Buzz
Last year marked a pivotal moment in advanced medical science when Patrick Hardison, a former firefighter, underwent the most comprehensive facial transplant surgery to date. This milestone capped nearly a decade of progress since the inaugural face transplant in 2005, transforming what once seemed like science fiction into a tangible reality. Over this period, not only were technical barriers overcome, but ethical concerns were also addressed. This narrative delves into the progression of this innovative procedure and the individuals whose lives it has profoundly transformed.
1. THE CHILD WHO REGAINED HER ORIGINAL FACE // 1994
In 1994, 9-year-old Sandeep Kaur suffered a tragic accident while working in an Indian field. Her braid got entangled in a threshing machine, resulting in her face being torn off in two sections. Rushed to a hospital three hours away, doctors determined traditional skin grafts were insufficient. Instead, they performed what is now recognized as the first face reattachment surgery. Since her own facial tissue was reattached, this pioneering procedure is classified as a face "re-plant" rather than a transplant.
2. THE PATIENT WHO RECEIVED A NEW MOUTH AND NOSE // 2005
Isabelle Dinoire’s partial facial transplant captured global attention not just for its groundbreaking medical significance, but also for the unusual events leading to it: Dinoire, reportedly experiencing emotional turmoil, had ingested sleeping pills and later woke up to find her dog had severely damaged her lips and nose while she was unconscious.
In November 2005, surgeons Bernard Devauchelle and Jean-Michel Dubernard—pioneers of the first modern hand transplant in 1998—conducted the world’s inaugural partial face transplant. They transplanted a section of tissue from a brain-dead donor’s mouth and nose onto Dinoire. Remarkably, Dinoire regained the ability to eat and speak within 24 hours and expressed contentment with the outcome 18 months post-surgery. However, she faced multiple tissue rejection episodes, highlighting the necessity for lifelong immunosuppressant therapy for transplant recipients.
3. THE SURVIVOR OF DOMESTIC ABUSE WHO RECEIVED AN 80 PERCENT FACIAL RECONSTRUCTION // 2008
In 2008, Connie Culp became the first American to undergo a partial face transplant. Culp’s husband had shot her during a violent altercation, devastating her mouth, nose, cheeks, one eye, and a portion of her facial bone structure. The Cleveland Clinic, the first U.S. institution to endorse the procedure, performed the intricate 22-hour surgery. This involved replacing 80 percent of her face, removing prior makeshift jaw reconstructions, and transplanting bone, muscle, nerves, blood vessels, and skin to rebuild the central area of her face.
4. THE AGRICULTURAL WORKER WHO ENDURED 10 SURGERIES TO RESTORE HIS FACE // 2010
In 2010, a Spanish farmer known only as Oscar, who suffered severe facial disfigurement from a gun accident, became the first person to undergo a full-face transplant at a Barcelona hospital. After nine unsuccessful attempts to reconstruct his face, Oscar qualified for this groundbreaking procedure. A team of 30 medical professionals, including surgeons, anesthetists, and nurses, worked for 24 hours to replace his facial muscles, nose, lips, upper jaw, teeth, cheekbones, palate, tear ducts, and eyelids. Just months later, the second full-face transplant was performed in France.
5. THE SURVIVOR OF SEVERE BURNS WHO REGAINED SPEECH AND SENSES // 2011
Dallas Wiens has no recollection of the November 2008 accident when his head struck a high-voltage wire while he was on a cherry picker. The electric shock caused severe burns across his body, leaving him blind and without facial features. Miraculously, Wiens survived and began recovering, but it was a 2011 full-face transplant at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston that truly transformed his life. The procedure replaced his entire face with a donor’s, restoring his ability to speak and smell, though his eyesight could not be recovered.
Following Wiens’s surgery, full-face transplants were performed on Mitch Hunter later in 2011 and Richard Lee Norris in 2012, the latter being an exceptionally complex operation.
6. THE VICTIM OF A CHIMPANZEE ATTACK WHO RECEIVED A NEW FACE AND HANDS // 2011
Charla Nash's experience, though not a landmark in face transplant science, stands out due to the unusual events leading to her injury. In 2009, Nash went to the Connecticut residence of her friend and boss, Sandra Herold, to assist with her pet chimp, Travis, who had become uncontrollable. Travis, a 200-pound adult male, brutally assaulted Nash upon her arrival, severely injuring her face and hands.
Following several initial surgeries, Nash underwent face and hand transplant procedures in May 2011 at Brigham and Women’s Hospital. While the face transplant was a success, the hand transplants failed due to an infection and were subsequently removed. Nash is still on the path to recovery, and her case is expected to aid in the treatment of war veterans with similar injuries.
7. THE MAN WHO GOT A NEW FACE IN JUST THREE WEEKS // 2013
The first face transplant in Poland is notable for its unprecedented speed. A man named Grzegorz underwent a full face transplant merely three weeks after a workplace machinery accident in 2013, which resulted in the loss of his nose, upper jaw, and cheeks. Typically, such complex surgeries require extensive preparation over months or years, but the urgency was critical to prevent brain infection due to the exposed area from the accident.
8. THE FIREFIGHTER WHO RECEIVED THE BIKE MESSENGER'S FACE // 2015
In 2001, Patrick Hardison, a volunteer firefighter, entered a blazing house in Senatobia, Mississippi, aiming to save a woman he believed was trapped inside. The roof caved in, dislodging his helmet, melting his protective mask, and severely burning his skin. This tragic incident resulted in Hardison losing his ears, nose, lips, and eyelid tissue, with almost no intact skin remaining on his face and neck. After enduring more than 70 surgeries and skin grafts, he was left with a mosaic of scars, enduring chronic pain and impaired vision due to non-functional eyelids.
In August 2015, Dr. Eduardo Rodriguez conducted the most comprehensive face transplant to date on Hardison at NYU Langone Medical Center. The donor was David Rodebaugh, a Brooklyn cycling enthusiast who passed away after a biking accident. The transplant covered an extensive area, from the back of Hardison’s skull, over his head, down to his collarbones, and included new eyelids and ears.
CHALLENGES AHEAD FOR THE PROCEDURE
The successes of these surgeries have alleviated many concerns, though not all. Initially, skeptics questioned whether face transplants would restore sensation and function, but patients have regained abilities like smell, taste, and touch. However, the procedure remains complex, demanding advanced microsurgery skills, extensive training, and large teams of experts. It is still evolving, with each surgery following unique protocols, highlighting the need for standardization. Surgeons are experimenting with CT scans and 3-D printed models to better match donor and recipient anatomy, enhancing precision and efficiency. Additionally, the high cost—averaging $300,000—and lack of insurance coverage in the U.S. pose significant barriers, sparking calls for policy changes.
The ethical debate surrounding face transplants persists. Early objections focused on the unsettling nature of the procedure and identity concerns. While some recipients feel a sense of duty toward their donors, few experience identity conflicts from wearing a donor’s face. The current ethical discussion centers on the lifelong use of immunosuppressant drugs, which prevent tissue rejection but increase risks of cancer, diabetes, and other health issues. Critics argue that while the procedure is transformative, it is not life-saving, potentially endangering otherwise healthy individuals.
Although public acceptance of face transplants is growing, advancements in science are likely to introduce new ethical dilemmas. Italian surgeon Sergio Canavero has announced plans to conduct the world’s first complete head transplant in 2017. While many neuroscientists remain deeply doubtful about its feasibility, the future promises even more extraordinary and controversial developments.
