Buzz
When the Rose Center for Earth and Space debuted in 2000, its centerpiece was a massive solar system model. However, observers quickly noticed something unusual—Pluto was absent. After the New York Times highlighted this omission, public outcry ensued. By 2006, the International Astronomical Union had officially reclassified Pluto as a 'dwarf planet.'
The most vocal opposition came from elementary school students, who sent Director Neil deGrasse Tyson a flood of angry letters. Their messages, reflecting the five stages of grief, are both heartfelt and amusing.
1. Refusal to Accept
Dear Natural History Museum, You forgot to include Pluto in your display. Could you please add a model of it? Here’s a description: It’s a planet. With love, Will Galmot (Age 7)
2. Outrage
Dear Mr. Tyson, I believe Pluto is a planet. Why do you disagree? I don’t like your answer!!! Pluto is my favorite planet!!! You’ll need to update all the books to reflect this. Pluto is a planet!!!!!!! Sincerely, Emerson York
3. Negotiation
Dear Scientist, What is Pluto called now that it’s not a planet? If you reinstate it, all the science books will be accurate. Do people live on Pluto? If they do, they’ll cease to exist. Why can’t Pluto remain a planet? Its size shouldn’t disqualify it. Many people love Pluto. If it’s gone, they’ll lose their favorite planet. Please reply, but avoid cursive—I can’t read it. Your friend, Madeline Trost
4. Sadness
5. Coming to Terms
Dear Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson, Remember all those kids who sent you angry letters? I want to apologize for everything we got wrong. We’re sorry for sending you mean messages about loving Pluto but not you. I’m truly sorry. Everything will be alright. Taylor (Age 7)
6. Further Acceptance
Dear Dr. Neil deGrasse Tyson, I understand how you feel. We share the same sadness about Pluto no longer being a planet. But we must move on—that’s what science teaches us. Learning about science is important. It makes you smarter! With love, Siddiq (Age 8)
May it orbit in tranquility.
