Buzz
The purpose of art conservation is to protect historical masterpieces for future generations, yet there are times when these well-meaning efforts result in catastrophic outcomes. Whether caused by insufficient expertise, hasty decisions, or outright negligence, certain restoration projects have rendered artworks irreparably damaged or completely altered. These incidents serve as stark reminders that art conservation demands not only technical skill but also a deep reverence for the original piece.
This compilation explores ten infamous art restoration blunders, showcasing the errors that transformed priceless cultural artifacts into lessons in what not to do.
10. The Melting Murillo: The Immaculate Conception (Spain, 2020)
Bartolomé Esteban Murillo’s The Immaculate Conception of Los Venerables is a revered 17th-century painting portraying the Virgin Mary. In 2020, an untrained furniture restorer in Spain was tasked with cleaning the artwork. The outcome was a disaster. Following two botched attempts to “restore” the Virgin Mary’s face, the painting became unrecognizable, appearing more like a crude, blurry sketch than Murillo’s refined and intricate work.
The incident ignited widespread anger and mockery, with many likening it to the notorious Ecce Homo restoration (featured later in this list). Specialists criticized the absence of regulation in Spain’s art restoration sector, where untrained individuals frequently handle priceless cultural treasures. Murillo’s painting ultimately needed comprehensive professional restoration, underscoring the dangers of placing masterpieces in unqualified hands.
9. The Overcleaned Sistine Chapel Ceiling (Italy, 1980s)
Michelangelo’s Sistine Chapel ceiling, created in the early 16th century, stands as one of the most celebrated achievements in Western art. From 1980 to 1994, a large-scale restoration effort sought to remove centuries of dirt and soot from the frescoes. Although the project revived the artwork’s vivid colors, detractors argue that it erased some of Michelangelo’s original nuances, especially his delicate use of light and shadow, known as chiaroscuro.
Certain art historians contend that excessive cleaning compromised the masterpiece’s intended depth and texture. They also assert that the restoration team overused chemical solvents, causing irreversible harm to sections of the fresco. While the Vatican maintains that the project was essential for preserving Michelangelo’s legacy, the debate continues to divide art experts, illustrating the fine balance between conservation and alteration.
8. The Overpainted Last Supper (Italy, 18th Century)
Leonardo da Vinci’s The Last Supper is a Renaissance icon, yet it has endured centuries of deterioration from environmental factors and earlier restoration efforts. The most damaging was an 18th-century attempt by artist Giuseppe Mazza, who sought to “repair” the fresco by overpainting Leonardo’s original creation.
Mazza employed oil paints instead of tempera, which not only masked Leonardo’s intricate brushstrokes but also accelerated the fresco’s decay. The overpainting faced widespread condemnation and was later removed in subsequent restorations, but the harm was permanent. Modern methods have since preserved the painting, yet much of Leonardo’s original brilliance remains lost, making The Last Supper a stark reminder of restoration failures.
7. The Waxing of the Parthenon Sculptures (England, 1937)
In 1937, staff at the British Museum initiated a contentious cleaning project on the Parthenon Marbles (also called the Elgin Marbles). Using wire brushes, abrasive tools, and acid, they aimed to remove centuries of dirt, believing they were revealing the sculptures’ original appearance. Instead, they stripped away the valuable patina, causing irreversible harm to the surfaces.
Art historians later labeled the cleaning a “disaster,” arguing that it undermined the Marbles’ historical authenticity. This incident continues to fuel debates over the Marbles’ ownership, with Greece pointing to the flawed restoration as proof of Britain’s inadequate stewardship of these ancient artifacts.
6. The Dimmed Rembrandt: The Night Watch (Netherlands, 1940s)
Rembrandt’s The Night Watch is a celebrated Dutch treasure, but a restoration effort in the 1940s led to unexpected harm. In an attempt to “enhance” the painting, conservators applied a heavy coat of varnish, which later darkened, masking many of the artwork’s intricate details.
Subsequent attempts to strip the varnish resulted in surface abrasions, further erasing Rembrandt’s original strokes. This sparked outrage among art enthusiasts and underscored the risks of aggressive restoration methods. Today, The Night Watch is meticulously monitored, with contemporary conservators employing advanced techniques to safeguard it from additional harm.
