Singing Love Songs on the Island,' by Tran Dang Khoa
Mentioning the 'poetic prodigy' Tran Dang Khoa immediately brings to mind familiar works such as 'Rain,' 'Coconut Tree,' 'Oh Moon... Where From.' It's evident that Tran Dang Khoa's poems often feature bright, familiar imagery and simple language. He vividly portrays life around him in a realistic and lively manner. This is clearly evident in the work 'Island Soldiers Singing Love Songs on the Island.'
As the title suggests, the central figure of the poem is the island soldier. They have been steadfastly holding their guns day and night, protecting the country's maritime borders. Writing about the theme of soldiers - the beloved soldiers of Uncle Ho, poet Tran Dang Khoa skillfully depicts people with beautiful souls, loving life, and always optimistic.
Living amidst the vast ocean waves, soldiers must endure extremely makeshift and deprived conditions:
'Coral rocks serve as the stage,'
A few metal sheets bury some chicken wings
Don't blame them, my dear, they're just makeshift
No backdrop can withstand the Truong Sa winds
To create a performance stage, the island soldiers utilized what nature provided, such as coral rocks. These are natural rocks distributed across our country's coastal areas. The chicken wings - where they await their performance - are also rudimentarily constructed using a few metal sheets. With just four concise lines, the poet helps us understand more about the difficult life on the islands. At the same time, we see the harshness of the vast nature, 'no backdrop can withstand the Truong Sa winds.'
When speaking of their makeshift, rudimentary living conditions, the soldiers do not feel sad or discouraged, but always wear a smile of optimism:
'The wind stings the face, The Island always changes its shape
Sand and gravel fly like wild birds
Just ignore it. Hey, comrades
Let's begin. The clouds and water have opened the show
Every few hours, Truong Sa Island changes its shape. It seems that living long on this land, the soldiers feel very familiar. The strong winds, high waves, or flying gravel are no longer obstacles to them. Now, when it comes to difficulties, they speak with a calm, light tone, 'Just ignore it.'
Moving on to the third stanza of poetry, the poet directs his pen to depict the portrait of the island soldiers:
'The makeshift stage hosts several bald-headed boys
The audience bustling around also includes the bald-headed soldiers
Scarce fresh water, is it meant for hair washing?
Old soldiers, young soldiers, all are bald and cheerful
The cultural performance becomes truly special when the cast and audience consist of 'several bald-headed boys.' In the midst of the windy waves, difficult travel, and isolation from the mainland, these soldiers have found their own pastime. Besides studying and fighting, they always strive to enrich and beautify life. With creativity, talent, and enthusiasm, the island soldiers have personally created cultural products in a 'self-sufficient' manner. Hence, whether in the stands or on stage, all you see are bald heads, no hair. The line 'Scarce fresh water, is it meant for hair washing?' not only explains the 'old soldiers, young soldiers, all are bald and cheerful' but also cleverly emphasizes the conditions of scarcity in their living environment.
The island soldiers also shine with an optimistic spirit, a love for life, and a pure, noble, and emotional soul. From hardship, they make everything brighter. They set aside difficulties and dangers to enjoy moments of happiness together. They joke around, affectionately calling their comrades 'elder siblings' or 'distant relatives.' When the melancholic melody echoes, the soldiers sing gentle, deep, and nostalgic songs. This is a special love song, unique to those soldiers living on distant islands. Like countless ordinary people, island soldiers also yearn for romantic love 'Beloved, where are you? Which direction do you reside?/ Does your hair fall long or short? Only the heavens know/ Whose silhouette will come to us?' Each sincere verse is sung from tender and romantic souls.
From personal, private feelings, island soldiers develop into shared emotions:
'Let's sing out so the night knows
That love shines within us here
We stand firm amidst countless storms and winds
The motherland Vietnam begins right here...'
The aphorism 'let's sing out' is like a call for everyone to join in singing the anthem loudly. It's a love song about romantic love. Or it's a love song about love for the homeland, the country. Above all, the island soldiers always keep the beloved image of the motherland in their small hearts. From there, they see the mountains and rivers of Vietnam as a support, a motivation to strive every day.
