Buzz
Classic children's stories offer young readers their first adventure into a magical universe where wonders unfold and anything can occur. These tales encourage children worldwide to embrace their imagination and understand that, in the end, good triumphs over evil (well, most of the time, at least). It's no wonder these stories have lasted through the years and continue to be shared with new generations.
Many adults have let their imaginations run wild over the stories they cherished as children. If you grew up with timeless bedtime stories or their movie versions, the following fan theories might just make you reconsider them in a new light.
10. 'Snow White'
'Snow White' stands as a classic fairy tale that has captivated children worldwide for generations. It's a touching narrative about true love that sparked the creation of the TV show Once Upon A Time and inspired various musicals and theatrical performances. It also became the first Disney movie, featuring a fictional female protagonist.
Naturally, this tale has spawned numerous fan theories. Among them, the darkest theory suggests that Prince Charming may not be what he appears (as Snow White's true love and all). According to this theory, he is actually Death, who kisses Snow White to rescue her from the brink of death and leads her directly to Heaven.
The evidence supporting this theory lies in the moment Snow White flees in fear from the prince when she first encounters him by the wishing well. It's thought to symbolize her first encounter with, and escape from, Death, as she was near the well when he appeared.
9. The BFG
It took 34 years for The BFG to finally receive its well-deserved Disney adaptation, transforming into an enchanting fantasy adventure. Mark Rylance brought the much-loved giant to life, perfectly capturing his unique language. Frobscottle, anyone?
Given the uniqueness of The BFG, numerous fan theories have emerged. One such theory, shared on Reddit, suggests that the young boy who lived with the BFG before Sophie arrived (and was eaten by the other giants) was actually a member of the British royal family. The theory is based on the fact that the boy had a portrait of Queen Elizabeth II in his room and wore a royal-style red coat with black and gold trim.
Another Reddit theory proposes that the ending of the story is merely a dream sequence, as the BFG decides to let Sophie sleep and dream for eternity rather than face the dangers of Giant Country or live alone as an orphan.
8. The Little Mermaid
By now, you've likely heard the theory suggesting that Elsa and Anna's parents are also Tarzan's parents and that their shipwreck was later discovered by Ariel and Flounder, right? Well, the fan theories surrounding the timeless tale of 'The Little Mermaid,' originally penned by Hans Christian Andersen, seem to be endless.
The latest theory connects the story to Aurora from Sleeping Beauty. It is believed that Aurora and Prince Phillip could be the royal ancestors of Ariel’s Prince Eric. The evidence? It is said that if you pause the movie at the scene showing Eric’s castle, you can spot a portrait of Aurora on the wall.
7. Peter Pan
For some reason, a happy fan theory just doesn’t seem to exist for Peter Pan. The tale is meant to be a whimsical fairy tale about a boy who never grows up and can fly. He spends his eternal childhood in Neverland with the Lost Boys, having a series of exciting adventures.
One unsettling theory suggests that if we take the quote from the book, 'Peter thins them out,' literally, it implies that Peter took matters into his own hands and ended the lives of the Lost Boys once they grew too old.
An even darker theory proposes that Peter Pan wasn't actually alive. Rather, he was an angel who descended to Earth whenever a child was dying, taking their hand and flying with them to Neverland, which was actually Heaven. This would explain why they never aged: they were already dead.
6. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, a beloved classic by Roald Dahl, has always sparked its share of controversy, even before fan theories gained traction. While intended as a children's book and later adapted into a film, some of its darker themes prompted parents to pay closer attention to what their children were watching.
As expected, a few dark theories emerged. One suggests that Willy Wonka secretly bribed the candy store manager, Bill, to ensure that Charlie received the last golden ticket. When Charlie asked for a chocolate bar for his grandfather, Bill conveniently handed him the display chocolate, guaranteeing he got the one with the golden ticket. Dark? Maybe not so much.
Another theory ties the classic story to Dante's Inferno, in which a man journeys through the various levels of Hell. The poem includes a ferryman who transports souls from the mortal world to the afterlife, placing them into one of the nine circles of Hell based on their sins.
