Buzz
Since the 1990s, educational institutions have implemented zero-tolerance policies targeting a wide range of behaviors, including drug use, weapons, and other issues, aiming to safeguard students. While some argue these policies are necessary, others criticize them for being overly strict, citing numerous high-profile incidents that have sparked national debate. Regardless of their intent, here are some of the most extreme and absurd examples of zero-tolerance enforcement in schools.
10. The Pop-Tart Incident
In March 2013, an eight-year-old student at Park Elementary School in Maryland was suspended for shaping his Pop-Tart into what resembled a gun. Coming shortly after the Sandy Hook tragedy, school officials were on high alert, but many critics argued their response was excessive. The suspension ignited widespread controversy and fueled discussions about the rigidity of zero-tolerance policies in public schools.
When news of the suspension broke, many accused the school of overreacting due to heightened sensitivity around gun-related issues. However, some defended the decision, claiming the boy had a history of behavioral issues, and the suspension was more about classroom disruption than the Pop-Tart itself. Supporters argued the incident was not solely about the shape of the snack but about maintaining order in the learning environment.
Although the boy’s parents acknowledged he had “minor behavioral issues,” they argued that suspending such a young student was an extreme measure. They filed a lawsuit against the school district, alleging that the school made no effort to address their son’s needs constructively. After the suspension, the boy completed the school year and was later transferred to another institution.
9. Girl Arrested for Drawing on a Desk
In 2010, 12-year-old Alexa Gonzalez was arrested for writing a message on her desk in green marker: “I love my friends Abby and Faith. Lex was here 2/1/10.” While most would expect detention or cleaning duty as a consequence, Alexa was arrested and faced potential suspension. This extreme response stemmed from zero-tolerance policies that classified her doodle as graffiti.
Alexa Gonzalez was handcuffed and escorted out of Junior High School 190 in Forest Hills, New York, by police officers, in full view of her classmates and teachers. She was taken to a nearby police precinct, where she described the experience: “They handcuffed me, and I was in shock... I didn’t want my classmates to see me like that, thinking I was a criminal.” Her mother revealed that Alexa remained in handcuffs for hours at the police station.
Following an investigation, education department spokesperson David Cantor admitted the incident should never have occurred. Alexa received an apology, and her suspension was revoked. However, she was still required to complete eight hours of community service, write a book report, and compose an essay reflecting on the lessons learned from the ordeal.
8. Student Forced to Undergo Psychological Evaluation for Twirling a Pencil
In 2014, 13-year-old Ethan Chaplin was subjected to a psychological evaluation and barred from attending school until the results were finalized—all because he twirled a pencil inside a pen cap. Another student, who had been bullying Ethan, noticed the action and shouted to the teacher, “He’s acting like he’s shooting a gun; send him to juvie.”
The teacher took the bully’s accusation seriously. Ethan was suspended for two days and sent to Riverview Medical Center for a five-hour evaluation. The school superintendent defended the decision, stating, “When a student exhibits unusual or non-conforming behaviors, we must investigate further. If a student’s actions or gestures could be interpreted as a potential threat to others in the classroom... that’s a red flag for us.”
Ethan’s father, Michael Chaplin, called the superintendent’s remarks “alarming,” arguing that they unfairly compared his son to notorious school shooters. Upon returning to school, Ethan was closely monitored by the principal, and his friends were questioned about his behavior.
7. Autistic Boy Suspended for Drawing a ‘Violent Image’
Rhett Parham, a 13-year-old autistic boy, enjoyed playing Bomberman 64, a Nintendo 64 video game. It’s common for individuals with autism to struggle with social cues, so Parham didn’t see an issue with drawing a scene from the game and bringing it to Hillcrest Middle School in Greenville, South Carolina. However, after other students raised concerns, Parham was suspended.
Students who reported the incident claimed Parham mentioned having a “bomb” and showed them his drawing. His mother expressed her frustration, stating, “I’m angry, upset, and honestly shocked that a drawing could be interpreted as a threat... especially from a child with special needs who processes information differently than neurotypical children.”
Fortunately, after discussions between Parham’s mother and school administrators, the suspension was revoked. His mother clarified, “They decided not to suspend Rhett or pursue expulsion. They understood that his disability influenced his actions and that he had no harmful intentions.”
6. Cub Scout Suspended for Bringing a Knife to School
In 2009, six-year-old Cub Scout Zachary Christie was suspended for bringing his Cub Scout utensil—a combination knife, fork, and spoon—to school. Zachary intended to showcase it during lunch, as he had been trained to use it responsibly. However, school officials deemed the tool too hazardous, suspending him and even threatening to transfer him to a reform school.
Zachary Christie, a new Cub Scout, took great pride in his standard-issue knife. However, following the Columbine tragedy, the Christina School District enforced strict zero-tolerance policies. Under these rules, anyone found with a weapon on school grounds would face consequences, regardless of age or intent. This policy led to the suspension of the six-year-old boy.
