Buzz
Death is an undeniable part of life, one that is impossible to predict or avoid. It is indifferent to age, ethnicity, marital status, or religion, and often arrives when least expected.
Regardless of when it occurs, the experience of death inevitably brings immense sorrow and grief to those left behind, as they struggle to adapt to a world without those they loved.
Picture yourself at a wake, hearing odd noises emanating from the coffin or being informed of a loved one's passing, only to later witness unmistakable signs of life. At first, you might wonder if this is simply a mistake or if your longing for their return has led to an illusion.
Now, imagine discovering that what you heard or saw was not a mistake but rather a tragic error in the declaration of death.
This compilation features truly unfortunate yet very real incidents of a similar nature. Here are ten individuals who were mistakenly declared dead but were, in fact, still alive.
10. Bella Montoya
On June 9, 2023, seventy-six-year-old Bella Montoya, a retired nurse from Babahoyo, Ecuador, was rushed to the emergency room after possibly suffering a stroke and cardiopulmonary arrest, which caused her to lose consciousness. Despite resuscitation attempts, Montoya failed to respond and was declared deceased a few hours later.
Montoya’s body was transferred to a funeral home on the same day, and her family began preparing for a wake later that evening. However, to the astonishment of everyone present, about five hours into the wake, strange noises were heard coming from Montoya’s coffin.
Upon opening the casket, Montoya was discovered, still alive, wrapped in sheets, breathing heavily. In a state of shock, her family immediately rushed her back to the hospital, where she was intubated and placed in intensive care.
It is believed that when Montoya experienced cardiorespiratory arrest, she also began suffering from catalepsy, a trance-like condition that leads to a loss of voluntary movement, muscle stiffness, insensitivity to pain, and slowed breathing. Unfortunately, this combination of symptoms may have contributed to the mistaken declaration of her death.
The health ministry has initiated an investigation into the doctors who treated Montoya, and a technical committee has been formed to assess the hospital's procedures for issuing death certificates. Tragically, Montoya passed away a week later after suffering a stroke while hospitalized.
9. Sammy Berko
On January 7, 2023, 16-year-old Sammy Berko from Missouri City, Texas, visited a local rock-climbing gym with friends. After reaching the summit and ringing the bell, Berko suddenly became 'completely limp.'
He was gently lowered to the ground and given CPR until emergency responders arrived. Berko was then taken to a nearby hospital, where doctors continued their efforts with CPR. Sadly, after two hours of unsuccessful attempts, Berko was declared dead.
Berko’s parents, Jen and Craig, were preparing to say their final goodbyes to their son. However, just five minutes later, something incredible occurred—Berko began to move.
The attending physician initially dismissed the movement as a mere reflex, but when Jen noticed Berko’s carotid artery pulsing, Craig exclaimed about Berko’s heartbeat and urgently called for medical help. The staff quickly responded and, fortunately, managed to stabilize him.
Berko suffered an ischemic spinal injury from being lowered down the rock wall and experienced short-term memory loss due to insufficient oxygen to his brain. Additionally, he was left with paralysis from the waist down.
It was later revealed that Berko had a rare genetic disorder known as catecholaminergic polymorphic ventricular tachycardia (CPTV), a hereditary heart condition that causes abnormal heart rhythms during physical activity or intense emotions when adrenaline levels surge. If untreated, it can even cause the heart to stop. Testing showed that Berko’s mother also has the condition, as does his younger brother Frankie, who tragically passed away in 2020 after suffering from seizures.
Berko later underwent a procedure called a sympathectomy and was prescribed medication to reduce the risk of an adrenaline surge leading to cardiac arrest in the future.
8. Tony Yahle
In the early hours of August 5, 2013, 37-year-old Tony Yahle, a diesel mechanic from West Carrollton, Ohio, began breathing abnormally. Unable to rouse him, his wife Melissa called 911, and Yahle was rushed to a local hospital by ambulance.
Sadly, Yahle’s heart fell into a fatal arrhythmia, and despite 45 minutes of resuscitation efforts by medical staff, he was declared dead. A cardiologist confirmed the time of death and suggested that Yahle’s family say their final goodbyes.
At that moment, Yahle’s son Lawrence pointed at his father and said, 'Dad, you’re not going to die today.' As Lawrence turned to leave and rejoin the family, Yahle began to show signs of life, and his heartbeat miraculously returned, just moments before his body was about to be sent to the morgue.
