Buzz
Not every filmmaker achieves a Citizen Kane with their first project. Every legendary director has a starting point, and some of the most celebrated names in cinema faced years of struggle before delivering their masterpieces. Meanwhile, others struck gold with their very first attempt.
This list features a blend of both scenarios. While these directors may not have been at their artistic peak, their initial efforts remain standout pieces in their filmography. These movies prove the timeless saying: Persistence pays off.
10. Bad Taste (1987) Director: Peter Jackson
Peter Jackson, renowned for The Lord of the Rings series, has cemented his status as a contemporary fantasy maestro. His meticulous attention to detail brought J.R.R. Tolkien’s legendary tale to life, with every aspect of Frodo’s journey meticulously designed to enhance the narrative. Even with a budget far smaller than that of Rings, Jackson managed to deliver another equally captivating story.
Bad Taste is a campy sci-fi flick where aliens invade New Zealand to turn humans into the main ingredient for a galactic fast-food chain. Produced on a shoestring budget of $25,000, the film cut costs by featuring Jackson and his friends in most of the roles.
The limited budget was allocated to creating outrageous body horror effects. Brains ooze from cracked skulls, and intestines burst in a manner reminiscent of slapstick comedy.
Bad Taste doesn’t aim for depth. Instead, it revels in the chaotic fun of obliterating human-eating aliens with chainsaws and rocket launchers. This B-movie absurdity carries a unique, endearing charm.
9. This Is The Life (2008) Director: Ava DuVernay
Ava DuVernay’s films are deeply rooted in real-world narratives. Through works like Selma, When They See Us, and 13th, she has consistently explored African-American history to uncover gripping tales. This storytelling approach was first refined in her documentary This Is the Life.
According to This Is the Life, hip-hop culture largely emerged from a single location: Los Angeles’ Good Life Cafe, also known as the Good Life Health Food Centre. Before becoming a filmmaker, DuVernay was a regular at the cafe’s open mic nights, where she connected with numerous aspiring rappers.
In the 1990s, future legends such as Ice Cube, Snoop Dogg, will.i.am, Common, and Lenny Kravitz honed their craft at these open mic events. The venue served as a creative hub for these rising stars to develop their talents. The documentary offers a firsthand account of one of the most significant cultural movements of the late 20th century.
8. Pushing Hands (1991) Director: Ang Lee
While Ang Lee is widely recognized in the West for his visually stunning films like Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, Hulk, and Life of Pi, which revolutionized special effects, he personally values his earlier, more intimate Taiwanese projects. These films, though quieter, carry just as much emotional and artistic weight.
Pushing Hands, co-written by Ang Lee and his frequent collaborator James Schamus, delves into a recurring theme in Lee’s work—the tension between familial obligations and personal responsibilities.
In Pushing Hands, Sihung Lung portrays Mr. Chu, a retired tai chi instructor who relocates to America with his son, Alex (Bo Z. Wang). The film explores the classic fish-out-of-water scenario as the traditional Chinese father grapples with adapting to American culture, causing friction within the family. Alex finds himself torn between his loyalty to his father and his responsibilities to his wife (Deb Snyder).
Lee’s skillful direction ensures the story remains nuanced, avoiding stereotypes. The film balances humor with poignant moments, offering a heartfelt reflection on the bonds and obligations that tie families together.
Lee and Sihung Lung revisited this theme in subsequent films like The Wedding Banquet and Eat Drink Man Woman. These three movies form the informal trilogy known as Father Knows Best.
7. Hard Eight (1996) Director: Paul Thomas Anderson
Hard Eight stands out in Paul Thomas Anderson’s filmography as the only work that feels like it could have been directed by someone else. Despite the surge of thrillers in the 1990s, the film remains a stark exploration of the pitfalls of gambling. Beyond its gripping tale of greed’s destructive power, it also captures Anderson in the process of defining his unique directorial style.
In Hard Eight, Anderson refined many of the elements that would become hallmarks of his later works. Signature traits such as unexpected plot twists, eccentric characters, and the harshness of fate first appeared here.
The film introduced three actors who would become recurring collaborators in Anderson’s career. The story primarily revolves around Philip Baker Hall as Sydney, an aging gambler, and John C. Reilly as John, his protégé. Philip Seymour Hoffman, another Anderson favorite, also makes a brief but memorable appearance.
Hard Eight also marked the beginning of Anderson’s collaborations with cinematographer Robert Elswit and composer Jon Brion. For both the characters and Anderson himself, the film was a journey of self-discovery. Within a few years, Anderson would establish one of the most distinctive filmographies of the 21st century.
6. I Wanna Hold Your Hand (1978) Director: Robert Zemeckis
Universal Pictures initially opposed Robert Zemeckis directing this film. The 26-year-old newcomer secured the role solely due to the support of Hollywood prodigy Steven Spielberg, who assured the studio he would step in if Zemeckis faltered. However, Spielberg never needed to intervene.
Instead, Zemeckis discovered the winning theme that would define his career: nostalgia.