A hearing was held after the incident, where Christie’s karate instructor and his mother’s fiancé testified about his character. Despite their defense, the school spokesperson stood by the decision, stating, “No parent wants to receive a call saying their child was injured because someone used a knife during an altercation.”
5. High School Student Arrested for Possessing a Kitchen Knife
In 2001, Lindsay Brown, a high-achieving high school senior, was arrested for having a kitchen knife in her possession. Known for her dedication to academics, Brown rarely had time to organize her car and was unaware of its contents. This oversight led to her arrest for felony weapon possession just before her graduation.
A felony charge can derail a promising future, and Brown was understandably devastated, knowing her dreams were at risk. She explained that she had accidentally left a kitchen knife in her car when she went to school. The 13-centimeter (5 in) blade was legally classified as a deadly weapon, and when someone spotted it, they alerted the police. Brown was immediately arrested and suspended from school, jeopardizing her graduation and potentially her scholarships. She expressed her frustration, saying, “They’re stealing my memories... I’m so angry I won’t walk with my friends over a kitchen knife.”
Fortunately, Brown wasn’t formally charged, as it couldn’t be proven that she intentionally had the knife. However, she missed her graduation ceremony and received her diploma by mail.
4. Boy Suspended for Pretending to Use a ‘Bow and Arrow’
In 2013, 10-year-old Johnny Jones was suspended after pretending to use an imaginary “bow and arrow.” While such play is common among children, the school interpreted his actions as a potential threat and disciplined him for what they deemed an imaginary weapon.
Jones was playfully pretending to shoot his friends with an imaginary “bow and arrow,” which the school staff perceived as violent and aggressive behavior. Using a pencil as his pretend arrow, Jones caused no harm to anyone. Despite this, the faculty viewed his actions as a potential threat. The incident began when another student pretended to shoot Jones with an imaginary gun, leading to the suspension of both boys.
Upon learning the reason for their son’s suspension, Jones’s parents considered legal action. His mother publicly stated, “Parents should be aware that if their child makes a finger gesture, they could be suspended for threatening with a firearm... That’s absurd.”
3. School Bans ChapStick
In 2014, Stuart Draft Elementary School prohibited a fifth grader from using ChapStick, classifying it as medication requiring a prescription. While most wouldn’t view ChapStick this way, the school district enforced the rule strictly. Grace Karaffa, the student affected, suffers from severely chapped lips that can bleed without treatment. Despite her need, she was repeatedly denied the use of ChapStick due to the ban.
The superintendent defended the policy, stating it was designed to safeguard students: “Our policy isn’t meant to be overly restrictive. It’s about protecting the students.” However, winter poses a significant challenge for Karaffa, who requires ChapStick multiple times a day. She recounted an incident where her lips bled repeatedly, yet she was still denied access to ChapStick: “Later that day, they began bleeding again, and my teacher said using ChapStick during school violated policy, so I had to go to the bathroom.”
Determined to change the policy, Karaffa launched a petition that gained widespread support among students. She collected hundreds of signatures and even spoke in classrooms, with supportive teachers helping circulate the petition. Eventually, the administration agreed to review the policy to determine if it was too stringent.
2. Boy Suspended for Discovering a Pocketknife
In 2003, Keith Post, a fifth grader at Pyles Elementary School in Stanton, California, was suspended for five days after finding a 5-centimeter (2 in) blade in the lunchroom. Post intended to turn it in but waited two hours, fearing the teacher might assume it was his. This delay led to his suspension instead of simply confiscating the blade and resolving the matter.
This incident raised questions about the rigidity of zero-tolerance policies. According to school rules, Post should have immediately reported the blade. The policy mandated a five-day suspension and a hearing for any student found with a weapon, regardless of the context. The principal argued that the policy aimed to ensure student safety. While the intent was understandable, punishing Post for trying to do the right thing sparked debate over whether such policies were too inflexible.
Post’s father commented on the situation: “The rule is meant for those who are caught with a weapon... Keith turned it in. He should be praised for his good behavior, not punished.” Despite the suspension, Keith stood by his actions: “It was the right thing to do... I can’t let myself do wrong.”
1. Boy Suspended for Calling His Teacher ‘Cute’
In 2011, nine-year-old Emanyea Lockett was suspended after telling a friend his teacher was “fine” in a suggestive tone and calling her “cute.” A substitute teacher overheard the remarks, leading to his suspension for what the principal of Brookside Elementary labeled “sexual harassment.” Lockett’s mother questioned the decision: “He didn’t touch her or act inappropriately... Why suspend him for two days over this?”
The school later sent a certified letter to Lockett’s mother detailing their reasoning. They claimed Emanyea’s comments constituted sexual harassment and added that he had previously used inappropriate language toward other students, despite no prior warnings to his mother. Emanyea denied these allegations, further complicating the situation.
Following an investigation, the school district concluded that Emanyea had committed no wrongdoing. They expunged the suspension from his record and issued an apology to him and his family. The principal responsible for the suspension subsequently retired in the wake of the incident.
