Buzz
Many brilliant artists and thinkers have faced the harsh reality of their greatest achievements being ignored or criticized during their lifetimes. These authors poured their hearts into their works, only to see them dismissed or misunderstood by contemporary audiences.
10. Moby-Dick by Herman Melville
Herman Melville's Moby-Dick, now celebrated as a cornerstone of American literature, was a commercial failure during his lifetime. Despite its profound impact on modern literary studies and its frequent appearances in popular culture, the novel sold a mere 3,715 copies, paling in comparison to Melville's earlier successes like Typee (16,300 copies) and Omoo (13,300 copies). Critics of the time were unsparing, with The Charleston Southern Quarterly Review delivering particularly scathing remarks about the book and its creator.
“Mr. Melville’s portrayal of Quakers is utterly pitiful, and his Mad Captain is an insufferable bore. The ramblings of the captain, along with other characters and even Melville himself, intended to be profound, come across as nonsensical drivel that could warrant a writ de lunatico against everyone involved.”
Melville’s death went largely unnoticed, with only one newspaper briefly mentioning him as a “long-forgotten author.” It wasn’t until years later that his brilliance was acknowledged, and Moby-Dick, his greatest work, was finally recognized as the masterpiece he always knew it to be.
9. The Sound and the Fury by William Faulkner
Now considered a groundbreaking work by one of the 20th century’s most celebrated authors, The Sound and the Fury captures the decline of a distinguished Southern family while pioneering innovative narrative styles. Despite its current acclaim, the book initially received mixed reviews, with one critic stating, 'The intentional complexity of the opening pages deters rather than engages readers.'
Faulkner held an immense personal attachment to the novel, firmly convinced it was his crowning achievement. His literary agent, Ben Wasson, recounted how Faulkner handed over the manuscript with the bold declaration, 'This is the finest work I will ever create.'
Despite Faulkner’s unwavering confidence in his magnum opus, the novel received a lukewarm reception upon its release. His fourth work struggled commercially until the publication of his sixth novel, Sanctuary, which Faulkner admitted was penned purely to address his financial struggles.
8. On the Road by Jack Kerouac
Today, On the Road is celebrated as the defining work of the Beat Generation, with Jack Kerouac as its iconic figure. However, when Kerouac initially penned the novel, it faced rejection from multiple publishers. Despite being turned down by at least six publishing houses, Kerouac remained undeterred in his writing pursuits.
In the early 1950s, Kerouac had only one published work, The Town and the City, and completed five significant novels that garnered no interest. Adding to his frustration, contemporaries like Allen Ginsberg and William S. Burroughs, who were inspired by Kerouac’s free-flowing prose, achieved quicker success. Kerouac expressed his exasperation in a letter to his agent, asking, 'Why don’t they recognize my talent?'
Eventually, On the Road was published, and Kerouac’s spontaneous writing style was praised as groundbreaking by some, while others dismissed it. Ginsberg suggested that the CIA might have influenced the negative reception, pointing to CIA-funded literary magazines like Encounter. He remarked, 'They viewed Kerouac’s candid wit, Whitman-like beauty, and personal honesty as unsettling, subjective, and egotistical or irresponsible. It reflects a narrow-minded, conservative mindset.'
As Kerouac’s fame grew, his earlier works were also published, but this led to further criticism of his spontaneous style, with critics accusing him of hastily producing novels.
7. The Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov
Spanning 12 years from 1928 to 1940, The Master and Margarita remained unpublished until 1967. When it finally saw the light of day, the Soviet authorities heavily censored and altered the text due to its contentious themes.
Bulgakov emerged as a polarizing figure in Soviet society. Although Joseph Stalin admired his play, The Days of the Turbins, most of Bulgakov’s works were banned as the ideological climate grew increasingly restrictive. Aware that his magnum opus would never be published under such conditions, Bulgakov tragically burned an early draft of the manuscript—a moment mirrored within the novel itself.
Bulgakov’s wife, widely believed to have inspired the character Margarita, safeguarded the manuscript for years after his death, ensuring its eventual publication. Today, it is regarded as one of the 20th century’s literary masterpieces, though it narrowly escaped being lost forever.
6. Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad
Though now regarded as Conrad’s most influential work, Heart of Darkness was largely ignored upon its initial release. Published alongside two other novellas, it garnered the least attention, with one reviewer who admired Conrad dismissing it as a 'minor work' and critiquing its 'overuse of adjectives to describe an ineffable and enigmatic mystery.'
The novella’s ambiguity, which initially drew criticism, is now the very reason for its lasting acclaim. While it struggled to gain popularity in its time, its themes have become a staple in literature curricula. Its endurance may be partly due to Chinua Achebe’s critique in An Image of Africa: Racism in Conrad’s Heart of Darkness, or perhaps its adaptation into the film Apocalypse Now, starring Marlon Brando as Kurtz and Martin Sheen as the reimagined Marlow.