With free verse, simple language, easy to understand, and rhetorical devices like 'Pebbles fly like wild birds,' aphorism 'Let's sing out for,' Trần Đăng Khoa has successfully highlighted the image of resilient but innocent, carefree island soldiers.
Reading the poem 'Island soldiers sing love songs on the island', we admire and love the people who are dedicating their youth and energy to the homeland. They are representatives of the heroic and courageous Vietnamese generation. Hopefully, the values and meanings of the work will always live on in the hearts of readers.
Sample essay Write the best poetry review
B. Topic 2. Analysis, evaluation of The Country, by Nguyễn Đình Thi
I. Outline for analyzing The Country by Nguyễn Đình Thi
1. Introduction:
- Introduction of the author and the work.
- Express general feelings about the poem.
2. Body:
2.1. Main inspiration and theme:
- Main inspiration: love and profound pride for the homeland.
- Theme: sentiment for the country.
2.2. Analysis and evaluation of the theme, content:
a. Autumn in reminiscence:
- Hanoi autumn depicted with:
+ Fresh, cool atmosphere 'early cold breeze'.
+ Fragrance of young rice mixed with the autumn wind 'wind blows new fragrance of young rice'.
+ Quiet space of long streets.
+ Leaves falling on the doorstep.
- Prominently in that picture is the image of people leaving with the mindset 'head not looking back'.
b. 'This autumn' - a completely different autumn:
- The line 'This autumn is different now' is placed at the beginning of the poem to emphasize the change in life.
- The country's picture in 'this autumn' is portrayed through the vast, rich space of 'mountains and hills', 'bamboo forests'.
- In that picture, people emerge with the mindset of being in charge 'The sky here belongs to us [...] The red rivers are laden with silt'.
c. Image of the country in wartime:
* Suffering, resentment of the country:
- The author creates images like 'bloodied fields', 'bowl of rice filled with tears', 'one pressing another's neck, one stripping another's skin' to:
+ Emphasize the cruelty of the enemy.
+ Evoke the painful situation of the nation.
-> Hatred, anger towards the enemy.
* Resilient, heroic country:
- A series of terms like 'shine', 'rise', 'unlocked', 'unshootable', 'stand up' are used to affirm the strength, resilient will, indomitable spirit of our nation.
- The two concluding lines 'Vietnam rises from fire and blood/ Shakes off mud, stands up brightly': symbolic images of the heroic Vietnam rising proudly from fire.
2.3. Analysis, evaluation of artistic highlights:
- Rich evocative language.
- Harmonious combination of romantic poetry and rhetoric.
- Successful use of comparison, metaphor.
3. Conclusion:
- Reaffirm the value of the work.
II. Sample Essay Analyzing The Country by Nguyễn Đình Thi
'The Country' is one of the prominent works of poet Nguyễn Đình Thi. This work was conceived in the early years of the resistance against the French colonialists (1948 - 1949) and truly completed in 1955. With rich evocative imagery, the poem has left a deep impression on readers about the image of heroic Vietnam.
Throughout 'The Country,' we easily see the subject to which the author dedicates his full emotions and feelings is the beloved homeland. In the poet's eyes, the country is always beautiful and rich in cultural traditions. Thus, the main inspiration of the work is love, sincere pride for Vietnam.
The poem opens with a scene:
'Cool as it was in the past
Autumn breeze carries the scent of new rice'.
Because it's a nostalgic autumn, only the most prominent, profound things are revealed. It's the fresh, cool air. Or the fragrance of green rice drifting in the autumn wind. With two concise lines, the poet vividly describes the space, the imagery of autumn. The autumn picture, though quiet and melancholic, still makes the sentimental character endlessly nostalgic, 'I remember the days of autumn that have passed.'
Deep in memory, Hanoi remains as poetic as ever:
'Early chill within Hanoi's heart
Long streets sway with the morning mist'
As autumn settles in, bringing a gentle chill that envelops the entire city. The long streets still echo with the swaying breath of the autumn breeze. Nature, the scenery seems immersed in silence. Standing out in the picture of Hanoi in autumn is the image of people leaving with a resolute attitude, 'heads not turning back.' Though stepping forward, their hearts remain lingering, deeply nostalgic. Hence, despite not looking back, people still feel 'the doorstep filled with fallen leaves.'
