Buzz
The Force might just be with this one, or maybe they had a few too many drinks and came up with a fan theory that defies reason. Okay, I might be a little harsh, but sometimes, no matter how deep your love for a franchise runs, these bizarre, far-fetched ideas can be, well, incredibly bizarre and far-fetched. From aggressive Ewoks to the wild theory of Jar Jar as a Sith Lord, there’s certainly no shortage of out-there fan theories for the “Star Wars” universe.
Here are 10 of the craziest Star Wars fan theories that will make you question everything.
10. Jar Jar Binks is the Real Villain of “Star Wars”
Lumpawarroo, a Reddit user, set out to make sense of Jar Jar Binks’s character. I mean, how much can one character endure? The Gungan is clumsy, awkward, perceived as racially insensitive, and an outcast—he’s a walking bundle of flaws (although, it is funny). Lumpawarroo’s theory is that Binks’s shortcomings are actually part of a bigger plot: he’s the true villain of Star Wars. If his flaws were fixed, the entire galaxy would be set on the right path again.
Mace Windu's gruff demeanor can be attributed to his jealousy, according to some interpretations. While he may come across as grumpy and dismissive of others, particularly Anakin, it's speculated that he is frustrated because he believes he should have been the Chosen One. This idea stems from his dismissive attitude and general arrogance.
Mace Windu's personality is far from warm. Known for his harsh, grumpy nature, he often comes across as a grumpy, condescending figure who looks down on younger generations. Despite this, his character stands out for his exceptional skills and the famous purple lightsaber. His complex persona juggles both his allegiance to the Jedi Order and his potential flirtation with the Dark Side.
One fan theory proposes that Mace Windu's constant grumpiness stems from his belief that he was meant to be the Chosen One, the one destined to destroy the Sith and restore balance to the Force. He doesn't trust Anakin’s potential, which aligns with his arrogant nature, suggesting he might be envious of Anakin's supposed destiny.
The crux of the argument lies in Windu's decision to attempt the assassination of Palpatine to bring balance to the Force, an action that highlights his desire to eliminate the Sith himself. Despite discovering Palpatine's true nature as a Sith Lord, Windu’s failure to succeed shows that he was not the Chosen One, even though he tried to act as if he was.
Rather than viewing Windu as a mere arrogant figure, one could argue he is simply superior in his abilities. He’s more perceptive than the majority of the Jedi, recognizing the danger of Palpatine long before most others. His actions may stem from pride, but they are driven by the belief that he alone was capable of bringing balance, proving his point despite the unfortunate outcome.
In *The Phantom Menace*, George Lucas may have slipped a playful jab at his friend Steven Spielberg. While such easter eggs are not uncommon in the world of filmmaking, this one might be a bit of a mix-up. During a scene where alien races are dismissing Chancellor Velorum, a group of aliens are said to bear a striking resemblance to E.T., the iconic extraterrestrial from Spielberg’s 1982 film. Given Lucas and Spielberg’s shared history, some fans believe this is a hidden reference to their directorial collaboration.
The theory might not be too far-fetched, as directors often hide easter eggs in their films. But perhaps this one was a case of mistaken identity. In *The Phantom Menace*, there’s a scene where alien races attempt to challenge Chancellor Velorum. Some fans think they spot a group of aliens who look just like E.T. from *E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial*. Considering the friendship between Spielberg and Lucas, many believe this could be a nod to their directorial bond.
7. Just because they share a resemblance…
In a more recent *Star Wars* movie, a theory surfaced that suggested Jyn Erso might be Rey's mother. However, there are several major issues with the timeline that make this theory impossible.
Jyn Erso appears in *Rogue One*, which, according to the timeline, occurs before *A New Hope*. If Erso were Rey's mother, this would imply that Rey would be 34 years old during *The Force Awakens*—a conclusion that doesn’t line up with the character’s actual age. While the two actresses do resemble each other, it's nothing more than a coincidence. Jyn is not Rey's mother, trust me.
In *The Rise of Skywalker*, British actress Jodie Comer makes a brief appearance as Rey’s mother. However, it turns out that Rey’s mother is essentially an unknown figure, a nobody in the grand scheme of things. On the other hand, Rey's father is revealed to be the son of none other than Palpatine himself. Rey’s parents, fearing for her safety due to her grandfather's influence, made the tough decision to abandon her, though Rey doesn't learn the truth until much later.
6. Snoke is Vader
No, Snoke is not Darth Vader. For those who need a refresher, Snoke is the Supreme Leader of the First Order, the figure who swayed Kylo Ren to embrace the dark side. Despite how far-fetched this idea might seem, the theory gained traction within the *Star Wars* universe itself.
