16 Exciting Pet Toys with Rave Reviews on Amazon

Just as you carry your Stanley everywhere, your furry companion can now have their own version. This isn’t a real Stanley but a squeaky, stuffed replica available in pink, blue, and purple, matching the size of an actual tumbler. 

Promising review: "My pup adores his tumbler as much as I love mine! A must-have for all Stanley enthusiasts. If you have an emotional support cup, your dog deserves one too. GET IT NOW!!!!!!!" —Stephanie

Price: $16.99+

We’ve previously highlighted this $4 cat toy, endorsed by a certified feline behavior expert, which has since become one of HuffPost’s top-selling items. Crafted from a flexible steel wire with cardboard rolls at the ends, its simplicity and brilliance tap into your cat’s natural hunting instincts, providing hours of entertainment. 

Promising review: "You likely know someone with a cat—maybe a cousin’s friend who feeds strays. Surprise them with this affordable, interactive toy that’s a hit with both cats and humans! My youngest cat even plays solo, carrying one end in her mouth while chasing the other. Between my glamorous life and red carpet events, I still find time to play with my four-legged pals. Cate Blanchett can wait—I need to order more of these! Can YOU spot both cat dancers in the photo?" —dee

Price: $3.99

Referred to by many as simply "the Banana," this toy is a hit among cats and cat enthusiasts, offering hours of playful enjoyment. 

Promising review: "My cat adores this! She tosses it in the air, then hugs it tightly while kicking it wildly with her back legs. Treat your cat to this and watch the joy unfold!" —E. McNamara

Price: $7.98

If you enjoy sipping on a cold seltzer, you’ll adore this interactive dog toy set, which comes with a box containing three squeaky mini cans. Dogs can have fun pulling the cans out of the box or playing with each toy individually. Alternatively, you can purchase a single Lick Croix can for your furry friend!

Promising review: "My pomeranian is obsessed with this toy. It’s absolutely adorable! Since I love the drink, it’s only fair my pup matches my vibe, haha. It’s a fantastic plush squeaky toy—highly recommend!" —izzy

Price: $27.95 for the set; $14.95+ for a single can

This duo of dog toys mimics two cans of White Claw, ideal for a pup who loves to have a good time. Each stuffed can stands seven inches tall and features a squeaker to keep your dog entertained. 

Promising review: "My dog adores it, and my baby keeps trying to steal it! She must’ve realized that there are no rules when you’re sipping on the paws." —Erin

Price: $12.99

This tower ball toy will keep your cat entertained for hours as they push the balls around in circles, exploring every level until they’re worn out. 

Promising review: "My kitten has claimed this toy as his own, leaving his sibling frustrated and impatient. He’s flipping it all over the room, which I never anticipated. At 6 months old, he’s not the brightest, but we adore him and love seeing him so entertained by this fun toy!" —SuzieB

Price: $10.46

Designed to ease teething discomfort, simply soak this toy in water and freeze it to provide your puppy with a cooling chew that soothes their gums. 

Promising review: "My 4-month-old Great Pyrenees chews on this daily, and it’s held up perfectly despite her razor-sharp teeth. Unfortunately, the bottom step of my staircase didn’t fare as well. Haha!" —Helen

Price: $5.59

This toy acts like a fishing rod for your home, allowing you to engage your cat without much effort. It includes multiple interchangeable attachments, ensuring long-lasting fun and keeping your cat entertained. 

Promising review: "These are the best cat toys ever! Who needs TV when you’ve got this and a playful cat?" — cody stephens

Price: $9.98

Who could resist this charming A-Paw-Rol puppy toy, complete with a mini spritz toy? It’s ideal for keeping your pup entertained during happy hour. The set includes two separate squeaky toys made from high-quality, washable plush. It’s from Bark Bros, a small Amazon Marketplace business known for its pun-filled, novelty pet plushies.

Promising review: "Our dog loves joining us for sunset cockTAIL time with the family. It’s hilarious and always gets a laugh from guests. The toy has held up wonderfully, and I can’t wait to get my pup his next drink!" —Sean R

Price: $21.99

Why settle for one giant crinkle fish when you can have three? These nearly 10-inch-long toys might even be bigger than your cat, adding to the fun. Filled with catnip, they’re soft enough for snuggling and chewing. Cats love the crinkly sound and the soft texture, making them perfect for playtime. 

Promising review: "I usually have to buy different toys for our four cats, but they all adore these—even the picky one! One of our cats, who prefers the garage, carried this toy out there and lost it. We had to retrieve it the next morning. I’ll need to buy another pack since there are only three toys and four cats. A fantastic choice if your cats enjoy larger toys!" —FOB_Safe

Price: $9.48

This squeaky duck toy is both durable and cute, resembling a typical plushie but designed to withstand heavy chewing. 

Promising review: "My 6-month-old lab destroys everything, including drywall. This duck, however, has held up better than the drywall." —Ben

Price: $5.99

This interactive puzzle-feeding toy keeps your dog entertained while they enjoy a snack. It’s perfect for fast eaters, encouraging them to slow down and eat safely. Available in three different designs. 

Promising review: "My puppies adored it. They might be smarter than I thought, as they solved the puzzle quickly. Still, it works great as a slow feeder for my little vacuum cleaner, lol." —Alfredo

Price: $9.99+

For less than $5, this durable flying disc will keep your pup active and entertained. It’s available in two sizes for both small and large dogs, as well as blue and green color options.

Promising review: "This is the only flying disc my dog will play with. The chewy edges need supervision to prevent destruction. It’s lightweight, easy to fold, and fits in a pocket or bag. When visiting my mom, her dog loved it so much she hid it under the deck—so we bought another one! It’s fun to throw, lightweight, and high-quality if not chewed excessively. The orange color makes it easy to spot." —Keely A.

Price: $4.89

This octopus-style dog toy, with its multiple legs and squishy head, is designed to keep your pup engaged. It’s durable yet flexible, perfect for interactive play, and the squeaky head adds extra excitement. 

Promising review: "My puppy loves this toy because of the eight legs he can grab onto. It’s his favorite now, and I’m glad I bought two! My puppy gives it two paws up!" —Sunny

Price: $9.99

This tiny squeaker toy, resembling a designer handbag, is about the size of a soda can and instantly elevates any toy collection. It’s the closest many of us will get to a real Birken. 

Promising review: "I bought this as a gift for my friend’s posh little dog, and they both adore it!" —sussyw

Price: $16.95

If you’re a gym enthusiast who loves to recharge with electrolytes, your pup can join the fun with this toy set. It includes a mini barbell and a Gatorade-inspired drink toy with squeaky and crinkly features. 

Promising review: "Your dog shares activities like walks and snacks with you, so why not include them in your hobbies too? Perfect for gym-loving humans and their pups! My dog adores it." —Amazon customer

Price: $16.95