After Rigorous Testing of 19 Duck Boots, These 8 Stand Out for Keeping Feet Cozy and Dry

Top Pick

The Columbia Women's Moritza Shield Omni-Heat Boots, our top choice for duck boots, surpassed all expectations. Featuring an elegant suede upper and a robust rubber sole, these boots are surprisingly lightweight. Their chic design complements nearly any winter ensemble, and they are available in four versatile shades. During testing, we wore them extensively for various activities—running errands, dog walking, driving, and grocery shopping—across diverse weather conditions, including sunshine, rain, mud, and snow. 

These boots impressed us with their exceptional comfort, featuring plush cushioning that molds to your feet and provides excellent shock absorption. The sturdy, thick outsole ensures a responsive energy return with every step. They are breathable, preventing overheating, and the fleece lining maintains an ideal warmth level. Despite their flexibility, the boots retain their structural integrity, moving naturally with your stride without feeling unstable. 

From the first wear, the boots felt broken-in and offered a snug, comforting fit. Their high-quality construction and durability are evident, promising long-lasting use. The traction is outstanding, though we noticed a slight slip on extremely icy surfaces. They effectively repel water and mud, with any minor residue on the rubber easily wiped clean. While walking in snow, a faint chill was noticeable at the front, but this was easily resolved by wearing thicker wool socks.

After three months of use, the boots remain in pristine condition, showing no signs of wear. Every component has held up remarkably well, consistently keeping our feet dry and comfortable through mud, rain, and snow. The fit has stayed true, though they’ve become even more comfortable over time. While there was no formal break-in period, the materials have softened slightly with wear, enhancing their comfort.

Size Range: 5–12 | Material: Suede | Insulation: 200g insulation

Top Choice for Traction

The Hunter Women's Explorer Duck Boots are designed for immediate comfort, requiring no break-in time. Built to last, these boots feature a rugged, non-slip sole that effectively sheds mud with every step. We tested them extensively in various conditions—rain, slush, and dry weather—across diverse terrains like concrete, grass, dirt, and even through puddles. The boots demonstrated flawless waterproofing and unmatched traction.

Crafted from a robust yet flexible material, these boots provide excellent arch and ankle support, making them ideal for long walks without discomfort. The fleece lining adds cushioning while maintaining breathability, preventing overheating. During our tests, we deliberately stepped into puddles filled with sticks and leaves. The boots emerged unscathed, with no stains, scratches, or damage—even on the white sections. Our feet stayed completely dry, with no water seeping in.

These Hunter boots excelled at repelling water, with droplets beading up and sliding off effortlessly. Mud and dirt also fell away without leaving stains. Stylistically, they lean towards a hiker boot design and are available in only two color options. However, their performance is impeccable. After months of regular use, the boots remain as comfortable and durable as ever, showing no signs of wear. They continue to look brand new, even after exposure to rain and mud, with their water resistance fully intact.

While not specifically crafted for hiking, these boots offered immediate comfort and have only grown more comfortable over time, molding perfectly to the feet even during long walks. They are sturdy and exude a sense of high-quality craftsmanship. The grip on the sole remains exceptional, showing no signs of wear. If you need a boot that’s completely waterproof, incredibly comfortable, and provides stability on any surface, this could be the perfect choice.

Available Sizes: 5–11 | Material: Polyester | Insulation: Recycled fleece lining rated for temperatures as low as -13°F

Top Choice for Insulation

No review of top duck boots would be complete without mentioning the original creator, L.L.Bean. These shearling-lined Bean Boots offer a modern take on the classic design, providing extra warmth due to their insulated lining. While maintaining the iconic style and durable rubber sole, they feature premium soft leather and plush shearling fur, giving them a luxurious, UGG-like comfort.

