Buzz
A question that lingers in the minds of many hospital patients: Can I truly rely on the professional responsible for my care? While the answer is often affirmative, there are instances of reckless negligence and exploitative behavior by healthcare providers that could unsettle even the most trusting individuals.
10. A Physician Advises a Patient to End Their Life
Dr. Arun Singhal, a general practitioner at a Liverpool hospital, encountered a distressing case in May 2011. A woman, identified as 'Patient A,' was on antidepressants and serving as a witness in a rape trial. Fearing for her safety due to her proximity to the suspect's brother, she sought a medical excuse from Dr. Singhal to avoid testifying. Overwhelmed, she confessed to being on the brink of suicide and expressed that her medication was ineffective.
Singhal’s reaction to Patient A resembled the behavior of a cruel online troll rather than a trained medical professional. He insulted her, calling her a 'disgrace' and coldly advised her to 'go ahead and end her life.' He even recommended she search the Internet for suicide methods. Unbeknownst to Singhal, Patient A recorded their conversation. Distraught, she reported the incident.
The Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service investigated the case and determined that Singhal had dismissed Patient A’s concerns and acted inappropriately. As a result, he was suspended for three months. Given the potential consequences if Patient A had followed his advice, Singhal was fortunate to avoid being permanently dismissed.
9. A Former Hospital Worker Sends Patients Fraudulent Lobotomy Notices
Between 2005 and 2010, Michelle Morrison from Elk Grove Village, Illinois, worked as the senior account representative at Alexian Brothers Behavioral Health Hospital until her termination. Consumed by bitterness, she retaliated by stealing hospital stationery and the confidential details of over 30 patients in a cruel scheme to humiliate her former employers.
From February 2011 to June 2012, Morrison sent six fake letters to three patients, falsely stating that their psychological treatments had been unsuccessful and that they required frontal lobotomies. The letters also included offensive comments and threats to expose the patients’ medical histories to their loved ones and colleagues.
After a two-month investigation, Morrison was identified as the perpetrator. Found in possession of patient records and hospital materials at her residence, she had no choice but to admit guilt. Expressing remorse, Morrison apologized in court for her first recorded criminal offense. She was sentenced to 30 months of probation.
8. Nursing Home Staff Mock Dementia Patients with Heartless Pranks
In 2010, six staff members at the Valley View Skilled Nursing Facility in Ukiah, California, thought it would be amusing to coat seven helpless dementia patients entirely in ointment, creating a slippery obstacle for the incoming shift. Instead of laughter, these employees, aged 23 to 51, faced arrest for their cruel actions.
Sadly, the Ukiah incident is not isolated. In May 2012, a worker at Kirknowe Care Home in the UK was fired for giving a dog treat to a dementia patient as a prank. Similarly, Tracie Nellis, a nursing home employee, exhibited cruel behavior in 2013 by pouring hot sauce into the mouths of two sleeping dementia patients, an act that led her to voluntarily surrender her nursing license.
The catalog of similar and often more severe offenses appears endless. These incidents highlight the troubling trend of healthcare workers exploiting vulnerable patients.
7. A Physician Smacks Sedated Patients on Their Buttocks
For over a year, Dr. Michael T. Clarke, a doctor at St. Joseph’s Hospital Health Center in Syracuse, New York, took pleasure in slapping the buttocks of sedated patients in the operating room. He later claimed this was a method to test spinal anesthetic effectiveness, but his colleagues disputed this explanation.
Witnesses reported that the doctor made vulgar remarks while striking patients, often with enough force to leave visible red marks. He also allegedly directed inappropriate comments at hospital staff. After months of silence, operating room staff reported his behavior to hospital administrators in December 2013.
An investigation by the state health department confirmed the allegations against Clarke. He was suspended in February 2014 and had to complete unspecified requirements to regain his position. Eight months later, he returned to work at St. Joseph’s.
6. A Surgeon Sends Explicit Texts During Surgery
Arthur K. Zilberstein, an anesthesiologist with 20 years of experience at Swedish Medical Center in Seattle, Washington, engaged in misconduct during various surgeries, including C-sections and pediatric appendectomies. He sent nearly 250 sexually explicit messages and photos to his girlfriend and, at times, to his patients.
On one occasion, he sent a patient a photo of himself in hospital scrubs with his genitals exposed. During a stomach operation, he managed to send 45 explicit text messages in less than 90 minutes.
Dr. Zilberstein was also accused of accessing patients’ medical records for personal gratification, engaging in inappropriate relationships at the hospital, and issuing unauthorized prescriptions. While it’s unclear if his actions harmed anyone, state authorities deemed his behavior serious enough to warrant the revocation of his medical license. Swedish Medical Center also suspended his privileges at the time.
5. An Anesthesiologist Strikes a Patient Post-Heart Surgery
Dr. Andrei Votyakov, an anesthesiologist at Russia’s Federal Center for Cardiovascular Surgery in Perm, had just completed a grueling 36-hour shift. In this exhausted state, he encountered a heart surgery patient who was restrained to the bed, wearing an oxygen mask, and unable to move.
The 61-year-old patient reportedly insulted Votyakov and showed no gratitude for his efforts. Losing control, the doctor struck the patient in the face and then repeatedly hit his chest near the surgical site. The patient passed away a week later.
