Buzz
Image Credit: Ozgur Coskun/Getty ImagesEating lobster correctly is an art, and Lorri Cousens, former owner of the renowned Waterman’s Beach Lobster stand in South Thomaston, Maine, reveals her expert technique for cracking and disassembling lobster gracefully. Whether you prefer using your hands or a fork is entirely up to you. At home, feel free to use your hands to savor the lobster meat as you break it apart. In a formal setting or if you prefer a cleaner dining experience, opt for a fork to enjoy the meat once it’s extracted from the shell. This is particularly useful when dipping the lobster into melted butter, which can be quite messy. While a lobster pick might seem handy for eating, it’s best reserved for extracting meat from the shell. Watch our step-by-step guide to mastering the art of eating lobster effortlessly and neatly.
- Remove the dark vein running through the lobster's tail and discard it. This vein is part of the lobster's digestive system and, while safe, doesn’t enhance the flavor.
- Utilize a lobster pick or skewer to easily extract meat from the claws, knuckles, and body.
- For a meatier experience, choose lobsters weighing 1.5 pounds or more. These larger lobsters typically yield more meat in the tail, claws, knuckles, and legs.
- Tomalley, the greenish substance in the lobster's body cavity, serves as both the liver and pancreas. While some consider it a delicacy, current advice suggests consuming it in moderation due to potential toxin levels that could cause paralytic shellfish poisoning.
Essential Tools and Tips
Tools and Equipment Needed
- 1 Lobster pick or skewer
- 1 Nutcracker
- 1 Empty bowl for shell waste
- 1 Bib (optional)
- Plenty of napkins (essential!)
Required Materials
- 1 Whole lobster
Step-by-Step Guide
Remove the Tail
The tail is the simplest and often the most substantial part of the lobster. Hold the body with one hand and the tail with the other, then twist in opposite directions to detach it. Lay the tail on its side and press firmly with both hands until the shell cracks, loosening the meat for easy removal. Detach the flippers at the end, then insert your thumb into the flipper side to push the meat out. Discard the dark vein running through the tail.
Detach the Claws
Twist off one claw at the knuckle joint, being cautious of the sharp edges. Remove the “thumb” portion of the claw and extract the meat inside using a pick. Place the remaining claw in a nutcracker, flat side down, and crack it at the widest point. Gently pull out the meat, which should come out intact.
Separate the Knuckles
These segments connect the claws to the body (four in total). Use your hands to detach a knuckle, then crack it open with a nutcracker. Extract the meat using a pick.
Detach the Legs
Pull off all eight legs by hand and savor the meat by sucking it out from each one individually.
Open the Shell to Reach the Body Meat
This step requires effort and can be messy. (For lobsters under 1.5 pounds, skip this as there’s minimal meat.) Stabilize the body near the tail while prying off the top shell to expose the rib cage. Use a pick to separate the meat from the ribs. For the bold: You’ll notice a green paste called tomalley, the lobster’s liver. While it’s a salty, creamy delicacy that can be eaten alone or on crostini, it’s advised to consume it sparingly or avoid it. Female lobsters may contain edible red or orange eggs.
Top 3 Lobster Dining Mistakes to Avoid
To ensure a polished and mess-free lobster-eating experience, avoid these common errors.
Familiarize Yourself with Lobster Tools
Eating lobster can be a complex task, so understanding your tools and their proper use is essential. Use a lobster pick to remove meat from the shell and a nutcracker to open the claws. A lobster cracker can also help break the shell for easier access to the meat.
Avoid Using the Lobster Pick as a Fork
Although a lobster pick resembles a small fork, avoid using it as one. Instead, use the pick to extract meat from the claws, knuckles, and body, then switch to a regular fork for eating.
Handle Butter with Care
Melted butter is a common accompaniment to lobster, enhancing its flavor. To minimize mess, place the butter container on or near your plate to prevent spills. Use a fork, not your hands, when dipping lobster into the butter.
Common Questions Answered
-
Which parts of the lobster are edible and which are not?
When consuming a whole lobster, you can enjoy the tail, claw, knuckle, leg, and body meat. Female lobsters may have red roe (eggs) along the tail shell, which are also edible. Avoid the tail vein, cartilage, and shell fragments. The tomalley—a green paste in the body cavity—is technically edible but should be consumed cautiously due to potential toxins.
-
Where can you purchase lobster for cooking?
For cooking, opt for fresh live or frozen lobster. Whole live lobsters or frozen parts like tails can be bought from seafood markets, fishmongers, or specialty stores. Alternatively, consider using a lobster delivery service.
-
What is the proper way to eat lobster?
When eating a whole lobster, the sequence is up to you. Use a knife and fork for the tail meat, as it’s often a large portion. Claw meat can be eaten with a fork or hands, as can knuckle and body meat. For the legs, simply suck out the meat.