We rigorously tested these boots in various conditions, including rain, snow, and ice, often for extended periods. They grew more comfortable with each use, though the lack of heel support required some adjustment. The boots are breathable, exceptionally warm, and fully waterproof, with a well-balanced weight. The shaft height is perfect—it’s high enough to block puddle splashes but not so tall as to hinder movement.

After three months of heavy use, these boots show no visible signs of wear. There’s no scuffing, and both the leather and stitching remain flawless. Even the laces look new, though we wish they were softer for easier tying. Their durability is impressive, and they’ve held up exceptionally well.

These boots perform just as well as they did on day one. They remain completely waterproof, and the shearling lining continues to provide warmth, though the rubber portion isn’t as effective at insulating against cold. The fit has stayed consistent, but the traction could be better compared to other models we tested. That said, these are among the most durable and well-crafted duck boots we’ve encountered, with scratch-resistant, high-quality leather.

These boots are built to last a lifetime. While incredibly stylish—pairing well with everything from leggings and jeans to dresses—they’re best suited for cold weather and light rain. Initially, the price seemed steep, but after extensive testing, we believe they’re worth every penny. These are a one-time investment that will serve you for years to come.

Available Sizes: 5–11 | Material: Leather | Insulation: Shearling-lined insulation

Top Pick for Tall Boots

The Eddie Bauer Women's Hunt Pac Deluxe Boot is ideal for staying warm, comfortable, and steady during winter adventures. These boots make walking through snow effortless, and despite being snow boots with a substantial build, they feel lighter and less bulky than typical snow boots.

There was a brief break-in period before they felt just right, but once broken in, they became comfortable, breathable, and warm without causing overheating. After about 20 wears in various conditions—rain, snow, slush, and mud on both concrete and grass—we experienced no blisters, redness, hot spots, or foot pain. The tall, sturdy design provided excellent support, even allowing us to run comfortably in them.

Another standout feature is their exceptional traction. The deep, jagged ridges on the soles make walking on snow and ice across different surfaces easy and slip-free. The material is thick and high-quality, and stylistically, they make a bold fashion statement. Available in four color options, these boots kept water out during rain, though a lining could improve insulation around the laces to block cold air.

Despite some scuff marks from heavy use, the boots still look fantastic after three months. They keep our feet dry, though the soles can feel cold during extended wear in snowy or slushy conditions. Over time, they’ve molded to our feet, becoming even more comfortable with each wear.

Available Sizes: 6–11 | Material: Suede leather | Insulation: 200-gram ThermaFill

Top Pick for Chelsea Boots

If you’re looking for a boot you can quickly slip on without hassle, the Lands' End Women's Insulated Flannel Lined Chelsea Duck Boot is a perfect choice. Similar to a classic Chelsea boot, this stylish design complements any outfit and features a convenient pull-on design with front and rear tabs for easy wear. Plus, it keeps you warm and completely dry in wet conditions.

From the moment we unboxed them, it was clear these boots were made with high-quality materials. They are robust, well-structured, and lined with cozy flannel. The weight is just right—neither too heavy nor too light. They felt comfortable immediately, and while they are firmer than some alternatives, this provided excellent support and stability throughout the day. The insulation retains warmth effectively, making them ideal for very cold weather, though they may be too warm for milder conditions.

These boots excelled during our tests in rainy weather and deep, wet snow. They effectively repelled water, staying fully waterproof with no leaks. The traction was impressive, providing stability on icy sidewalks. If we had to suggest improvements, adding a built-in sock at the top for a snugger fit and more color options would enhance their appeal.

After months of use in challenging conditions like rain, snow, and mud, the boots have maintained their durability. They’re easy to clean and show minimal signs of wear, even enduring a few playful bites from a dog. Their water resistance remains dependable, keeping feet warm and dry in all conditions.

While these boots aren’t the best for long walks, wearing thick socks helped prevent heel chafing. Over time, they’ve become slightly more comfortable, though we still wish the lining was thicker for added warmth in freezing temperatures.

