Buzz
Anyone who's ever owned a pair of tights knows the heart-sinking feeling when a rip, tear, or snag ruins your favorite pair. While tights are a budget-friendly wardrobe essential that can enhance an outfit, provide leg coverage, and keep you warm during colder months, their low price often means sacrificing durability. But are there any tights out there that hold up?
It turns out there are options, though we had to dig deep to find them. We combed through reviews of popular tights to find the ones that shoppers swear won’t rip, no matter how many times they’re worn. Each pair on our list boasts a 4-star rating or higher, which is no small feat — as reviewers don't go easy on tights.
Check out our list of tights worth the investment for their durability. Whether you’re dressing for the office or hitting the dance floor at a wedding, these tights are sure to keep you covered.
Unless stated otherwise, all sizes mentioned in this post are in women’s sizes.
1. A pair of opaque tights with more than 24,000 5-star reviews
2. Machine-washable tights available in a wide range of colors
3. The viral 'pineapple-proof' sheer tights
You may have heard of these sheer Shapermint tights before, known for the brand's claim that they won't rip — even with a pineapple inside them. (There’s even a photo on the product page showing the tights holding a pineapple with ease.) Available in three colors and sizes S–3XL, these high-waisted tights offer shaping and are so durable that 99% of women reportedly couldn’t tear them, according to the brand.
4. Fleece-lined faux-sheer tights for maximum warmth
5. 'Blackout' tights from Target, which one reviewer dubbed 'the best pair of tights I've ever owned'
Can tights priced at just $9 really withstand the rip test? According to shoppers, they can, as these blackout tights from Target boast a 4.6-star rating across over 700 reviews. They're thick, warm, and opaque, designed for winter outfits. Available in ivory or black, with sizes S/M to 1X/2X.
6. Or their equally popular sheer version, just as affordable
If opaque tights aren’t your thing, check out this sheer version by A New Day from Target, with a 4.4-star rating across over 500 reviews. Available only in black, it offers the same size range of S/M to 1X/2X. These tights are less warm than the opaque variety but feature a control top that reviewers say stays in place without rolling down.
7. Some playful plaid tights to add a fun touch to a simple outfit
8. A pair of transition dance tights that are perfect for everyday wear
9. A pair of J.Crew tights that are completely opaque and designed to keep you warm
J.Crew offers these ultra-opaque control top tights in black, with a pre-order option in burgundy. While they come at a higher price compared to typical Amazon or Target tights, many reviewers believe the quality and warmth justify the cost (especially if you catch them on sale). These machine-washable tights are also durable. Available in sizes XS–L.
10. A pair of vibrant microfiber tights available in plus sizes
These sheer Ulla Popken tights are available in eight vibrant colors. They're breathable, machine-washable, and versatile, making them a great choice for those seeking both style and comfort. Plus, they're a reliable plus-size option where many tights fall short in sizing. Available in sizes 14/16 to 30/32.
11. Hanes blackout tights that come highly recommended by testers
In a test of tights' rip resistance, Byrdie named these Hanes blackout tights the best budget-friendly option, praising their ability to resist Velcro, jewelry, and other potential snags. With a 100 denier count, they offer the darkest and most opaque finish. The tights feature a snug fit at the waist and extra stretch in the back. Available in sizes S to XL.