Still, it's the autumn picture, but now it adorns itself with a new garment:
'This autumn is different now
I stand joyfully amidst the hills
The wind rustles through the bamboo forest
The autumn sky dons a new attire
In the azure, conversations are filled with sincere laughter
If in the first seven lines, the poetic tone flows slowly, gracefully, and deeply, then by this stanza, the tone becomes robust, cheerful, and lively. The simple phrase 'This autumn is different now' somewhat emphasizes the change in life. Through this 'autumn today' portrait, the country appears vast, expansive with the spaciousness of 'hills' and 'bamboo forests.' Standing amidst that land, people cannot help but feel joyful, excited to be masters of destiny, masters of the land and rivers:
'This sky here belongs to us
These mountains and forests belong to us
The fragrant fields stretch far and wide
The spacious roads branch out in all directions
The rivers flow red with heavy silt
The phrase 'this is' combined with the method of enumeration has contributed to emphasizing the vastness and grandeur of Vietnam's mountains and rivers. No longer just an individual 'I,' now it has become 'we' - the collective 'us' of the community. The passage resembles an epic song. That anthem is sung by a heart devoted to the motherland.
Defining the nation, Nguyen Dinh Thi believes:
'Our country
The land of those who have never bowed'
Not in terms of geographical location, the poet gently affirms that Vietnam is the land of heroes. A country where generation after generation, lifetime after lifetime, is ready to sacrifice blood and bone to defend the homeland and territory. Thus, the tradition of bravery and indomitability always flows in the blood of those 'with red blood and yellow skin,' 'descendants of the Lac and Hong.'
Confronting the enemy, our people are deeply resentful and filled with hatred:
'Oh, the rural fields flowing with blood
Barbed wire pierces the evening sky
In the long nights of marching, simmering
Suddenly, anxious, remembering the eyes of a loved one
Describing the pain during the years of fire and smoke, the poet creatively crafted many images like 'rural fields flowing with blood,' 'bowl of rice soaked in tears,' 'one crushing the other, skinning each other.' From there, emphasizing the cruelty, the brutality of the enemy, and evoking the plight of the nation. The poetic tone, sharp and resolute, as if to overwhelm the enemy.
Faced with difficulties and hardships, the people never give up. Instead, they stand up bravely to fight:
'Sunny days chase after rainy nights
Every step on the road is a sacrifice
Brows ablaze, imagining a new heaven and earth
Our hearts brim with the light of dawn
A series of words like 'shining up', 'bursting up', 'uncontrollable', 'unshootable', 'rising up' used in the following verses have highlighted the resilient and indomitable spirit of our people. The feelings of resentment and love for the country are the strength, cheering on courageous people in battle.
Finally, the poem concludes with an endless beautiful image:
'Vietnam rises from blood and fire
Shaking off mud, standing tall and bright'
From pain, from sacrifice and loss, Vietnam rises proudly, shedding mud and shining brightly. Thus, Nguyen Dinh Thi skillfully erects a towering monument to the nation on the backdrop of blood and fire, on the space where 'guns shake the sky.'
Alongside its remarkable theme, we cannot overlook the unique artistic features. With rich evocative language, harmonious blending of lyrical and argumentative tones, and the use of comparison, metaphor, and enumeration, the poet successfully expresses the inspiration of national pride and praise.
'The Homeland' will always stand out as a work on the theme of love for the homeland. The images of autumn landscapes or the nation's resilience always leave a deep impression on the reader's mind. Through this, I grow even more fond and proud of this beloved S-shaped land.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - END - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
We hope that the sample essay content for 10th grade above will help you grasp the key points of the poems 'Island Soldiers Singing Love Songs on the Island' and 'The Country.' To improve your writing skills, you can practice at home with similar essay types such as:
- Analysis of 'The Apricot Blossom Season'
- Analysis of 'Walking in the Fragrant Tram Forest'
