The 15 Greatest Psychological Thrillers

Psychological thrillers are my top choice when it comes to films. They dominate my DVD shelf and are the ones I keep coming back to. There's something thrilling about the suspense, the way the plot twists keep you on edge without relying on excessive gore. These films engage the mind, not just the senses. Here, I've put together a list of my personal top ten psychological thrillers of all time. As always, feel free to disagree or suggest others that could expand this list in the comments. Note: This list also includes a competition, with further details available at the end of the article.

15. The Talented Mr Ripley Anthony Minghella, 1999

Set in the 1950s, Tom Ripley works as a Manhattan lavatory attendant and uses a borrowed Princeton jacket to sneak into a garden party. There, he meets the wealthy father of a Princeton graduate who, mistaking Tom for a friend of his son, offers him $1,000 to go to Italy and convince Dickie Greenleaf to return home. Once in Italy, Tom becomes entwined with Dickie and his fiancée Marge, pretending to love jazz and secretly nursing homoerotic desires as he enjoys a life of luxury. Tom’s deceptive talents extend to forgery and impersonations, and when Dickie tires of him, dismissing him as a nuisance, Tom takes extreme actions to claim Dickie’s life for his own. This was the first film I saw Matt Damon in, and I was struck by how he made every scene so unsettling. To top it off, Philip Seymour Hoffman makes a memorable cameo.

Purchase the DVD on Amazon

14. Fatal Attraction Adrian Lyne, 1987

Dan Callagher, a happily married New York lawyer, embarks on an affair with his colleague Alex. The two enjoy a passionate weekend while Dan’s wife and child are away. However, Alex becomes obsessed and will stop at nothing to make Dan hers. How far will she go to claim him? This film has permanently altered the way I see Glenn Close, as she portrays pure evil in this gripping 80s thriller. A must-watch for some classic 80s horror.

Purchase the DVD on Amazon

13. The Game David Fincher, 1997

Nicholas Van Orton, a work-obsessed businessman, turns 48 when his estranged, drug-addicted brother reappears to gift him a unique experience for his birthday – a membership to a mysterious, exclusive game. Despite his doubts, Nicholas signs the waiver and finds himself plunged into an unpredictable and life-altering adventure. A lesser-known gem by the director of Se7en, though not as widely recognized, this film captivates with its suspenseful psychological twists. It’s guaranteed to hook you. In terms of psychological tension, it’s arguably the top contender.

Buy the DVD on Amazon

12. Cape Fear Directed by Martin Scorsese, 1991

Sam Bowden is a family man and a small-town corporate lawyer. Max Cady, on the other hand, is a psychotic rapist, notorious for his tattoos, cigar-smoking habits, and his bible-quoting speeches. Their connection? Fourteen years ago, Sam, as a public defender, was assigned to defend Cady in a rape trial. However, Sam made a grave mistake by withholding crucial documents from his illiterate client, which could have potentially led to Cady's acquittal. Now that Cady has been released, he is determined to seek vengeance on Sam and his family, aiming to teach them a painful lesson. Though The Departed was a strong contender, Cape Fear stood out due to its unique intensity and my preference for older classics. Nonetheless, if you haven't watched the newer Departed, it's definitely worth seeing as well.

Purchase the DVD on Amazon

11. American Psycho Directed by Mary Harron, 2000

Patrick Bateman is charming, highly educated, and intelligent. At twenty-seven, he's living his version of the American Dream. By day, he thrives in the high-powered world of Wall Street, accumulating wealth on top of his already privileged background. But as night falls, his facade shatters, revealing a disturbing descent into madness, where fear and violence become his experiments. This film has more unsettling moments than any other I can think of, and it is possibly the most grotesque of the films on this list. Yet, it manages to handle the horror in a strangely 'tasteful' way. For me, the most chilling scene involves a drawer filled with medical tools—if you've seen the movie, you'll know exactly what I mean.

