Buzz
We often have a fixed idea of what a detective should be. Sherlock Holmes, with his methodical, intellectual approach, gave us the archetypal gentleman detective. In contrast, the early 20th century pulps introduced tough, hard-boiled detectives with fedoras, cigarettes, and gritty street smarts. More recently, modern television has brought forward detectives who rely on cutting-edge technology, using DNA analysis, enhanced images from blurry CCTV footage, and even the occasional interrogation tactics. However, the world of detective fiction is more diverse than we might realize.
10. Zenigata Heiji
Created by Japanese author and music critic Nomura Kodo (1882–1963), Zenigata Heiji was a police officer in the Edo period. Living in modest quarters, he served as a goyokiki, a humble assistant to a higher-ranking doshin (police officer) named Sasano.
Not being a samurai, Zenigata Heiji was forbidden to wield a sword. Instead, he would hurl heavy coins with bullet-like precision to incapacitate his foes or use a jutte (a large truncheon) to disarm criminals non-lethally. While the latter was grounded in historical truth, the former was a dramatic literary creation that helped define the character.
Zenigata Heiji gained recognition not only for his sharp deductive skills but also for his compassionate nature. He often saw criminals through a lens of sympathy, though he condemned their actions. His true allegiance lay with the common folk, not the elite samurai class, who frequently dismissed him as a failure despite his many accomplishments.
Despite his strengths, Zenigata Heiji was far from flawless, struggling with vices such as excessive drinking and smoking. Much of his knowledge of crimes came from his trusted associate, Hachigoro, who played the role of a Watson to his Holmes, keeping him informed with the latest gossip and rumors from the everyday people.
Zenigata Heiji would later rise to fame in historical television dramas known as jidai-geki, where feudal lawmen and their investigations became a staple of the genre, much like sheriffs in American westerns.
9. Papa LaBas
Papa LaBas, a creation of African-American author Ishmael Reed, appears in the novels Mumbo Jumbo (1972) and The Last Days of Louisiana Red (1974). A private investigator who refers to himself as a “jacklegged detective of the metaphysical,” he operates in New Orleans, using hoodoo as his method for solving crimes.
His workplace is known as the Mumbo Jumbo Kathedral, a place where “jewelry, black astrology charts, herbs, potions, candles, talismans” are crafted. People trust his powers, having witnessed him perform feats like knocking a glass off a table simply by staring at it, or filling a room with the sounds of forest creatures. He presents a memorable image, often seen wearing “his frock coat, opera hat, smoked glasses and carrying a cane.”
The character of Papa LaBas draws inspiration from the Haitian loa Papa Legba, who is the descendant of the West African god Eshu/Elegbara, the lord of transitions. Eshu is both a trickster deity and a mediator of communication.
Some critics interpret the character of Papa LaBas as a critique by Reed of Western rationalism as the sole path to truth. They describe the first novel as an “anti-detective” story, celebrating the mystery rather than solving it. These works are influenced by Reed’s philosophy of neo-hoodoo, a jazz-infused prose style that embraces multiple narratives and perspectives while challenging traditional norms.
8. Inspector O
James Church is the pen name of a CIA intelligence officer who spent three decades working in East Asia. Drawing from this experience, he introduced the character of Inspector O in his 2006 novel A Corpse in the Koryo.
Inspector O is a brilliant detective in North Korea, navigating a corrupt, paranoid, and Kafkaesque environment while trying to solve crimes. Church has explained that the novels aim to depict how a smart, logical individual must act in a country like North Korea. Despite O’s skepticism toward the government, his investigations are constantly thwarted by the oppressive bureaucracy and limited resources, with much of the first novel centered around his quest for a simple cup of tea.
“The character had to reflect the true nature of North Korea,” Church shared in an interview with The Independent. “It’s crucial to humanize the situation and capture my experience of real individuals facing real problems in North Korea, compounded by the additional challenge of living under a system that applies immense pressure on them.”
Many of the cases Inspector O investigates often unravel into complex plots, intrigue, and deep connections to North Korean politics and history. For example, a bank robbery becomes linked to a potential coup, while the murder of a diplomat’s wife in Pakistan eventually ties back to the North Korean famine of the 1990s. While the Kim family is never directly named, their influence is felt as a constant, looming presence referred to as 'the center.'
Church keeps his pseudonym to maintain the ability to travel to North Korea without detection, allowing him to observe everyday life for his fictional work. As he mentioned to The Independent:
People warned me that if I got arrested, they’d take me to an interrogation room, and I’d learn a lot about interrogation techniques. I told them I didn’t want to do that. Half of it is imagination, and the other half is piecing together what I know about how North Korean [authorities] operate, how unsettling it can be in some instances, and how it sometimes works against itself. I’ve worked in bureaucracy for years, so it’s not just specific to Korea.
