Buzz
For years, psychopathy has been a recurring theme in popular culture. Whether seen in movies, books, or TV shows, we are constantly exposed to the concept of psychopaths, both in fictional and real-world contexts.
The media often presents psychopaths as cold, calculating figures who lack moral judgment. In many depictions, they are seen as pure evil, unworthy of any empathy.
While it's true that psychopaths are wired differently from most people, not all of them fit the sinister mold of characters like Hannibal Lecter from The Silence of the Lambs. Today, we'll explore the truth about psychopaths—it's not what you might think.
10. Absence of Empathy
Psychopaths are often portrayed as cold, alien beings who exist beyond societal norms. This is the common stereotype of psychopaths created by popular culture. Most people wouldn’t typically describe a psychopath as a compassionate individual.
Consider Hannibal Lecter, for example. As he callously slaughtered and devoured his victims, it was clear he had no regard for their suffering. However, to claim that psychopaths are incapable of empathy is not entirely accurate.
The truth is that psychopaths possess an empathy switch. This metaphorical switch in their minds can be turned on or off, or adjusted in intensity, at their discretion. External factors can also affect how this switch operates.
For most individuals, experiencing empathy is an instinctive response—it happens naturally. However, for psychopaths, empathy doesn’t come by default; it is more of a voluntary, conscious decision they make.
When they choose to show empathy, they can switch on their charm and do so effortlessly. This is often a tactic for their personal gain. After achieving their objective, the empathetic switch is promptly turned off.
Psychopaths fully understand what empathy is, but for them, it takes a considerable effort to feel it. Experiencing empathy is like being physically restrained. Once those restraints are released, that’s when the stereotypical psychopaths from popular culture emerge.
9. Psychopaths Aren’t Always Manic Men
There’s a reason the majority of psychopaths in pop culture are men. This is because psychopathy predominantly manifests in men. Female psychopaths are much less commonly depicted.
Part of this is due to the fact that women generally possess higher levels of empathy compared to men. Women tend to be more concerned with moral issues and the well-being of others. As a result, female psychopaths typically score much lower on the PCL-R (psychopathy checklist) than their male counterparts.
Although there has been limited research on female psychopaths, extensive studies have focused on male psychopathy, particularly within prison populations. Psychopaths in these settings are predominantly male.
It is also widely believed that psychopathy in women tends to emerge later in life. It may develop due to jealousy, manipulation, and tumultuous relationships—issues often encountered during adulthood. This form of psychopathy is linked to relational aggression, in contrast to the covert aggression typically seen in male psychopaths.
8. A Psychopath’s Way of Thinking Cannot Be Changed
Think about the psychopaths you’ve encountered in popular culture. Do you believe that sitting down with them and asking them to be more empathetic would have any impact?
Chances are, they would just mock you and disregard your words. Even if they did absorb some of what you said, it would likely have little to no effect. In fact, the idea that it could work seems absurd.
However, there is a study that demonstrates it is indeed possible. Whether psychopaths consciously or unconsciously choose to feel empathy, encouraging them to be more empathetic can actually lead them to become more empathetic.
A team of Dutch scientists conducted an experiment with 21 psychopaths, showing them videos of violent crimes, people in distress, and individuals in conflict. The brain activity of the participants was measured, revealing that the motor, somatosensory, and emotional regions of their brains were less active compared to nonpsychopathic individuals.
Afterward, the participants were instructed to try to empathize more with the individuals shown in the videos. This resulted in an increase in brain activity, to the point where it became difficult to differentiate between the brain scans of the psychopathic and nonpsychopathic participants.
Instead of keeping Hannibal Lecter confined, maybe simply telling him to be more empathetic would have been a more effective approach.
7. The Case for Insanity
In popular culture, psychopathic maniacs are often depicted as murderers capable of committing the most heinous crimes. These characters, usually portrayed in horror films and psychological thrillers, are thrust upon us, leaving lasting impressions that shape our understanding of what a psychopath truly is.
While some individuals undeniably fit this portrayal, most would consider them insane. However, the majority of psychopaths are not psychotic. They maintain full control over their mental faculties, understanding right from wrong. What sets them apart is their lack of emotional involvement, which makes it easier for them to make unethical choices and engage in criminal behavior.
