Buzz
At Mytour, we've explored our fair share of unsolved enigmas. There's a unique thrill in unraveling clues that have long stumped investigators. Some mysteries that once seemed impossible to crack are no longer a mystery. Today, we're revisiting these cases to uncover how the puzzle pieces finally fell into place when they were solved.
10. Lori Ruff’s Real Identity
In 2004, Blake Ruff married the woman he believed to be the love of his life, a lady named Lori Kennedy. Lori, a private individual, refused to discuss her past, and most who knew her accepted her silence as a part of her character. However, after Lori's tragic suicide in 2010, the Ruff family discovered a box that revealed an entirely different story: since 1988, she had been living under a false identity stolen from a deceased girl.
When Lori’s story gained widespread attention, Colleen Fitzpatrick, a genetic genealogist, volunteered to help crack the case. Her investigation led police to the Cassidy family. The Cassidys had a daughter named Kimberly McLean, who had run away in 1986 after a heated argument with her parents about their divorce. Upon seeing Lori’s photo, a family member exclaimed, “My God, that’s Kimberly!”
A DNA test confirmed that Kimberly McLean and Lori Ruff were one and the same. The discovery, though a relief, was also deeply bittersweet—her mother had finally found her long-lost daughter, but tragically, she would never have the chance to see her alive again.
9. The ‘Grateful Doe’ Identified
In 1995, Michael Hager lost control of his car and crashed into a tree in Virginia, killing both him and a teenage hitchhiker he had picked up. The only clues to the boy’s identity were a Grateful Dead T-shirt he wore and a note found in his pocket from two girls, promising they would meet him again. Since then, the Grateful Doe’s image has been shared across the Internet in hopes of identifying someone who knew him.
8. Benjaman Kyle Discovers His True Identity
In 2004, a man in his fifties was discovered lying naked between two dumpsters behind a Burger King in Georgia. He had been struck three times in the head and had no recollection of his own identity. He adopted the nickname “BK” and later expanded it to “Benjaman Kyle.” For the next ten years, Benjaman lived without any clue about his real identity.
CeCe Moore, a genetic genealogist, took on the task of uncovering Benjaman’s past and discovered that he had been missing much longer than ten years. He had run away from his parents in 1976 and had not been in contact with them since then.
Benjaman’s true identity remains a secret because he wishes to maintain his privacy. However, he has been reunited with his family, which, ironically, may never have happened if he hadn’t lost his memory.
7. The Mystery of the Mary Celeste
In 1872, the ship Mary Celeste was discovered adrift at sea, completely deserted. Strangely, there were still six months' worth of food and water aboard, and there was no evidence of damage or conflict—but every crew member had disappeared. The mysterious tale of the Mary Celeste has fascinated many over the years, and now, chemistry professor Dr. Andrea Sella believes he has solved the riddle.
According to Dr. Sella, 1,100 liters (300 gallons) of alcohol had leaked onto the ship, and the crew abandoned it after the alcohol exploded. Dr. Sella conducted an experiment to recreate the explosion. The blast would have blown open the hatches, scaring the crew, but would have left no trace of physical damage behind.
6. Caledonia Jane Doe Identified
In 1979, a young woman was found in a Caledonia, New York, cornfield, shot twice in the head. Her pockets were emptied, and heavy rainfall had washed away any evidence that could have helped identify her. Even dental records didn’t yield a match, and she was buried without a name.
Meanwhile, in Florida, another woman began wondering about an old classmate named Tammy Jo Alexander. She hadn’t heard from her in years and decided to search for her. Upon finding her, she learned that Tammy had run away years before, and her mother, struggling with severe drug addiction, never even bothered to report her missing.
The concerned classmate reported her findings to the police, who quickly realized that Tammy was the Caledonia Jane Doe. The reason they hadn’t been able to identify her by dental records was that, in her 16 years of life, Tammy’s mother had never taken her to the dentist.
5. Chelsea Bruck’s Killer Identified
In 2014, Chelsea Bruck attended the last Halloween party of her life. She dressed as Poison Ivy and left around 3:00 AM with a man in costume. No one knew who her mysterious companion was, and Chelsea never returned home. Three weeks later, her body was found in an abandoned field.
It took nearly two years for authorities to identify a suspect. In July 2016, they arrested a man named Daniel Clay, after his girlfriend claimed he confessed to the crime. However, the police have not disclosed many specifics.