The fan theory emerged from the suggestion that Palpatine’s spirit had been transferred into Vader’s body, which eventually morphed into Snoke. However, there’s a small problem with this theory—Luke burns Vader’s body at the end of *Return of the Jedi*. Looks like this one isn’t getting confirmed, *Star Wars*.
5. Could Snoke Be Luke’s Wife?
Can we please stop with the Snoke theories already? This one is really pushing the limits of believability. Sure, when there’s no solid origin story to go off of, people will grasp at anything that sounds good. But at this point, we actually have an origin story for Snoke, so let’s move on.
YouTuber Crazy Kahzmoh put forward the bizarre theory that Snoke is actually Luke’s spouse (or partner), and Rey is their daughter. Another variation of this theory suggests that Rey could be their adopted child. It's not the concept of Luke's sexuality that’s the issue here, but the fact that we already know this theory isn’t true. While we're all for some wild *Star Wars* ships, this one is downright ridiculous given what we've seen.
4. Snoke is Jar Jar Binks
This theory is a bit of a twist on the first one, but with a notable difference.
In this variation, Jar Jar Binks is secretly a highly skilled and powerful Force user who secretly works with the Sith before eventually becoming Snoke. Although this theory led to some fun *Darth Binks* fan art, it’s hard to take seriously. Sometimes, we just need to accept that Binks is simply a fool, and that’s all there is to his character. He wasn’t fooling anyone with his supposed intelligence, unlike Yoda’s subtle tricks in *Empire Strikes Back*. And the hologram trick with Palpatine in *The Force Awakens* didn’t have some deeper meaning either.
Snoke was a creation of Palpatine, designed to take charge in his absence and further his own dark agenda.
3. Darth Maul is still alive
Darth Maul is one of those characters who feels so unique, so cool, and honestly underrated. I mean, his face alone is iconic! This theory posits that Darth Maul, the vengeful Sith Lord, must still be alive simply because he was such a force to be reckoned with in *The Phantom Menace*. The guy was just too awesome to meet a simple death.
After all, he did manage to kill Qui-Gon Jinn. If anyone was going to take down the legendary Jedi, it had to be someone as fierce as Maul. But of course, Obi-Wan and Owen Lars are credited with ending Maul's life, so how could he possibly have survived that devastating head injury?
Hatred. Yes, let the hate flow through you.
Darth Maul was revealed to be alive in *The Clone Wars* after his brother found him with mechanical spider-like legs. While the design might have been unexpected, it definitely surprised the audience and gave the theorists a win. Maul’s deep hatred for Obi-Wan kept him going, even in his half-spider form.
2. The Jedi Aren’t as 'Good' as You’d Like to Believe
Sometimes, the most outlandish theories actually turn out to be true, and *Star Wars* is no stranger to this. For example, Palpatine created Snoke, Rey is a Palpatine, Boba Fett survived the Sarlacc pit, and more. But one theory dives deeper, challenging the ideas of right and wrong in the *Star Wars* universe.
When we think about the Jedi and the Sith, we often view it as good versus evil. This is because the protagonists are typically Jedi, and we naturally want to root for the heroes in adventure films. But is it really that simple? The Jedi may not be as heroic as we assume (thanks to Anakin), and honestly, who can blame him for questioning their actions?
First off, the Jedi operate much like a *Star Wars* mafia. They offer 'protection,' but it comes with a heavy political agenda. They don’t tolerate opposition to the Republic and want the Jedi Order to control the political system. It’s their way or the highway. Additionally, their methods are extreme. They take children from their families and force them through dangerous, grueling training. Qui-Gon even entered young Anakin in a deadly pod race just for some materials.
Third, and perhaps the most convincing piece of evidence for this theory comes directly from Luke Skywalker himself. In *The Last Jedi*, he tells Rey that a Jedi’s pride leads to their demise and that it’s time for them to fade away.
1. Luke Didn’t Blow Up the Death Star
We all know Luke destroyed the Death Star. Relying on the Force, he shot two proton torpedoes into the reactor core, and boom, the Death Star was gone! But one Reddit user shared a theory that suggests something else entirely. According to this theory, the Stormtroopers are the real culprits.
Much like their inability to hit anything, the Stormtroopers apparently also struggle with pressing the right buttons. This theory points to the moment right before the explosion when the Stormtroopers say, 'Standby.' Yep, it was the Stormtroopers who took down the Death Star. Maybe it was the guy who bumped his head on the door frame.