The American Psychiatric Association classifies psychopathy as a personality disorder, not an insanity disorder. Nonetheless, philosophers and neuroscientists have argued for the possibility of allowing insanity pleas in these cases. Despite this, the law does not recognize psychopaths as legally insane, even though it’s difficult to accept that the psychopaths we see in movies are not actually insane.
6. Psychopathic Traits Are What Define a Psychopath
The term 'psychopath' is being used far too casually these days. It seems that anyone who commits even a minor wrongdoing gets labeled a psychopath. And it's not just killers we're talking about.
Iconic characters from popular media—like Dr. House from the show named after him or Dr. Cox from the medical comedy Scrubs—have been called psychopaths by many. Their poor social skills, overblown self-esteem, arrogance, and other traits made people believe they were afflicted with this personality disorder.
While these characters certainly displayed some traits that could show up on the PCL-R checklist, that doesn't necessarily mean they are psychopaths. In fact, most of us might check off a few boxes on the PCL-R list. It's not a cause for panic.
The Society for the Scientific Study of Psychopathy defines psychopathy as a 'constellation of traits.' So don't fall for the trend of labeling anyone you don't like as a psychopath. Just because someone does something wrong doesn't make them a psychopath.
5. Criminals Are Psychopaths
In films and TV shows, it seems like every person who ends up in jail is automatically assumed to be a psychopath. This has contributed to the perception that prisons are filled with psychopathic individuals.
It’s true that many prisoners suffer from some sort of personality disorder, often due to violent and antisocial behaviors. However, these traits don’t necessarily indicate psychopathy.
Around 75% of incarcerated individuals are diagnosed with a personality disorder. However, only about 16% of US prisoners can be classified as psychopaths. Therefore, criminal behavior and psychopathy are not inherently linked.
4. They Possess No Emotion
Psychopaths are portrayed as cold, calculated individuals with no emotional depth. This lack of emotion is often cited as the reason these characters from popular culture are capable of committing such crimes. It’s not just a matter of not having empathy; they seem to be devoid of all emotions, including positive ones like love.
When Hannibal Lecter developed psychopathy, he struggled to form any emotional connections. Instead, he took pleasure in manipulating people’s minds, simply for his own entertainment. Naturally, he also had a taste for their organs.
This doesn’t imply that psychopaths are devoid of emotions, though. That would suggest a completely different personality disorder. True psychopaths, those on the extreme end of the spectrum, tend to have difficulty experiencing emotions. However, certain events can trigger an emotional reaction.
For instance, the death of a loved one might prompt a psychopath to cry. A psychopath’s capacity for emotions largely depends on their individual score on the PCL-R checklist.
3. We All Know What The Term ‘Psychopath’ Means
The term “psychopath” is frequently used in popular culture, leading many to believe that medical professionals fully understand psychopathy. However, the term itself is actually vague and poorly defined.
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders doesn’t include psychopathy as a condition. The closest match is an antisocial behavioral disorder.
Despite the many well-known figures in popular culture who are labeled as psychopaths, this isn’t a medically recognized diagnosis. A more precise diagnosis would be an antisocial personality disorder. Yes, this applies even to Hannibal Lecter.
2. Don’t Pay Heed To Other People’s Emotions
In popular culture, psychopaths seem to be able to commit their crimes because they lack any emotional awareness. In reality, however, they may not be in touch with their own emotions, but they are often better than most at reading the emotions of others.
Take Hannibal Lecter as an example. He could read people effortlessly. Although he was a psychiatrist, psychopaths in other fields can possess the same skill. They understand exactly how you feel—they just don’t care. This ability makes them charming, as they know exactly how to manipulate your emotions. It also makes them dangerous, shrewd individuals.
1. Always Content
In popular culture, psychopaths always seem unfazed. Even after committing heinous crimes, they’re rarely shown feeling regret or emotional distress. They give off the impression that they’re always in control, completely content with their actions and circumstances. Even when locked up in prison, they appear disturbingly at ease with life.
In reality, however, psychopaths can experience sadness, though they may not feel emotions the same way others do. They are also capable of feeling depression. This is partly because they harbor a strong sense of entitlement. When things don’t go their way, that’s when their criminal behavior often emerges.
At times, committing crimes cannot solve all of their problems. Psychopaths are not always able to get what they want, which can lead to frustration and other mental health issues like depression. It may seem unusual, but depression is a common condition in certain types of psychopaths.
