Buzz
Medieval movies have always been a personal favorite of mine, which is why I was excited to create this list. However, during my research, I was astonished to find how few films truly capture historical accuracy. This list includes 9 movies, though I initially aimed for 10. The Medieval era, spanning from the 6th to the 16th century, is the focus here. While none of these films are entirely flawless in their historical portrayal, they stand out as the most accurate within the genre. You won’t find films like *A Knight’s Tale* here.
9. Henry V 1989, Kenneth Branagh
King Henry V of England (Kenneth Branagh) faces an insult from the King of France, prompting him to lead his army into battle. Throughout the campaign, the young king grapples with his soldiers' declining morale and his own internal uncertainties. The story reaches its climax during the brutal Battle of Agincourt. Adapted from Shakespeare’s renowned play, this film features stunningly realistic battle sequences.
Purchase this DVD on Amazon
8. The Name of the Rose 1986, Jean-Jacques Annaud
In 1327, a Benedictine Abbey is thrown into chaos following an unexplained death, leading the monks to believe the apocalypse is near. As the Abbey prepares to host a council debating the Franciscan Order’s stance on the Church renouncing wealth, William of Baskerville, a renowned Franciscan monk, is called upon to investigate the death. This film masterfully portrays the internal struggles of the Franciscan Order during this period and, true to Umberto Eco’s style, is meticulously researched.
Get this DVD on Amazon
7. The Message 1976, Moustapha Akkad
This historical epic delves into the origins of Islam, chronicling the life of Mohammed. In line with Islamic traditions, Mohammed is neither seen nor heard, as depicting him physically is considered sacrilegious. Set in 7th century Mecca, the story follows Mohammed's divine encounter with the Angel Gabriel, who instructs him to guide the people of Mecca to abandon the 300 idols of Kaaba and embrace the worship of a single, omnipotent God.
Purchase this DVD on Amazon
6. El Cid 1961, Anthony Mann
This cinematic masterpiece tells the tale of Rodrigo Diaz, revered as 'El Cid' by his admirers. A paragon of honor, he skillfully leads the charge to expel the Moors from Spain. Although certain elements, like the rallying cry for Spain's victory, may seem anachronistic given the era's political landscape, the film stands out for its remarkably authentic depiction of the Crusades period.
Purchase this DVD on Amazon
5. Andrei Rublev 1969, Andrei Tarkovsky
Andrei Rublev chronicles the journey of the renowned icon painter amidst the chaos of 15th-century Russia, a time rife with clashes among rival Princes and invasions by the Tatars. Tarkovsky's signature breathtaking cinematography shines brilliantly throughout this film.
Purchase this DVD on Amazon
4. A Man for All Seasons 1966, Fred Zinnemann
Set in 16th-century England, this film highlights the timeless struggle of individuals like Sir Thomas More, who cherish life yet possess the unwavering moral strength to sacrifice it for their beliefs. Focusing on the final seven years of the English chancellor's life, the narrative centers on the conflict between More and King Henry VIII. The King seeks to sever ties with Rome to annul his marriage and remarry, while More, a devout Catholic, cannot condone such actions. Despite minor ambiguities in character relationships, the film offers a remarkably precise depiction of the era and the challenges faced by Saint Thomas More. It surpasses recent 'Elizabeth' films in both historical accuracy and artistic integrity.
Purchase this DVD on Amazon
3. The Passion of Joan of Arc 1928, Carl Theodor Dreyer
Few films can claim the level of authenticity achieved by dramatizing the actual court transcripts from the trial of Saint Joan of Arc. Despite being an early silent film, it earns its top ranking by staying true to the historical account, free from the distortions or hidden agendas seen in other portrayals of Joan. Maria Falconetti's portrayal of Joan is widely regarded as one of the most extraordinary performances ever captured on screen. If you haven't experienced this masterpiece, it's a must-watch.
Buy this DVD at AmazonSynopses Courtesy of IMDB
2. The Lion in Winter 1968, Anthony Harvey
Set in 1183, Henry II gathers his sons Richard, John, and Geoffrey, along with his imprisoned wife Eleanor, for a Christmas reunion at Chinon. Joining them are King Philip II of France and his sister Alais, who is also Henry's mistress. Philip demands that Alais marry John as previously agreed, or he wants her dowry, the Vexen lands, returned. With Eleanor having already granted Aquitaine to Richard, the resolution of this conflict could shape the destiny of England. Featuring stellar performances by Katharine Hepburn and Peter O’Toole, this film is an absolute must-watch.
Purchase this DVD at Amazon
1. The Return of Martin Guerre 1982, Daniel Vigne
This film follows Martin Guerre as he returns to his village in rural France after spending years away at war, having left as a child. Despite his knowledge of personal details about his family and friends, no one recognizes him, and many doubt his true identity. Inspired by true events, the story was later adapted into the film Sommersby, starring Jodie Foster and Richard Gere.
Purchase this DVD on Amazon