5. The Frankenstein Mummy (Egypt, 19th Century)
During the 19th century, early Egyptologists experimented with various methods to preserve mummies. One notable failure involved a mummy from the British Museum, which was treated with paraffin wax to strengthen its fragile bindings. Although the wax initially seemed effective, it eventually caused the wrappings to decay, resulting in permanent damage to parts of the artifact.
This case highlights the trial-and-error methods of early conservation, where good intentions often led to unintended damage. Modern conservators now use non-invasive approaches, but past errors remain a stark reminder of the dangers of experimenting with priceless artifacts.
4. The “Cartoonish” St. George Statue (Spain, 2018)
In 2018, a 16th-century wooden statue of St. George at the Church of San Miguel de Estella in Spain became the center of a restoration disaster. A local crafts teacher, inexperienced in art conservation, was tasked with restoring the statue of St. George slaying a dragon. The outcome was a crude, overly bright repaint, with the saint’s face rendered in unnatural colors and lacking the original’s intricate details. Art historians and conservationists decried the irreversible loss of the statue’s historical and artistic value.
The incident underscored the risks of ignoring proper conservation procedures. Critics blamed the church and local officials for not consulting qualified experts and disregarding heritage preservation laws. The controversy also sparked global debates about safeguarding cultural treasures, especially in smaller communities with limited resources and conservation knowledge. The restoration drew widespread mockery and comparisons to the 2012 “Ecce Homo” debacle. While some hoped the backlash would promote better funding and training for restoration, others grieved the permanent loss of a historical masterpiece.
3. The Damaged Rockefeller Picasso: Le Tricorne (USA, 2014)
Pablo Picasso’s Le Tricorne, a painted stage curtain from 1919, became the focus of a major controversy in 2014 after sustaining damage during its relocation from New York’s Four Seasons Restaurant to the New York Historical Society. The massive curtain, standing over 20 feet (6 meters) tall, had been a cherished feature of the restaurant for years, serving as both a decorative highlight and a testament to modern art’s presence in public spaces. When the building’s management decided to move the artwork for renovations, experts cautioned about the challenges of transporting such a delicate piece.
These warnings proved accurate when Le Tricorne was torn during the move due to careless handling and insufficient equipment. The art community was outraged, with critics blaming the movers and property owners for negligence. Although the curtain was later restored, some areas suffered irreversible damage, reducing the artwork’s historical and cultural significance. The incident sparked renewed discussions about the obligations of private owners in protecting public art and underscored the risks of mishandling large, fragile masterpieces.
2. The “Potato Head” Jesus: Ecce Homo (Spain, 2012)
In 2012, a fresco of Jesus Christ titled Ecce Homo, created by 19th-century artist Elías García Martínez, gained global attention after a botched restoration by an amateur. The fresco, located in the Sanctuary of Mercy church in Borja, Spain, was a humble yet respected depiction of Christ. Cecilia Giménez, an elderly parishioner with no formal training, attempted to restore the deteriorating artwork. The result was a comically distorted image, often compared to a “Potato Head” or “Monkey Jesus,” which drew widespread ridicule.
Despite the mockery, the botched restoration unexpectedly turned Borja into a tourist hotspot, with visitors eager to see the infamous fresco. While it became a source of internet humor and a cautionary tale in the art world, the incident also raised serious concerns about allowing untrained individuals to handle culturally significant works. Experts noted that professional restoration could have preserved the fresco, but now it remains permanently altered, albeit with an oddly endearing quality.
1. The Flaking Vermeer: The Girl with the Pearl Earring (Netherlands, 1990s)
Johannes Vermeer’s The Girl with the Pearl Earring is a globally cherished masterpiece, but a 1990s restoration sparked debate among art experts. The goal was to remove centuries of varnish and dirt that had dulled Vermeer’s vibrant colors and intricate details. While the cleaning restored the painting’s original radiance, it also posed new risks. Some specialists noted micro-flaking in areas like the girl’s face and the famous pearl earring, attributing it to the solvents used during the process.
Critics also contended that the restoration might have removed glaze layers applied by Vermeer, subtly changing the painting’s texture and depth. Though The Girl with the Pearl Earring remains an iconic work, the restoration sparked discussions about the ethics of prioritizing visual appeal over historical authenticity. This case underscores the delicate balance between preserving fragile artworks and meeting the expectations of contemporary audiences and museums.
