Buzz
Did you know that Amazon's app offers some exclusive features? You can scan barcodes to instantly check prices in real life, use your phone’s camera to search for items with just one tap, track orders in real-time, and more. Download the app for free and enjoy $5 off your first in-app purchase!
1. NYX Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner makes it easy to achieve a perfect, long-lasting cat-eye look. Its ultra-precise tip is flexible and simple to use, giving you smooth, fluid strokes for a sharp finish. You can adjust the thickness of your lines with just a gentle press.
Promising review: "This product is incredible! I’ve been using Kat Von D's tattoo liner, but since her line has been discontinued, I’ve been on the hunt for an affordable alternative, and I totally found it with this one! It’s so pigmented! (Even with my deep complexion) and it stays put without smudging. It applies effortlessly and gives me a perfect cat-eye look. Couldn’t be happier with it" –Alex S
Price: $7.08+ (sold individually or in a two-pack, and available in two colors)
2. HAUS Laboratories Liquid Eye-Lie-Ner, created by Mother Monster herself, Lady Gaga, delivers a bold statement. It's long-lasting, smudge-proof, and comes in either a flexible felt tip or a precision tip option. An added bonus: it’s vegan and cruelty-free! Some styles/colors even include Wingtip Stickers to ensure your winged eyeliner is flawless every time.
Promising review: "This formula feels like it’s made from permanent marker ink! That being said, it’s INCREDIBLE. I have VERY oily eyelids, and after wearing it for 12 hours straight, it didn’t fade, smudge, or transfer to my lower lids. I’ve been using a different felt tip liquid liner for years, but I think I’m switching to this one. The applicator is sturdy and easy to handle. The final test will be if the felt tip dries out after a few uses. If it doesn’t, this will be my new favorite eyeliner." –MaryAnne
Price: $12.60+ (available in two styles and four colors)
3. Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen offers both affordability and practicality. The hyper-easy brush tip smoothly follows the natural curve of your eye, providing a flawless glide. Its custom hexagonal grip ensures maximum control, allowing for effortless, stable application. It lasts up to 24 hours with vivid color that won’t smudge!
Promising review: "I’m a big fan of brush eyeliners. I’ve tried Urban Decay and Kat Von D liners, but this one is by far the best, especially for the price. It glides on smoothly and makes creating winged eyeliner much easier. Plus, the pigmentation is excellent. I will definitely repurchase." –M.A.
Price: $6.98
4. iMethod Eyeliner Stamp ensures you get a perfectly symmetrical wing every time. This clever eyeliner features a double-sided tip, with one side being a wing stamp and the other a fine liner. The waterproof duo includes two eyeliners — one for the left eye and the other for the right eye.
Promising review: "Simple and straightforward to use. The angle at which you hold the pen is key to achieving your desired look. You can make the line flare upwards or keep it short and to the side. This was my first time using it, and I was impressed with how well it turned out. I don’t wear makeup often, just once or twice a month, so I have limited experience. This pen made it seem like I knew exactly what I was doing, lol. It’s a bit thicker than I typically prefer, but overall, I’m happy with it." –Fran
Price: $11.95
5. Maybelline Eyestudio Master Precise All-Day Liquid Eyeliner delivers a quick and flawless line. This smudge-proof liner creates sharp, precise lines, offering intense waterproof color that lasts up to 12 hours. It’s the perfect eyeliner to define your eyes and add a pop of color.
Promising review: "Absolutely love this!!! Many others tend to dry out in just a few weeks, but I've been using this one for months and it's still going strong! I prefer a very thin eyeliner line, and this works perfectly for that. On special occasions when I want a thicker line, it does the job just as well. Overall, this is a great eyeliner!!! While it's not entirely waterproof, it doesn't smudge as much as others do. As a mail carrier working in 90-degree heat for over 6 hours, I don't end up with raccoon eyes with this eyeliner! Highly recommended." –Christi
Price: $4.99+ (available in a single or two-pack and in four colors)
6. Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner is a fan favorite for a reason. The fine, marker-like tip ensures precise application, whether you're a beginner or a professional. From delicate lines to bold, dramatic strokes, it has you covered. Go for a bold color or stick with a classic black. Pro tip: Shake it well before use to fully saturate the tip!
