Buzz
While Thanksgiving sides often steal the spotlight, a well-smoked turkey can hold its own against even the best mashed potatoes, cornbread, or stuffing. This year, try something new by smoking your turkey for the juiciest, easiest holiday main course. Our step-by-step guide may just become your new favorite Thanksgiving tradition.
Why Choose to Smoke a Turkey for Thanksgiving?
The flavor is what draws many to smoking a turkey: the unique taste that wood smoke imparts to the bird adds complexity and richness. Smoked meat absorbs the deep, earthy, campfire-like notes of barbecue, perfectly complementing the cool weather and classic Thanksgiving sides. But there are even more reasons to smoke your turkey this year:
- It's virtually foolproof. Smoking ensures your turkey won’t be overcooked, delivering perfectly tender and moist meat with a flavorful depth. Using higher heat (325 to 350°F) crisps the skin while keeping the turkey juicy.
- It's simple. Once you have the right smoker, preparing and smoking the turkey is almost as easy as roasting it.
- It opens up oven space. Moving your turkey outside to the smoker frees up crucial space in your oven for all the other Thanksgiving dishes.
What You’ll Need to Smoke a Turkey
To smoke a turkey, the only essentials are a smoker and a meat thermometer. If you're just starting out with smoking meat, a great option is a plug-in pellet smoker, which effortlessly maintains a consistent temperature range with minimal attention from you.
For a plug-in pellet smoker, instead of manually adding wood to a firebox, you simply fill the smoker's hopper with pellets, set your desired temperature, and let it do the work. While some of these smokers can be quite pricey, you can also find models under $100.
If you don’t have a smoker, you can still replicate the smoking process using a gas or charcoal grill. The key is to cook the turkey slowly and evenly over indirect heat. For example, in a gas grill, turn on only half the burners and place the turkey on the unlit side.
To get that signature smoky flavor, add a smoker box with wood chips that have been soaked in water—or even apple juice—for an extra touch of flavor.
How to Prepare Your Turkey for Smoking
Preparing a turkey for smoking is very similar to prepping a turkey for roasting. Before you light up the smoker, follow these simple steps.
Step 1: Thaw and Bring Your Turkey to Room Temperature
Just like when you roast a turkey, start by thawing your bird (if it's frozen) and bringing it to room temperature for up to 2 hours. This ensures the turkey reaches an even temperature inside and out. A cold bird will take longer to smoke and may cook unevenly.
Step 2: Spatchcock (Optional)
There are two ways to prepare a whole turkey for smoking: as is or spatchcocked, which is the preferred method for a quicker, more even cook. For spatchcocking, use kitchen shears to cut out the backbone and then flatten the bird, spreading out both halves for more even heat distribution.
Step 3: Oil and Season
Use paper towels to pat your turkey dry, then lightly coat it with olive oil or melted butter. After that, apply a generous amount of salt, pepper, and any additional seasonings you like, such as rosemary and garlic powder, covering the entire surface.
When seasoning a turkey for smoking, it's important to keep it simple. Smoking at higher temperatures means the smoke has less time to penetrate the meat, resulting in a more subtle smokiness that complements the turkey’s milder taste. A simple rub ensures the seasoning enhances, rather than overpowers, the turkey's natural flavor.
If you’ve brined your turkey beforehand, you can skip this step.
How to Smoke a Turkey
Now that your turkey is thawed, tempered, oiled, and seasoned, it’s time to get the smoker going. Here’s what to do next.
Step 1: Preheat
For smoking a Thanksgiving turkey, we recommend going high and fast. Set your smoker to a temperature between 325 and 350 degrees.
Many experienced smokers prefer to start at a lower temperature, around 200 degrees, and then increase the heat for the final phase. This method works, but it adds to the cook time and introduces an additional variable.
We favor a higher smoking temperature because, on Thanksgiving, it’s crucial to predict when your turkey will be ready. It’s more difficult to gauge that if you begin with a low temperature and then raise it.
Step 2: Smoke Your Turkey
Place your turkey directly on the smoker grates, no need for a sheet pan. At 325 to 350 degrees, a spatchcocked turkey will take about 10 to 12 minutes per pound. For most birds, this means at least an hour, or potentially longer.
You might hear suggestions about injecting or basting your turkey during smoking. However, if you’re smoking a spatchcocked turkey, these methods aren’t necessary due to the faster cooking time.
Step 3: Remove and Let Rest
The most reliable way to check if your smoked turkey is done is by checking the temperature. Insert the thermometer into the thickest part of the thigh, and when it reaches 165 degrees, it’s ready to serve.
Allow your smoked turkey to rest on a rack, cutting board, or serving platter for at least 30 minutes to ensure the juices are locked in and the flavor is enhanced. Keep the turkey uncovered while resting to preserve the crispy, smoky skin.