Get the DVD on Amazon

10. Les Diaboliques Directed by Henri-Georges Clouzot, 1955

A conniving wife and her lover, both involved in a plot to murder the tyrannical headmaster of a boarding school, carry out their sinister plan by drowning him in a bathtub before disposing of his body in a filthy swimming pool. However, when the pool is drained, his body is nowhere to be found, leading to eerie sightings of the headmaster that slowly erode the sanity of his would-be killers and leave the audience gripped by mounting tension. This film, which was remade in 1996 under the title Diabolique starring Sharon Stone, is a far superior experience – the remake pales in comparison.

Purchase the DVD from Amazon

9. Straw Dogs Sam Peckinpah, 1971

In this gripping thriller, astrophysicist David Sumner and his wife Amy move to Britain to escape the violence of America, only to find themselves targeted by a group of local construction workers. When David finally stands his ground, the situation spirals into an all-out bloody confrontation as the locals invade their home. This is not the Dustin Hoffman most are familiar with, and it's one of my top psychological thrillers. Be warned, though—some of the scenes are disturbing, making it a film worth purchasing or downloading.

Purchase the DVD from Amazon

8. Play Misty for Me Clint Eastwood, 1971

Clint Eastwood stars as Dave Garver, a disc jockey who becomes the obsession of a deranged fan, Evelyn Draper (Jessica Walter). After a casual encounter in a bar, Evelyn reveals that she is the voice behind the repeated requests to play the Erroll Garner classic 'Misty.' What begins as an innocent date quickly spirals out of control as Evelyn stalks Dave, disrupts his professional life, terrorizes his home, and even threatens to kill his girlfriend, Tobie Williams (Donna Mills). The haunting melody of 'Misty' will never sound the same again after watching this chilling thriller. This film marks Clint Eastwood’s directorial debut, and it’s an unforgettable one!

Buy the DVD from Amazon

7. The Usual Suspects Bryan Singer, 1995

After a massive explosion at the waterfront, Verbal, a key witness and participant, recounts the events leading up to the disaster. The tale begins when five men are brought in for a lineup and interrogated about a truck hijacking (the usual suspects). Among them is Keaton, a crooked cop who has been exposed, indicted, and is now trying to go straight. However, the cops continue to hound him, and while waiting for bail, he’s convinced to take part in one last job with the other four. Things go relatively smoothly until the ominous presence of the legendary Keyser Soze begins to influence the situation. Despite its modern-day setting, the film has a distinct forties noir vibe, filled with suspense, intrigue (and a hefty body count), along with plenty of twists. Ranked #20 on IMDB’s Top 250 for good reason: it boasts a stellar cast, top-notch direction, and striking cinematography.

Purchase the DVD from Amazon

6. Memento Christopher Nolan, 2000

Memento follows two intertwined narratives about Leonard, a former insurance investigator who is unable to form new memories, as he seeks to avenge the murder of his wife—the last thing he remembers clearly. One story moves forward in time, while the other moves backward, gradually revealing more details with each twist. This is not just an edge-of-your-seat thriller, but a brilliantly constructed film that keeps you guessing until the very end. Guy Pearce delivers an outstanding performance in this must-see masterpiece.

Purchase the DVD from Amazon

5. Se7en David Fincher, 1995

This intense thriller follows the chilling journey of a deranged serial killer with a twisted sense of justice. He meticulously selects seven victims, each embodying one of the Seven Deadly Sins, and takes it upon himself to act as an executioner, inflicting horrific punishments for their perceived sins. A seasoned detective on the verge of retirement teams up with a determined young cop to stop him, only to fall into the killer’s intricate web. Anyone who has witnessed this masterpiece can attest to the gripping suspense, always wondering what horrific fate awaits the next victim. This film is a must-see if you haven’t yet experienced it.

Purchase the DVD from Amazon today!