Promising review: "This eyeliner is so easy to apply, even for the blind! As someone who is legally blind, I do my makeup by feel. Eyeliner has always been the toughest for me, so I stopped using it for years. I decided to give this one a try after reading the reviews, and I am so glad I did. It went on perfectly and was so easy to use! I’m thrilled to be wearing eyeliner again! Some people may not believe that blind individuals wear makeup or think it’s hard to do, but here’s a picture of my first attempt with this eyeliner." –Lowe Family
Price: $22 (available in three tip styles and nine colors)
For more details on why a Mytour editor loves this, check out her full Stila eyeliner review.
7. Revlon ColorStay Liquid Liner Twin Pack offers twice the value, whether you want to keep one for yourself and share the other or simply double the fun. This liquid formula delivers precise definition, is smudge-proof, and dries quickly for up to 16 hours of wear. Furthermore, it's ophthalmologist-tested, making it safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens users.
Promising review: "This is without a doubt my favorite liquid eyeliner. I've been using it for years and still love it. It doesn't smudge and the hard-tipped brush makes it easy to apply. It also removes easily with a makeup wipe." –Alyson
Price: $8.99
8. NYX Matte Liquid Waterproof Liner allows you to reinvent your look with its stunning matte finish. The ultra-fine precision brush offers total control, making it easy to create lines ranging from delicate to bold. The matte black formula provides a flawless, smudge-proof finish. Plus, it's vegan and cruelty-free!
Promising review: "I absolutely love this makeup... their eyeliner is unmatched! My eyes are very sensitive, and I can't use cheap, low-quality eyeliners without experiencing redness, dryness, and irritation. This eyeliner stays on all day, looking freshly applied the entire time, and it washes off easily. Most importantly, it doesn't irritate my eyes or skin. Plus, it arrived on time and was packaged properly!" –Nakia
Price: $5.94
9. L'Oreal Paris Infallible Liquid Eyeliner is your go-to for perfecting the fine-tip flick. The ultra-fine felt tip gives you full control to create precise lines that stay put for up to 12 hours. Achieve a sleek, sophisticated look with this 0.4-millimeter eyeliner pen.
Promising review: "I’ve tried probably 15 different felt-tip liquid pens, and then I came across this one at the drugstore. From the moment I tried it, I was hooked. It applied so smoothly. I’m 53 years old, and my eyelids have creases. I used to hate when the eyeliner was too thin or runny, causing it to bleed and feather on my lids. This felt-tip pen has rich, thick ink that stays exactly where you draw it! It dries quickly, so if you make a mistake, you can correct it fast. I rarely need to reapply throughout the day or at night, and it’s much more affordable here than at the drugstore." –Leslie
Price: $6.99+ (available as a single or two-pack and in three colors)
10. Wet N' Wild Mega Last Breakup-Proof Liquid Eyeliner delivers an opaque, streak-free line. The ultra-pigmented, waterproof formula ensures a precise, intensely bold line with each application. It features an ultra-fine brush-tip that allows you to create anything from a thin line to a bold, dramatic stroke, and the color lasts for up to 16 hours.
Promising review: "I love this! The tip has a pretty fine point to it allowing for thick or thin line control and it is SO smudge-proof! I work with animals and end up getting water sprayed in my face often and it doesn’t move! If I take a nap with it on? Still solid when I wake up. Rub my eyes way more than I should? No raccoon eyes! But when I want it gone it comes right off when washing my face or using a remover wipe! I highly recommend this to anyone looking for a good, budge-proof eyeliner that won’t take 50 years and a bottle of oil to get off." –Logan
Price: $4.98
11. Maybelline Ultra Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner delivers a certified all-day wear. This waterproof liner has a precision brush with a glossy finish and refuses to budge. Application tip: Rest your elbow on a countertop for a steady grip, and line in sections: along the inner, middle, and outer upper lash line.