7. Lord Darcy
Randall Garrett, a science fiction author now somewhat forgotten, was once considered one of the leading creators of his era during the mid-20th century. His most lasting contribution was the character of Lord Darcy, an occult detective from a parallel reality where Richard the Lionhearted didn’t die in 1199. Instead, he lived on to build a powerful Anglo-French empire under the Plantagenet dynasty, which survived into the 20th century.
Serving under the Duke of Normandy, Lord Darcy operated in a universe governed by the rules of magic, which he used to solve crimes in much the same way Sherlock Holmes employed scientific reasoning.
According to legend, the creation of Lord Darcy was the result of a bet between Isaac Asimov and Garrett. Asimov doubted that a “fair-play” detective story could be set in a science fiction or fantasy world, arguing that the detective would inevitably resort to advanced technology or magical devices to crack the case. Garrett disagreed and crafted a fantasy universe where magic followed strict, well-defined laws, projecting psychic power with clear limitations.
Chief Forensic Sorcerer Master Sean O’Lochlainn, who assists Lord Darcy, is skilled at determining when a crime has been committed using mundane methods instead of magical ones. Thus, while Lord Darcy employs alchemy and sorcery in his investigations, he also depends on logical reasoning and analysis to uncover the truth. This may explain why the stories were published in the science fiction magazine Analog, which generally did not feature works of pure fantasy.
6. Omar Yussef Sirhan
Matt Rees, a Welsh journalist and former Jerusalem bureau chief for Time magazine, dedicated nearly a decade to studying the Israel-Palestine conflict. This deep knowledge led him to write Cain’s Field: Faith, Fratricide, and Fear in the Middle East. He later channeled his extensive experience into creating the character of Palestinian detective Omar Yussef Sirhan, who first appeared in his 2006 novel The Bethlehem Murders, followed by three more captivating mysteries.
As an Arab nationalist and history educator, Sirhan is an unlikely candidate for criminal investigations. He relies on his intelligence, moral reasoning, and the power of his clan’s reputation to confront more violent adversaries. His appearance is unique, as he navigates refugee camps with a purple briefcase, wearing impeccably tailored clothes, a comb-over, and mauve shoes. His protection stems from his membership in the Sirhan clan, which includes members of Hamas, Fatah, and other Palestinian political factions.
Rees has earned praise for telling distinctly Palestinian stories. While Israelis are an inevitable presence in the background, they are not the focal point of the investigations. Rees, leveraging his deep understanding of Palestine, gave depth to Sirhan’s character, while also infusing the novels with Palestinian cultural influences—ranging from direct translations of local expressions to rich descriptions of the region’s cuisine. His works have been applauded for addressing complex political and historical issues through the perspective of a determined and analytical detective.
5. Jim Chee And Joe Leaphorn
Born in 1925 as a second-generation German in Oklahoma, Tony Hillerman grew up surrounded by classmates from the Pottawatomie and Seminole tribes. After his World War II service and a career as a journalist and editor, he authored The Blessing Way in 1970, the first book in his Navajo series. This book introduced Joe Leaphorn, a world-weary and cynical Navajo detective.
In 1980, Hillerman wrote People of Darkness, introducing the idealistic Jim Chee. The two detectives came together in the 1986 novel Skinwalkers. Hillerman eventually wrote a total of 16 novels focused on his Navajo detectives.
The two detectives offer different views on Navajo tradition. Chee embraces traditional rituals and songs, even training to become a yataalii (medicine man) to uphold his culture. Leaphorn, however, is more skeptical, having studied archaeology and law enforcement techniques, yet he still respects his heritage.
Despite his disbelief in witches, Leaphorn's involvement in a murder-suicide case, where a man killed three ‘skinwalkers’ (people who can transform into animals), forces him to recognize that these supernatural beliefs can have real-world consequences. This tension between the traditional Navajo perspective and the logic of detective work is a recurring theme in the series.
In the 1980s and 1990s, Hillerman faced criticism for depicting outsiders as the primary threat to the Navajo people, with one journalist commenting, 'It’s the alcohol, stupid!' Others accused him of exploiting Navajo culture for personal profit.
Despite facing criticism, Hillerman's novels gained significant popularity among readers in the Navajo nation. It was soon discovered that he had been donating a portion of his earnings to various projects on Navajo reservations, though he kept this quiet. In 1987, the Navajo Tribal Council honored him with the Special Friend of the Dineh Award.
The Navajo Times reported that Navajo police officials had encountered non-Native Americans visiting reservation police stations, eager to meet Leaphorn and Chee, unaware that these characters were purely fictional.