The charges tell their own story: The sexual conduct charges suggest what Clay may have intended. The second-degree murder charge indicates that things didn’t go as planned that night. And the charge for concealing a body implies he hoped no one would ever discover Chelsea.
4. The Identity of ‘Baby Hope’ Uncovered
In 1991, workers on a construction site in New York uncovered a blue cooler filled with a grim secret: a young girl’s body, wrapped in a black trash bag and hidden beneath a pile of Coca-Cola cans. Her identity was unrecognizable due to severe decomposition.
It wasn’t until 2013 that police, aided by a tip from an anonymous caller, were able to track down Margarita Castillo, eventually identifying the girl as her daughter, Anjelica—better known as Baby Hope.
Anjelica’s story turned out to be even more heartbreaking than anyone could have imagined. Her cousin, Conrado Juarez, was responsible for her brutal assault. When she screamed for help, he smothered her with a pillow, killing her in the process. He confessed his actions to his sister, Margarita’s niece, who then gave him a cooler to dispose of the body.
Margarita never reported her daughter’s disappearance due to her status as an undocumented immigrant who couldn’t speak English. She feared deportation. While she had seen news stories about Baby Hope, the fear kept her from coming forward—until the police arrived at her door.
3. The Mystery of Paul Fronczak’s True Identity
In 1965, the Fronczak family thought they were finally reunited with their stolen child. After their baby, Paul, was abducted, they were overjoyed to hear about a toddler found abandoned in a stroller. Believing this child to be their missing son, they took him home and raised him as their own.
As the child grew older, he started to look less and less like the Fronczak family. In 2012, the family decided to take a DNA test, only to discover that the boy they had raised for years was not their biological son.
CeCe Moore—the same CeCe who helped Benjaman Kyle—assisted Paul in uncovering his true identity. She discovered that his birth name was Jack. Though his biological parents had passed away, he had a twin sister named Jill. Both Jack and Jill had vanished before they turned two, with Jill still missing.
CeCe’s findings raised more unanswered questions: What happened to Jill and Paul? Why was Jack left alone in a stroller? Who was responsible for the abductions? At least Jack now knows the truth about his origins.
2. The Mystery Surrounding Raoul Wallenberg’s Death
Raoul Wallenberg is remembered as a hero. A Swedish businessman during World War II, he saved over 100,000 Jewish lives by providing them with forged documents to help them escape. His efforts were met with betrayal when he was imprisoned in a Soviet labor camp.
Although Wallenberg passed away in 1947, the exact cause of his death remains controversial. The Soviets claimed he died of a heart attack, but many question the veracity of this statement.
In June 2016, the diaries of KGB chief Ivan Serov were made public. In these diaries, he writes, “I have no doubts that Wallenberg was liquidated in 1947.” He further suggests that Wallenberg’s death was ordered directly by Stalin and Molotov.
While the diary entry does not provide definitive proof, it strongly indicates that the KGB did not believe Wallenberg’s death was accidental. Even at the highest levels, it was understood that Stalin was responsible for his death.
1. Bella In The Wych Elm
In 1943, four boys in Worcestershire made a chilling discovery—a human skull hidden inside a witch hazel tree. Investigations led to the body of a woman who appeared to have been killed in a ritualistic manner. The mystery deepened when unsettling graffiti appeared around town with the phrase: 'Who put Bella in the Wych Elm?'
The identity of the woman remained unknown, and there were no reports of a missing person named Bella. This left the authorities baffled as to who she was and why the cryptic messages referred to her as 'Bella.'
Professor James Webster now believes he has unraveled the mystery. According to him, the 'Bella' in the message was a German actress named Clara Bauerle. Clara, who performed in the West under the stage name 'Clarabella,' is thought to be the person referred to as 'Bella' in the haunting graffiti.
Clara was allegedly working as a Nazi spy and was ordered to parachute into the region in 1941. While she successfully landed, she never checked in and was never heard from again. Webster theorizes she was spotted and ultimately disposed of in a witch hazel tree.
+ Further Reading
While many of the unsolved mysteries in our archives remain unsolved, we've also covered a number of cases where the mysteries have been resolved! Here are a few for your enjoyment:
10 Mysteries That Might Finally Have Answers 10 Fascinating Historical Puzzles We’ve Unraveled 10 Confounding Cases Solved Long After the Police Gave Up 10 Mysteries Cleared Up By Astonishing Plot Twists