Similar to Marty McFly in Back to the Future or Forrest Gump in his titular film, the characters in I Wanna Hold Your Hand inadvertently influence pivotal moments in history. The story revolves around six New Jersey teens desperate to secure tickets for The Beatles’ debut performance on The Ed Sullivan Show.
Driven by their obsession with the band, the group embarks on outrageous adventures to catch a glimpse of their idols. The film playfully bends reality for comedic effect. Much like Who Framed Roger Rabbit, Zemeckis crafts a heartfelt homage to 20th-century pop culture icons, blending humor and charm. While he achieved greater fame later, his debut remains his most sincere celebration of the past.
5. Medicine For Melancholy (2008) Director: Barry Jenkins
On the surface, Medicine For Melancholy is a love story. It follows two individuals exploring the city after a one-night stand, suggesting that a meaningful connection can emerge from a fleeting encounter.
However, this isn’t your typical romantic tale. By the film’s conclusion, there’s no certainty the pair will reunite or pursue a future together. Instead, the movie captures two people savoring each other’s presence, uncertain of what lies ahead.
The film transcends genre constraints to explore deeper themes, particularly the intersection of race and modern dating. Much like the relationship it portrays, Medicine For Melancholy leaves many questions unanswered, inviting reflection.
The movie’s authenticity is its greatest strength, feeling organic and unforced. Jenkins’s subsequent work, Moonlight, achieved even greater acclaim by masterfully balancing societal commentary with a tender love story, earning him an Oscar for Best Picture.
4. Targets (1968) Director: Peter Bogdanovich
Technically, Peter Bogdanovich’s directorial debut was Voyage to the Planet of Prehistoric Women, but the film was so poorly received that he disowned it, crediting it to the pseudonym Derek Thomas. He chose Targets as the first film to carry his name, a decision that proved to be the right one.
Targets serves as both a tribute to classic horror and a precursor to the genre’s evolution. Boris Karloff, in his final leading role, plays an aging horror star lamenting the decline of traditional movie monsters. His narrative runs parallel to Tim O’Kelly’s portrayal of a sniper on a killing rampage.
The two storylines eventually intersect when Karloff’s character faces the sniper at a drive-in theater showing one of his films. While Karloff triumphs in the movie, O’Kelly’s character symbolizes a darker, more enduring reality.
Released shortly after the assassinations of Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy, the film initially struggled at the box office. Over time, however, it has been re-evaluated and is now regarded as an early blueprint for the slasher genre that would dominate horror in later decades.
3. Ascenseur Pour L’echafaud (1958) Director: Louis Malle
Ascenseur pour l’echafaud (Elevator to the Gallows) marked the dawn of the French New Wave. Louis Malle, at just 24, introduced the movement’s defining features—intricate narratives, intimate cinematography, and precise editing.
The film’s blend of young lovers and a botched murder scheme became a hallmark of the genre. Beyond its technical innovations, Ascenseur pour l’echafaud launched Jeanne Moreau into stardom.
The film’s most enduring legacy may be its groundbreaking soundtrack by Miles Davis. The jazz icon improvised the score after a brief plot summary, with the music later synchronized to the scenes. This innovative approach set the stage for modal jazz’s rise in the 1960s.
Ascenseur pour l’echafaud revolutionized cinema, leaving an indelible mark on both its visual and auditory storytelling.
2. The Connection (1961) Director: Shirley Clarke
Few films have sparked as much controversy upon release as The Connection. It polarized audiences, with everyone forming strong opinions. However, after just two screenings, authorities arrested the projectionist and closed the theater. The film gained notoriety in art house circles as one of the most banned movies of its time, though by modern standards, its content seems relatively mild.
The Connection stunned viewers with its bold subject matter and unconventional presentation. Adapted from Jack Gelber’s play of the same name, the film depicts a group of jazz musicians and heroin addicts as they share introspective monologues while awaiting their next dose.
Unflinchingly honest about the dangers of heroin addiction, the movie was laced with profanity, a choice deemed scandalous in the early 1960s. Equally groundbreaking was its jazz soundtrack, which mirrored the raw, experimental nature of the narrative. Though few saw it upon release, those who did hailed it as one of cinema’s most influential works.
1. They Live By Night (1948) Director: Nicholas Ray
It takes exceptional skill to invent a new genre with a debut film. While deeply rooted in noir, They Live by Night is now recognized as a trailblazer for the lovers-on-the-run trope.
Adapted from Edward Anderson’s novel Thieves Like Us, the film popularized the trope of a naive woman (Cathy O’Donnell) drawn into a life of crime by a charismatic outlaw (Farley Granger). Its narrative framework heavily influenced Arthur Penn’s groundbreaking Bonnie and Clyde in 1967 and Robert Altman’s 1974 adaptation of the same novel, Thieves Like Us.
Even without spawning countless imitations, They Live By Night stands as a poignant exploration of life on the fringes. Rather than focusing on graphic violence, the film delves into the existential anxiety of having nowhere to turn. Ray’s empathy for the marginalized reached its pinnacle seven years later with the timeless classic Rebel Without a Cause.
