Buzz
Constructive criticism is an art form. It’s a method of encouraging positive behavior without resorting to blame or personal attacks. To master this skill, maintain a positive tone and focus on clear, achievable goals. While there are many ways to offer constructive feedback, each individual is unique, so tailor your approach based on what you know about the person.
Steps
Only criticize when you have a clear purpose
Before offering criticism, ask yourself, “What is my goal?” Once you’ve identified what you hope to achieve, you’ll know where to focus during the conversation. Without a clear purpose, you risk overwhelming the other person with unnecessary information or making them feel pressured.
- You might want a specific behavior to change. For example, you may want an employee to stop violating company policies or a student to avoid shouting at classmates when overly excited.
- Your goal could also be to help someone improve. For instance, you might want to advise a colleague on better customer communication or assist a teacher in managing their classroom.
- If you can’t answer the question, “What is the purpose here?” you likely don’t need to offer criticism. Even if you’re internally judging someone, it’s not always necessary to voice it.
Pay attention to your tone when speaking
-
What you say matters, but how you say it is equally important. If the other person senses your goodwill and friendliness, they are far more likely to accept your feedback. The situation can worsen if they feel attacked for their mistakes, so lower your voice, maintain a calm demeanor, and use a tone that makes them feel respected and valued.
- There are times when a stern or serious tone is necessary. For example, if you catch your child playing with fireworks or an employee swearing in front of a customer, you must emphasize the severity of the issue.
Speak to the person privately
Praise in public and criticize in private for the best results. No one likes to be called out for poor performance in front of others, so a private conversation helps reduce tension. You can invite them to your office or suggest meeting during lunch, always with a smile.
- If you criticize someone in front of others, they may feel humiliated or embarrassed. The chances of a productive conversation are much higher without an audience.
Start with a compliment
Find something great to say about the person. If you plan to criticize an employee for their sales performance, start by acknowledging their hard work and dedication. If addressing someone’s rude behavior, begin by praising their enthusiasm. Starting the conversation with positive feedback helps the person feel at ease and more receptive before diving into the main issue.
- When talking to your child, you might say, “I love you and I’m proud of how hard you’ve been studying, but your teacher just called me…”
- When addressing an employee, you could say, “You’ve been doing an excellent job with sales, and your work ethic is impressive, but I need to remind you about the company’s attendance policy…”
- When giving feedback to a friend, you might say, “I know you care about me, and you know I care about you too, but something recently has been bothering me…”
Use “I” statements to create a positive tone
Give them a chance to self-critique
One way to start the conversation is by letting the other person speak first. You can ask them a hypothetical question about what they would say if they were in your position or encourage them to reflect on their behavior from a new perspective. This approach is great if you’re worried the other person might feel attacked or pressured. It’s also helpful if you’re unsure whether they realize they’ve made a mistake.
- If your employee is struggling at work, you might say, “If you were the manager and had an employee receiving multiple customer complaints, how would you handle the situation?” or “How would you rate your own performance if you had to evaluate it?”
- When talking to your child, you could ask, “How would you feel if a classmate acted that way?”
- When speaking to a friend, you might say, “How would you feel if a friend talked behind your back?”
Connect the criticism to their goals
You can persuade the other person by emphasizing the benefits of accepting your feedback. If your criticism seems completely unrelated to their goals, they’re less likely to take it well. Ask yourself, “What does this person need?” Before (or after) delivering your critique, explain how your feedback will help them achieve their objectives to make it more convincing.
- For an employee who often misses deadlines, you might say, “I know you’re aiming for a promotion, so I thought we could discuss a few changes you could make to reach that goal. What do you think?”
- If a colleague is consistently late, you could say, “I remember you mentioned wanting to boost your sales numbers. I have an idea that might help. Would you like to talk about it?”
- When speaking to your child, you might say, “I know you want to go to summer camp with your friends, but if you don’t improve your grades, you’ll have to attend summer school.”
Criticize behavior, not the person
People are more likely to change if they don’t feel personally attacked. We don’t always act in ways that align with who we are or how we see ourselves. By focusing solely on what the person did, you make it easier for them to change. They’re less likely to respond well if they feel you’re belittling or challenging their core identity.