4. Emil Tischbein
Erich Kastner's children’s novel Emil and the Detectives was published in Weimar Germany in 1929. The story follows 10-year-old Emil Tischbein, who is sent to Berlin by his poor, widowed mother to stay with relatives. While on the train, his money is stolen, and instead of turning to the police, he decides to track down the thief himself, with the help of a group of schoolchildren.
The children form a complex network of spies, couriers, and telephone lines to catch the thief. The novel became an instant classic across Germany and Europe, inspiring later works like Enid Blyton’s The Famous Five and The Secret Seven.
A film adaptation was made in 1931. Critics lauded Kastner for pioneering a new genre of children's literature that took young people seriously, highlighting their distinct qualities. The novel's success also sparked the emergence of juvenile detective literature as a recognized genre. One critic even argued that the book represented the 'democratization of German civic life,' depicting Berlin as a city where civil liberties thrive, which, ironically, would become painfully evident only a decade later.
3. Bony
British-born Australian author Arthur Upfield wrote a series of novels from the 1920s to the 1960s centered on the adventures of Napoleon Bonaparte, known as 'Bony,' a half-Aboriginal detective. Abandoned as a child by his Aboriginal mother and white father, Bony was raised by a matron at a mission station, who named him after the renowned leader Napoleon Bonaparte, a man of power, mystery, and achievement.
A brilliant student, Bony eventually returns to his mother's people and undergoes initiation into their tribe. After assisting the police with a murder investigation in the outback, he joins the Queensland police and ascends to the position of detective inspector.
Though often feeling like an outsider, Bony is accepted by both Aboriginal people and whites who are unaware of his mixed heritage. This duality isolates him from both sides but allows him to navigate both worlds effortlessly, solving complex puzzles and mysteries others cannot. His deductive abilities are enhanced by traditional Aboriginal techniques for reading the land and interpreting traces left by animals, weather, and human activity.
In 1970, Fauna Productions attempted to adapt the Napoleon Bonaparte series into a television show, believing that a half-Aboriginal detective embodied a quintessentially Australian concept. However, the series faced strong criticism from Aboriginal groups for casting a white New Zealander, James Laurenson, to portray the lead character while wearing dark makeup, rather than casting an Aboriginal actor.
2. Elias Contreras And Hector Belascoaran Shayne
Set in Chiapas, the most impoverished region of Mexico and home to the Zapatista movement, The Uncomfortable Dead is a Mexican detective thriller. Elias Contreras, a Zapatista fighter, also serves as the official detective investigating a series of missing persons. Despite being deceased, Contreras takes on the role of narrator, offering a unique perspective on the unfolding investigation.
Contreras is accompanied by Hector Belascoaran Shayne, a tough, one-eyed private detective. The novel is filled with philosophical musings and political commentary, set against a vivid and chaotic backdrop. With a narrative that features loose storylines, a host of strange and sometimes supernatural characters, it creates a story that blends detective fiction with magical realism, deeply rooted in Mexico's violent and politically charged history.
Paco Ignacio Taibo II and Subcomandante Marcos joined forces to write this narrative. Taibo, a Spanish-born Mexican author, is known for his crime series featuring Hector Belascoaran Shayne. Subcomandante Marcos, a political writer, is widely believed to be the alias of Rafael Sebastian Guillen Vicente, the founder of the Zapatista Army of National Liberation. Marcos is famously known for only appearing in public wearing a ski mask and carrying a deformed rooster, which he claims represents 'all disenfranchised people.'
1. Hanno Stiffeniis
Michael Gregorio is the pen name for the husband-and-wife duo, Michael Jacob and Daniela De Gregorio, not to be confused with the French comedian of the same name. Together, they created Hanno Stiffeniis, a rural Prussian magistrate in the time of the Napoleonic Wars, who faces a series of unusual and mysterious crimes.
The authors' debut novel, A Critique of Criminal Reason, forced Stiffeniis to confront a string of bizarre murders attributed to the Devil in the city of Konigsberg. He sought the assistance of philosopher Immanuel Kant. Subsequent stories saw the tenacious Prussian detective tackle challenges such as enduring the shame of French occupation, pursuing a serial killer along the Baltic coast, and dealing with a vampire craze sparked by the discovery of a drained body.
The couple chose the Prussian backdrop for its unique and rich historical significance, though it has since disappeared. Konigsberg, the setting for their first novel, is now Kaliningrad, home to a Russian nuclear submarine base. Although their works are grounded in extensive historical research, the authors often weave fictional elements: 'Our Prussia is a Grimm-inspired literary fantasy.'
