Buzz
A trifle is the ultimate chaotic yet charming dessert. Without its signature bowl, it would be a complete mess, but its delightful qualities make up for the disorder. While some prefer elegant layers of cake, jam, and custard, I believe trifles should embrace their wild side. Let’s celebrate their quirky nature by making a trifle with Pop-Tarts—a dessert that’s unapologetically fun and indulgent.
As the summer heat saps our energy, this no-fuss dessert is the perfect solution. Combining the simplicity of an icebox cake with the nostalgic taste of Pop-Tarts, it’s a treat everyone will love. Begin by preparing a sweet whipped cream. Add a quarter cup of powdered sugar to a mixing bowl, along with a pint of heavy whipping cream. Use a stand mixer or hand mixer to whip the mixture until it forms soft, fluffy peaks, then blend in a teaspoon of vanilla extract. This process typically takes five to ten minutes, depending on your equipment.
While my heavy cream was whipping in the stand mixer, I prepared the Pop-Tarts. Chopping them into small rectangles is optional—you could simply tear them apart—but I opted for neat pieces to give the trifle a more structured texture. This way, you can decide whether to crumble them further or leave them in larger chunks.
Once the whipped cream is prepared, spread a quarter of it evenly at the bottom of a bowl. Scatter chunks and crumbs of Pop-Tarts over the cream, then add another layer of whipped cream. Repeat the process, finishing with a final layer of whipped cream on top.
Try to resist eating it immediately. Cover the bowl and let the trifle chill in the refrigerator for at least four hours, or ideally overnight. The moisture from the whipped cream will seep into the Pop-Tarts, softening them. When you finally indulge, the cream will have a firmer texture, and the tarts will be tender, creating a harmonious blend. The wait is absolutely worthwhile.
Add sprinkles for a playful touch, but do so right before serving. Over time, the sprinkles' dye will bleed into the whipped cream, so leftovers might look less appealing the next day. However, your trifle will be a delightful masterpiece today. Each spoonful offers a fluffy mix of vibrant jam and cake-like pastry pieces. I used four packs of Pop-Tarts, totaling eight tarts. Feel free to stick to one flavor or mix and match—I combined four Cherry Frosted and four Frosted Confetti Cupcake, which turned out wonderfully.
This recipe yields eight generous servings, but you can easily halve it for a smaller portion or double it for a crowd that loves indulgent treats. Store any leftovers in the fridge, covered, for up to five days.
Pop-Tart Trifle
Ingredients:
8 Pop-Tarts (4 sleeves)
¼ cup powdered sugar (or 3 tablespoons granulated)
1 pint heavy whipping cream
1 teaspoon vanilla extract (optional)
Sprinkles for decorating (optional)
Using a stand mixer or hand mixer, whip the sugar and heavy cream together until medium peaks form. If desired, mix in the vanilla extract.
Spread a quarter of the whipped cream evenly across the bottom of a bowl. Evenly scatter a third of the crumbled Pop-Tarts over the cream. Add another quarter of the whipped cream, smoothing it into a uniform layer. Repeat the process with the remaining Pop-Tarts and cream, finishing with a final layer of whipped cream. Cover the bowl and refrigerate the trifle for at least four hours, or overnight. Add sprinkles just before serving for a festive touch.