Promising review: "This eyeliner has been my absolute favorite for the past few years. I wear it pretty much every day and I take pride in my lined wings. Last year, I got into a bad car accident by hitting a tree, avoiding an oncoming car. I broke my neck and wound up in the hospital for almost 24 hours before being discharged without needing surgery. I was BAWLING my EYES out for most of this period and sleeping on and off. This liquid liner stood up to all that. Yeah, it cracked a little bit, but if you ask me it still looked fierce as hell. My neck is A-OK now and I continue to buy this product and wear it every day. I wear it swimming underwater and as long as I don't full on rub my eyes, I'm golden. In conclusion, 10/10 would recommend." –Kristen
Price: $5.79+ (available in two colors)
12. Arishine Magnetic Eyeliner is the perfect match for fake lashes. This revolutionary eyeliner lets you apply lashes without the hassle of messy glue. The magnetic eyeliner is infused with tiny magnetic particles that securely hold magnetic eyelashes in place, giving you longer, thicker, and beautiful lashes. Simply apply the eyeliner and place the magnetic lashes on top. For extra hold, add another layer of eyeliner.
Promising review: "I think I have finally found the perfect magnetic eyeliner. It goes on easily like regular liquid eyeliner. After applying the lashes with this eyeliner, I didn't need to touch up the eyeliner itself. What I love most is that my lashes stay on, even with 56 mph winds here in Chicago. From morning until bedtime, they stay intact. Even if I accidentally fall asleep with them on, the eyeliner holds them securely until I remove them. Incredible product." –vtanriover
Price: $8.98+ (available in multipacks with lashes)
13. Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner comes straight from clean beauty expert, Jessica Alba. This vegan eyeliner is made with plant-based ingredients to create an intense, inky-black formula that glides on smoothly for a perfectly defined, satin-finish line that lasts for up to eight hours. No flaking, no smudging, no budging—just flawless eyeliner all day long!
Promising review: "I’m absolutely in love with this eyeliner! I have very sensitive skin, and most traditional makeup breaks me out in hives. This eyeliner not only works beautifully, but it also doesn’t cause any irritation to my skin! I’m so happy to have found my new go-to for achieving the perfect cat-eye." –Wilkey
Price: $9.99
14. Eyeko Skinny Liquid Eyeliner will elevate your WFH meetings with either dramatic feline flicks or fine, precise lines. Enhance your eyes with this one-of-a-kind, long-lasting formula, featuring sodium hyaluronate for a satisfying, color-rich, smudge-proof finish.
Customer Review: "Stays in place all day, even for those with oily eyelids. It’s also a great choice for sensitive eyes, no irritation or redness even after wearing it for 12 hours (said by someone who can't use 'hypoallergenic' Clinique eye products). Deep matte black color, doesn’t fade, and remains non-shiny. Application is easy, but be aware that the pen tip is firmer than other liners (less flexible brush), so you’ll need to change your angle for a thinner line. Once you get used to it, it’s really easy. It applies smoothly and looks gorgeous all day." –B. Borkent
Price: $16
15. Rimmel Exaggerate Felt Tip Eye Liner is the ideal way to make a bold statement with any makeup look. Its smooth formula offers eye-enhancing definition that stays intact! With just one stroke, this lash-hugging liquid eyeliner blends seamlessly with your lashes, leaving no gaps or empty spaces!
Customer Review: "I’ve bought this product several times, it’s my favorite eyeliner. It dries to a matte finish, not glossy, and it’s super easy to apply and wing out. I even use it to smudge the black for a smokey look, and it turns out great. For the price, I highly recommend it. I set my makeup with a setting spray, including my eyes, I work 11-hour shifts, and my eyeliner stays put without smudging or running. I use a little and gradually build it up with the felt tip. I’ve only used it on my top lid, not on the waterline, and I recommend it." –Angela GPrice: $5.67+ (available as a single or two-pack)
The reviews for this post have been condensed and edited for clarity and brevity.