Yahle was airlifted to another hospital, where he spent five days in a coma before fully regaining consciousness. Despite extensive testing, doctors could not determine what caused his heart to stop, as no heart defects were found. Yahle was discharged from the hospital on August 15, 2013, with no further complications.
7. Sreekesh Kumar
On November 18, 2021, 40-year-old Sreekesh Kumar was struck by a speeding motorcycle in Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh, India, resulting in a severe head injury. After receiving initial treatment at a private hospital, Kumar was referred to multiple other hospitals, ultimately visiting three in total in search of further care.
Upon reaching a district hospital, Kumar was examined by doctors multiple times. However, after finding no signs of a heartbeat, pulse, or blood pressure, he was declared dead. His body was then sent to the mortuary freezer.
About seven hours later, as Kumar’s family met with police officers to identify his body and discuss an autopsy, his sister-in-law, Madhu Bala, noticed his cheeks were warm and recognized signs of life. The doctors were quickly notified, and Kumar was transferred to a health center in Meerut.
The unusual situation surrounding Kumar's death declaration is believed to have been caused by 'suspended animation,' a condition where the body’s life functions slow down or stop. Furthermore, due to power issues in the mortuary freezer, the intermittent shutdown and restart may have contributed to saving Kumar’s life during the time he spent inside.
However, due to the severity of his internal head injuries, Kumar slipped into a coma upon arrival at the health center in Meerut. Additionally, he suffered from a bleeding disorder, making surgery impossible. As a result, he was placed on a ventilator and given medication. Tragically, after five days, Kumar passed away due to a clot in his brain.
6. Mackayala Jespersen
On November 7, 2003, 20-month-old Mackayala Jespersen wandered out the sliding glass door and into her home's backyard, where the pool was, after her mother briefly left the living room to wake her four-year-old sister. Unfortunately, Jespersen’s mother later found her face down in the pool.
In a desperate attempt to save her daughter, Jespersen’s mother jumped into the pool, pulled her out, and called 911. When officers arrived, they began performing CPR, a procedure continued by the paramedics when they arrived. Jespersen was then rushed to a local hospital.
In the emergency room, doctors continued efforts to resuscitate Jespersen with CPR, breathing tubes, and a heated blanket. However, after her heart monitor showed a flatline for about an hour following her discovery in the pool, she was disconnected from the breathing tube and officially pronounced dead.
Forty minutes after Jespersen was declared dead, detectives began photographing her body and taking notes. As they worked, they noticed her chest moving. Initially, the detectives thought it was simply a natural reaction to the body releasing gas. However, as the spasms grew longer and more pronounced, the detectives sought assistance from medical staff, who were fortunately able to revive Jespersen.
Although Jespersen survived the traumatic incident, she suffered severe brain damage due to the extended period of oxygen deprivation. Subsequently, Jespersen’s family filed a medical malpractice lawsuit against both the hospital and the physician who had treated her.
5. Thomas Maxwell
In the early hours of February 15, 2023, 43-year-old Phebe Maxwell heard a thud coming from her father, 66-year-old Thomas Maxwell’s bedroom. When she went to check on him, she found him lying on the floor. She offered assistance, but assuming his fall was related to sciatica, her father assured her he could get up and return to bed on his own shortly.
However, when Phebe checked on her father again around 10 a.m., she found him in the same position. This time, his lips were blue, and his body was cold. Panicking, Phebe immediately began CPR while her mother called 911.
When paramedics arrived at the home in Clearwater, Florida, they found Maxwell unresponsive, with no pulse, no breath, and his body cold to the touch. After evaluating his condition, they declared him dead.
Despite their conclusion, Phebe heard noises coming from her father and insisted that he was still alive. The paramedics dismissed her claims, stating that the sounds were merely the body releasing gases. After the sheriff’s department arrived, the paramedics departed.
Fortunately, when one of the sergeants entered Maxwell’s room, he pulled back the sheet covering his body and heard him gasp for air. Not only was Maxwell breathing, but he also had a pulse. At that point, a different emergency team was called, bringing a defibrillator before transporting Maxwell to the hospital.
Upon arrival at the hospital, doctors determined that Maxwell had suffered cardiac arrest, respiratory failure, and injuries to his kidneys, arteries, and lungs. He was placed on a ventilator and induced into a coma. Maxwell regained consciousness on February 17, 2023, and after a week in the ICU, he was released to go home.
The two paramedics who initially responded to Maxwell’s home were later dismissed due to their negligent handling of the situation.
4. Torianto 'Junior' Brinson
On September 26, 2021, 15-year-old Torianto 'Junior' Brinson was in a car accident in Missouri City, Texas, where he was ejected from the vehicle.