4. Taxi Driver Directed by Martin Scorsese, 1976

In this gritty portrayal of New York City, cab driver Travis Bickle is consumed by the decay he sees around him, growing more disturbed by his intense loneliness and alienation. He finds himself perpetually disconnected from the world, unable to form any meaningful relationships. Tormented by insomnia, he seeks solace in the seedy world of local adult entertainment and fantasizes about escaping his dismal life. Robert De Niro’s chilling performance keeps the audience on edge every moment he’s on screen, creating an atmosphere of constant unease. Scorsese’s masterpiece is a modern thriller for the ages.

Get your copy of the DVD from Amazon now!

1. The Manchurian Candidate Directed by John Frankenheimer, 1962

After Raymond returns as a decorated hero from the Korean War, his fellow soldiers are unable to recall the specific actions that earned him his medal. Two members of the platoon begin experiencing strange recurring nightmares, and one of them becomes determined to uncover the truth about Raymond’s current life. What disturbing and dangerous secrets are the Government and the Army concealing? This captivating thriller led to a remake (which pales in comparison) starring Denzel Washington. The original boasts stellar performances by Janet Leigh, Frank Sinatra, and the unforgettable Angela Lansbury.

Purchase the DVD from Amazon now!

Extra Mulholland Drive Directed by David Lynch, 2001

I’ve included this as a bonus rather than in the main list because it feels more aligned with the surrealist genre. However, it certainly has psychological thriller elements, so it’s worth mentioning. This eerie film takes you on an odd journey through Los Angeles and the life of an aspiring movie star, ultimately leading to no clear destination. As with many of Lynch’s works, this film resists any clear explanation – stay tuned for the surrealist film list, as it’s sure to make an appearance there.

Get the DVD from Amazon today!

3. Silence of the Lambs Directed by Jonathan Demme, 1991

Clarice Starling, a sharp and driven FBI trainee, is dispatched to the Baltimore State Hospital for the Criminally Insane to interview Dr. Hannibal Lecter – a brilliant psychiatrist turned cannibalistic serial killer. She must engage with Lecter, using her intellect, to obtain crucial information in the search for ‘Buffalo Bill,’ a mysterious and deranged killer. Silence of the Lambs claims the top spot, as it’s not only the finest of its genre but also introduced one of the most terrifying, cunning, and vile characters in cinema: Dr. Hannibal Lecter. It’s also arguably one of Jodie Foster’s finest performances.

Get your DVD from Amazon now!

2. Rear Window Directed by Alfred Hitchcock, 1954

L.B. “Jeff” Jeffries, a professional photographer, sustains a broken leg while capturing an action shot at an auto race. Forced to stay in his New York apartment, he spends his days watching his neighbors through his rear window. Gradually, he becomes convinced that one of them has murdered his wife. With the help of his glamorous society model girlfriend, Lisa Freemont, and his nurse, Stella, Jeff embarks on an investigation. I could only pick one Hitchcock film for this list (otherwise, it would have been a Top 10 Hitchcock list), and Rear Window seemed like the obvious choice. With outstanding acting, masterful cinematography, and suspense throughout, it’s a classic.

Get the DVD from Amazon now!

+ Competition

At 1pm GMT tomorrow, I will randomly select one commenter from the list to win a copy of the fantastic newly released book, Top 10 For Men. This book features over 250 intriguing lists that are sure to captivate any man (though women will enjoy it as well). Topics covered include: What is the most common murder weapon? Which variety of chili is the hottest? Who is the most searched woman on the internet? For an official excerpt, click here.

The winner will be chosen at random from the comments, and as usual, you can increase your chances by leaving more than one comment – but please ensure your comments add value to the list. No spammy comments will be accepted! To enter, you must be a registered user on List Universe. If you haven’t registered yet, click here to do so.

A huge thanks to Octopus Books for generously donating the prize for this competition.

Sources: this article references synopsis information from IMDB – the Internet Movie Database