In the film, the children are taken on a boat ride through the factory, with each one receiving punishment for their transgressions (such as turning into a blueberry for stealing). Additionally, just like Dante ascends from Hell in the poem, Charlie rises into the sky in a glass elevator at the conclusion of Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory.
5. Anne of Green Gables
Anne of Green Gables was first published in 1908 and has since inspired numerous sequels, TV movies, musicals, stage productions, and feature films. The beloved story follows a redheaded orphan girl who is sent to live with a middle-aged brother and sister to help with their farm. However, they initially wanted a boy. Over time, they change their minds, and Anne Shirley’s coming-of-age journey begins.
One popular theory suggests that Anne was first in love with her best friend, Diana Barry, before eventually falling for Gilbert Blythe, whom she eventually married. This theory proposes that Anne is bisexual and never truly let go of her first love. The theory is supported by several instances in the book where the two girls have a deep bond and are heartbroken when Diana’s mother forbids their friendship. One memorable quote is: “If you love me as I love you, nothing but death can part us two.”
4. Little Women
Building upon the Anne theory, another fan hypothesis suggests that Jo March from Little Women was not simply a tomboy, but a lesbian. In the story, Jo enjoys dressing in men's clothes and has no romantic interest in the boy next door who is enamored with her, preferring only friendship. It is also believed that Louisa May Alcott herself revealed through interviews that she had an attraction to women, stating that she may have been mistakenly born into a woman’s body because she had a “man’s soul” and was drawn to beautiful girls, not men.
Jo also remarks in the book that Laurie is the type of boy she would wish to resemble if it were possible. She confesses that she feels something is wrong with her and expresses her belief that she will never quite belong anywhere.
3. The Magical World of Harry Potter began in 1997 when J.K. Rowling introduced the first book in the now legendary series. By 2013, the franchise had sold over 500 million copies worldwide, cementing its place as the best-selling book series of all time. The books were also adapted into a series of hugely successful films.
The Harry Potter story began in 1997, and its impact was immediate. By 2013, the first book and its sequels had sold over half a billion copies. The stories' success transcended the written word and evolved into blockbuster films, further solidifying their status as the best-selling book series ever.
One of the most unsettling fan theories suggests that J.K. Rowling intentionally created a horcrux for every book in the Harry Potter series. According to this theory, she poured her soul into every death scene, ensuring that the stories would live on eternally. This idea is said to explain the profound emotional impact that these death scenes have on readers.
2. Alice In Wonderland is a timeless classic that has enchanted readers with its whimsical world since its publication. Its influence spans generations, inspiring countless adaptations and interpretations.
In a similar vein to Christopher Robin, some believe that Alice in 'Alice's Adventures in Wonderland' may have been suffering from schizophrenia. Her calm demeanor in response to the talking White Rabbit is often interpreted as evidence of this mental condition.
A theory that has persisted since the 1960s suggests that the entire story of 'Alice in Wonderland' serves as an allegory for drug use. Supporters of this theory point to elements like the Cheshire Cat, who leaves behind only a grin, Alice's consumption of strange potions and mushrooms, and the caterpillar puffing on a water pipe as proof. Fans have even noted the reference to red pills and Wonderland in 'The Matrix,' which further supports this interpretation.
1. Winnie-the-Pooh
Who doesn’t adore the beloved characters from Winnie-the-Pooh, especially Eeyore with his melancholy demeanor? The character of Winnie was inspired by the author’s son’s cherished teddy bear, which is currently on display at the New York Public Library.
Naturally, a theory arose to cast a darker, more bizarre twist on this heartwarming tale of Christopher Robin and his friends. According to this theory, all the charming characters are mere figments of Christopher Robin’s imagination, each symbolizing a different form of mental illness.
What were once innocent animal companions now represent deeper psychological struggles: Winnie embodies an eating disorder, Eeyore mirrors depression, Piglet personifies anxiety, Tigger reflects ADHD, Owl stands for narcissism, and Rabbit showcases OCD. Furthermore, it’s suggested that Christopher Robin himself suffers from schizophrenia. A far cry from a cheerful conclusion.