5. Catch-22 by Joseph Heller
The 1961 New York Times review captures the essence of the critique: 'Catch-22 is filled with passion, both humorous and intense, but it falters due to a lack of structure and coherence. It’s a mix of character sketches, anecdotes—some of them brilliant—and well-crafted scenes, but it doesn’t come together as a novel. The material, focusing on the antics and struggles of an American bomber squadron in World War II Italy, feels repetitive and overly long. Alternatively, it could be seen as too short, as none of its intriguing characters or plotlines are developed enough to take center stage. Joseph Heller is like a talented artist who crams every idea from his sketchbook onto one canvas, relying on their charm and shock value to make up for the absence of a cohesive design.'
The New York Times wasn’t alone in its criticism. Roger H. Smith’s review dismissed Catch-22, stating, 'its author cannot write,' while John W. Aldridge condemned it as 'completely shapeless, pornographic, and immoral,' criticizing its anti-establishment stance and rejection of widely accepted values.
Although many of Heller’s peers appreciated Catch-22, few foresaw its eventual status as a cornerstone of American literature, now a staple in academic curricula.
4. The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald
When it was first published, Fitzgerald’s most renowned novel was described as 'a confusing and garish spectacle.' The Saturday Review was particularly harsh, stating that Fitzgerald 'deserves a good shaking. Here is undeniable talent that shamelessly parades itself in a chaotic manner. The Great Gatsby is an absurd tale, whether viewed as a romance, melodrama, or a straightforward depiction of New York’s elite.' Despite the publisher’s promotional efforts, the book struggled to sell, receiving largely mixed reviews.
Over time, The Great Gatsby has gained immense popularity, with its iconic protagonist brought to life by legendary actors like Robert Redford and Leonardo DiCaprio. The novel has also been adapted into film six times, cementing its place in cultural history.
If The Great Gatsby had achieved its current acclaim during Fitzgerald’s lifetime, he might have devoted more energy to writing novels, which he considered his true calling. Alternatively, given his extravagant lifestyle, he could have easily wasted any extra income on his luxurious habits.
3. Walden by Henry David Thoreau
Thoreau’s seminal work sold only 2,000 copies in its first five years, and the initial reception was mixed. Robert Louis Stevenson notably criticized Thoreau’s retreat to the woods as 'womanish solicitude,' describing it as 'unmanly, almost cowardly.'
Today, however, the opening line, 'I went to the woods,' is instantly recognizable, with many able to complete the famous quote: 'because I wished to live deliberately, to front only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived.'
Walden has been repeatedly referenced in popular culture and is celebrated as one of the most significant literary works ever penned. John Updike remarked that Walden has become a symbol of the back-to-nature, preservationist, anti-business, and civil-disobedience ethos, with Thoreau himself idolized as a protester, eccentric, and hermit saint. However, Updike cautioned that the book risks being 'as revered and unread as the Bible.' Among the American classics of the mid-19th century—Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter (1850), Melville’s Moby-Dick (1851), Whitman’s Leaves of Grass (1855), alongside Harriet Beecher Stowe’s Uncle Tom’s Cabin (1854) and Emerson’s essays—Walden has profoundly shaped America’s self-perception.
2. The Metamorphosis and Other Stories by Franz Kafka
Kafka’s work only gained significant recognition after World War II, long after his death. His writings resonated deeply with readers in the 1960s, particularly those living under oppressive communist regimes in Eastern Europe.
Although The Metamorphosis was published during Kafka’s lifetime, it failed to attract much attention. Kafka himself was critical of the novella, stating after finishing it, 'I am now reading The Metamorphosis at home and find it bad.' He expressed strong dislike for the story, particularly its 'unreadable ending.'
Much of Kafka's work saw the light of day posthumously, narrowly escaping destruction. Following his final wishes would have led to the burning of his unpublished manuscripts. Although 'The Metamorphosis' appeared in a literary journal in 1915, well before his passing in 1924, it initially failed to garner the acclaim it enjoys today.
1. Lolita by Vladimir Nabokov
'Lolita' faced rejection from five prominent publishing houses, including Viking and Doubleday. The book review editor of the 'Chicago Tribune's Magazine of Books' dismissed it outright, labeling it as obscene and refusing to feature it.
Ironically, the controversial nature of 'Lolita' propelled it into the spotlight. The story, centered on a 12-year-old nymphet—a term coined by Nabokov—was deemed scandalous, and scandal often drives sales. While numerous publishers shunned 'Lolita' due to its provocative content, this very quality garnered widespread attention and, ultimately, the recognition that Nabokov and his masterpiece rightly deserved.
Nabokov's literary talents remained a topic of debate even after his passing. His 'New York Times' obituary highlighted that while readers acknowledged his technical prowess and command of form, they were often perplexed by his playful irreverence and love for parody. The question lingered: Was he merely a skilled craftsman enchanted by whimsy, or a deeply creative and profound artist?