Video evidence from February 21, 2013, captures an apparent argument between Votyakov and the patient before the doctor turns violent. The footage, later shared online, sparked public outrage and prompted an official inquiry. Votyakov expressed remorse for his actions but denied responsibility for the patient’s death. A criminal investigation appeared to support his defense, as he was fined 100,000 rubles and sentenced to five months of community service.
4. A Nurse Pilfers From Unconscious Cancer Patients
In January 2015, Morriston Hospital in Wales launched an operation to apprehend a thief. Patients had been robbed since at least November, and suspicion fell on a staff member. Collaborating with local police, they set a trap using a marked £20 note placed under a plant pot. The plan succeeded, but the discovery that the thief was a hospital employee, preying on critically ill patients, was disheartening.
The thief was 49-year-old nurse Jacqueline Perry, who worked in the cancer ward. She reportedly waited for patients to fall asleep before stealing valuables to support her husband’s drinking habit. Her thefts ranged from painkillers and cash to jewelry. In one case, she took £14 from a cancer patient. Another victim, 89-year-old Nancy Thomas, lost three cherished family rings worth £1,800, which Perry sold for a fraction of their value before Thomas passed away.
Perry stole a total of £2,739 worth of items before being caught in the hospital’s sting operation. She claimed her arrest relieved her of the guilt that had tormented her. For her crimes, she was sentenced to 16 months in prison. Sadly, some of her victims did not survive to witness her punishment.
3. Surgeons Who Abandon Patients During Operations
Dr. Pervaiz Chaudhry, a cardiac surgeon at Community Regional Medical Center in Fresno, California, conducted nearly 350 bypass surgeries between 2009 and 2010, ranking him among the top five heart surgeons in the state by volume. However, his high workload may have compromised patient safety, as his survival rates were below the state average. This could be linked to allegations that he frequently left surgeries unfinished.
Several lawsuits claim Chaudhry exited operating rooms before completing procedures. In one case, his hospital was fined $75,000 after he left a physician’s assistant to close a patient’s chest while he went to a luncheon. The patient, 72-year-old Silvino Perez, suffered a heart attack and was left in a vegetative state. Chaudhry denies these allegations, but an investigation by California’s State Department of Health concluded he had endangered Perez. The status of other claims remains unclear.
Chaudhry isn’t the only medical professional to prioritize food over patient care. In 2012, a Swedish anesthesiologist and nurse anesthetist caused a patient’s death by leaving for lunch during surgery. They were supposed to remove a tumor from a 72-year-old man, but when lunchtime arrived, the doctor left for a meal. Fifteen minutes later, the nurse anesthetist also left, resulting in the patient’s death.
A nurse from the orthopedic department was called to replace the absent doctor and nurse. Unfortunately, she lacked the necessary training to notice that the patient’s respirator was off or to handle the sudden bleeding. By the time the doctor and nurse returned from lunch, the patient had been without oxygen for eight minutes and later died from brain damage.
2. An Intoxicated Anesthetist Causes the Death of a New Mother
On September 26, 2014, Helga Wauters, a Belgian anesthetist, began her shift at a private French clinic where she had worked for only two weeks. Despite her experience since 1994, her actions that day were catastrophic. When 28-year-old Xynthia Hawke went into labor, Wauters was assigned to administer pain relief. Tragically, Wauters’ drunken state led to Hawke’s death.
After administering an epidural to Hawke, Wauters left to have drinks with friends. Complications during labor necessitated a C-section, requiring her to insert a tube into Hawke’s trachea for additional medication. Upon returning, Wauters smelled of alcohol and appeared disoriented, yet she was permitted to continue. She mistakenly inserted the tube into Hawke’s esophagus, triggering a heart attack. Hawke died four days later, though her baby survived.
Investigations revealed Wauters had a severe alcohol addiction, evidenced by 17 empty vodka bottles found in her home. She confessed to drinking a glass of rosé after the epidural and consuming a vodka-water mix the night of the procedure. She weakly defended her actions, claiming alcohol reduced her cognitive abilities by 30% but steadied her hands. Tests showed her blood alcohol level was nearly five times the legal limit the day after the incident.
Initially denied bail after her arrest, Wauters was later granted release by the court under strict conditions: she had to pay 50,000 euros, remain in France, cease medical practice, and enroll in a rehabilitation program.
1. A Physician Illegally Records Patients During Pelvic Exams
Dr. Nikita A. Levy, a gynecologist and obstetrician at Baltimore’s prestigious Johns Hopkins Community Medicine, worked there for 25 years. For at least eight years, he used a concealed camera pen to secretly record the pelvic exams of his patients. His actions were exposed in 2013 when a colleague reported suspicions about his pen.
Law enforcement, called in by the hospital, discovered more than 1,200 videos and images dating back to at least 2005. Over his 25-year tenure at the clinic, Levy had treated an astonishing 12,692 women, all considered potential victims. The hospital was compelled to notify each of them about the severe breach of privacy.
Investigators found no proof that Levy recorded the exams for purposes beyond personal use, but the violation was deeply distressing for his victims. Some women reported avoiding medical visits or refusing to take their children to doctors after learning of Levy’s actions. A class-action lawsuit ensued, and Johns Hopkins settled by paying $190 million to over 7,000 affected patients. Levy’s own fate was grim: ten days after his crimes were exposed, he wrote an apology letter to his wife and took his own life using helium and a plastic bag.