Emergency responders found Brinson unresponsive, with no breathing or movement, and he was quickly transported by Life Flight to a nearby hospital, where he was declared dead.
However, Brinson's mother, La’Kisha Wells, 39, refused to accept the heartbreaking news and began praying over her son. As she held his hand and prayed, she witnessed a movement, enough to get him taken into surgery.
Brinson sustained significant brain damage from the crash and underwent four brain surgeries. He remained in a coma for 21 days and in a semi-coma for several months before being moved to a rehabilitation facility, where he had to relearn basic skills like brushing his teeth, bathing, and eating.
Less than a year later, the teenager once declared 'dead' was not only recovering well but excelling in his studies and playing on his high school basketball team.
3. Hamdi Hafez al-Nubi
In May 2012, 28-year-old Hamdi Hafez al-Nubi, a waiter in Luxor, Egypt, suffered a heart attack while working and was declared dead at the hospital. On May 11, his family brought him home to prepare his body for burial.
The process of Ghusl Mayyit, part of Islamic tradition, is carried out by close family members of the same gender. The deceased's body is washed with soap and water in a specific manner, maintaining dignity and privacy before being wrapped in a clean white cloth.
During this ritual of washing, shrouding, and burial, it is believed that three things occur: the body returns to the earth, the soul faces judgment, and the living are reminded of their finite time on Earth.
Imagine the shock of the family when, after completing burial preparations, a doctor arrived to sign Hafez al-Nubi's death certificate and discovered his body was still warm. Upon further examination, it was revealed that he was, in fact, alive.
Naturally, when Hafez al-Nubi’s mother heard the news, she fainted. Thankfully, she was revived as well, and what had initially been a somber occasion transformed into one of joy and celebration.
2. Jamie Ogg
After three years of trying to conceive, Kate Ogg from Sydney, Australia, became pregnant with twins. However, in March 2010, she gave birth prematurely at 27 weeks to twins, Emily and Jamie.
While Emily survived the early birth, Jamie had stopped breathing, and his heartbeat was nearly undetectable. Doctors battled for 20 minutes to revive him, but when their efforts failed, Jamie was declared dead.
As Ogg held Jamie on her bare chest, and she and her husband David began to say their goodbyes, Jamie started to make small, sudden movements that became increasingly noticeable. Despite this, the doctor maintained that these movements were merely reflexive, reaffirming his previous declaration of death.
Two hours later, Jamie's eyes opened, and at that moment, the couple began to doubt the doctor's conclusion. Soon after, Jamie reached for their fingers and even accepted a small amount of breastmilk from Ogg's fingertip.
Even in the face of these clear signs of life, both the medical staff and the doctor refused to acknowledge that Jamie might still be alive. In a desperate move to get the doctor’s attention, the Oggs claimed they had finally accepted their son’s death, knowing he would come back to check on Jamie.
When the doctor returned, he used a stethoscope to listen to Jamie's chest and was stunned to hear signs of life. The hospital staff immediately sprang into action, and after 80 days in the neonatal unit, both Jamie and Emily were able to return home. Miraculously, Jamie showed no lasting medical issues.
The Oggs attribute Jamie's survival to the practice of 'kangaroo care,' a method where parents hold their baby skin-to-skin to generate warmth, which they believe played a key role in saving Jamie's life.
1. Gonzalo Montoya Jiménez
On January 7, 2018, twenty-nine-year-old Gonzalo Montoya Jiménez, who had been serving a two-and-a-half-year sentence for robbery at the Villabona Penitentiary Center in Asturias, Spain, failed to report for the daily headcount. Later, he was discovered unconscious in a chair in his cell, showing no signs of life.
Given the presence of cyanosis (a condition causing the skin, lips, or nails to turn blue due to a lack of oxygen), discoloration of his face, and rigor mortis, Jiménez was declared dead by three forensic doctors who examined his body.
However, four hours later, as Jiménez lay on the morgue slab with his body already marked for an autopsy, he unexpectedly began snoring. This unusual sound caught the attention of the pathologist, revealing that Jiménez was still alive. He was immediately rushed to the emergency room, placed in intensive care, and eventually regained consciousness.
Jiménez’s family later revealed that he had epilepsy and suspected that he may not have been properly managing his medication. While his epilepsy could have triggered a cataleptic state, placing him in a trance-like condition, neither this nor the other conditions were conclusively identified as the cause of his earlier death ruling.