- For example, instead of telling a struggling salesperson, “You’re bad at building relationships with clients,” you could say, “I think you could improve how you communicate with customers.”
- Another example: Instead of telling a colleague with sloppy attire, “You look messy,” you might say, “I wouldn’t choose that outfit for work. What I mean is…”
- This is especially important when giving feedback to a loved one or family member. Instead of saying, “You treat me terribly!” try, “I don’t like it when you speak to me that way.”
Be honest about the severity of the issue
If you’re criticizing them for a serious reason, say so. However, if the issue isn’t a big deal, acknowledge that too. If someone breaks a minor workplace rule they might not even realize they’ve violated, don’t act like it’s the end of the world. On the other hand, if someone’s behavior endangers others’ safety or the business, you must address it firmly. Adjust your language and tone based on the severity of the issue.
- You might tell an employee who’s often a few minutes late, “Look, I know this seems minor, but I’d appreciate it if you could clock in at 9:00 sharp, not 9:04 or 9:02.”
- For a more serious issue, like an employee being rude to a customer, you could say, “I need to be direct with you about this. The company never tolerates employees speaking to customers that way. It damages our reputation.”
- When criticizing children, it’s crucial to emphasize why you’re addressing the behavior. If they’ve done something dangerous, make sure they understand how serious it is.
Acknowledge external factors
Recognizing other factors can help the other person take responsibility. If the individual is facing difficulties at home, express your understanding of their personal struggles. If their actions are due to pressure, acknowledge that you might act similarly under stress, but emphasize the need for communication. This approach helps them grasp the essence of your expectations.
- For instance, if addressing your husband about not helping with housework, you might say, "I know you're working hard at the office and contributing significantly to our family, but it would really help me if you could occasionally assist with washing the dishes."
- When speaking to a child, you could say, "I understand that sometimes you get too excited to control yourself, but next time your friends come over, please try not to do that."
- You might tell a tired night-shift employee, "I know working the night shift is tough and it's hard to get enough rest, but since I noticed you sleeping on the job, we need to discuss this issue."
Specify future changes
Provide the person with specific steps to follow. If your feedback is vague or not specific, it will be difficult for the other person to effectively act on your suggestions. After delivering your critique, offer actionable advice for improvement. You might even offer to help them with some steps!
- For example, remind an employee who often forgets accessories on their uniform, "Next time before leaving home, remember to check your bag for your name tag. If you forget, you can come to me for a spare."
- If your roommate is lazy about housework, you could say, "Xuân will clean the kitchen, and I'll take care of the bathroom. Can you handle sweeping the yard every week?"
Express your trust in them
You can say this at the beginning or end of your critique, as long as it makes the other person feel supported. If they believe you lack faith in them, they may feel disheartened after receiving criticism. If your goal is to help them improve, express appreciation for their efforts and confidence in their ability to meet your expectations.
- For example, you might conclude a conversation with a struggling student by saying, "I know you're a smart and diligent student. I believe in you, and I'm confident you can do it!"
- You could tell an employee lacking confidence, "You're an indispensable part of the team, and I know you have what it takes to excel."
Respond to concerns with empathy
Giving the other person a chance to respond is essential. If they feel unheard, they may perceive the conversation as unfair once it ends. Allow them an opportunity to share their thoughts or feelings. Even if you disagree or they focus on a different aspect of your critique, it's crucial they feel listened to.
- You might close the conversation with a question like, "Does this seem fair to you?" or "How do you feel about this?" and let them express themselves.
- If the person seems discouraged afterward, you could say, "I understand why you're disappointed. I feel the same, but we still need to address this."
- If they become defensive or upset, try to ease the tension by reminding them of your intent to help. You might say, "I don't mean to bring you down. I just want to help. I apologize if I caused any misunderstanding."
- If they lose control and start yelling or acting out, stay calm, help them relax, and let it go. Clearly, they're not in a state to engage in a productive conversation.
Advice
- The "sandwich" feedback method (negative feedback sandwiched between positive feedback) often works well in everyday life, but in professional settings, many prefer directness as it's more common. This approach can sometimes make your critique seem insincere.
- Learn from those who excel at delivering constructive criticism.