Available Sizes: 6–11 | Material: Leather and rubber | Insulation: 200-gram Thermolite

Top Pick for Casual Wear

True to the Sorel brand’s reputation, the Women’s Out N About III Classic Boot required no break-in period and provided consistent comfort and support. We tested them during various activities, including driving, walking on dry and wet grass, pavement, rocks, and frost-covered ground. They remained comfortable and supportive, even during prolonged standing on hard surfaces, without causing discomfort or cramping.

Despite their bulky look, these boots are surprisingly light. They are fully waterproof and effectively repel water. The material is sturdy but doesn’t compromise comfort, and their lower height prevents them from digging into the skin. These versatile boots are easy to style and slip on, making them ideal for quick errands in wet conditions. They come in multiple color options but lack insulation, making them less suitable for freezing temperatures.

After three months of use, these duck boots have shown impressive durability with minimal signs of wear. They clean easily with a quick rinse, maintain their water resistance, and keep feet completely dry. While their shorter design makes them less ideal for deep snow, they excel in rainy weather, offering excellent traction.

The comfort level has remained consistent since the first wear, though additional padding on the sides would enhance the experience. In terms of longevity, these boots are exceptionally well-made and durable, with soles and seams showing no signs of wear. We found the sizing to be inaccurate but achieved a perfect fit by sizing up. For added warmth with thick socks, consider sizing up even further.

We maintain our initial view that these boots are highly versatile. However, after several months, we believe they are better suited for temperatures above 30°F (unless paired with thick winter socks), as they lack sufficient insulation for colder climates. Conversely, they can feel too warm in temperatures above 50°F. For those seeking a fashionable, casual boot suitable for various weather conditions and activities, these boots offer excellent value and style.

Available Sizes: 5-12 | Material: Leather and suede | Insulation: None

Top Pick for Everyday Wear

The Sperry Women’s Syren Gulf Duck Boots are not only visually appealing but also incredibly comfortable from the first wear. We tested them for hours in both rain and sun, indoors and outdoors. They feature cushioned insoles, true-to-size fitting, and a snug fit. They remained comfortable throughout, keeping our feet warm while maintaining breathability.

These boots have a rubber lower section, but the upper part around the ankle is fabric, so thick socks are recommended for colder weather due to the lack of insulation. They provide good support, and the laces can be tightened for additional ankle stability. The traction is impressive—on dry indoor surfaces, you can feel and hear the grip. They also performed well on wet outdoor surfaces, including slippery wooden decks.

Our feet stayed completely dry, with water droplets sliding off the rubber tops. Even when standing or jumping in puddles, no water seeped through. These high-quality boots share the classic duck boot shape but are much lighter. They come in half sizes for a perfect fit and are available in various colors, including gray, brown, and black, catering to different style preferences.

After three months of use, these boots have proven to be as durable as expected. The ties, zippers, fabric upper, rubber lower, outsoles, and cushioned insoles are all in excellent condition. They remain waterproof, keeping feet warm and dry. The comfort level is unchanged, with the cushioned soles providing excellent arch support and a cloud-like feel with every step.

During one walk, some mud splashed onto the beige rubber, and we couldn’t remove it completely on the first try. While it’s not very noticeable, we believe a more thorough cleaning will eliminate it entirely. These boots remained comfortable during extended wear and have shown remarkable durability.

Available Sizes: 5–12 | Material: Fabric and rubber | Insulation: None

Top Pick for Style

The UGG Hapsburg Duck Boot seamlessly combines style and practicality, making it perfect for colder weather. It features a pull tab for easy wear and a lace-up closure for a secure fit. The boot includes foam padding around the ankle collar and under the tongue for added comfort. The sockliner molds to the foot, and extra heel padding ensures a cushioned step. The footbed is also padded, and the lightweight midsole absorbs shock effectively.

These premium boots boast a sleek leather upper and exceptional traction, thanks to the rubber outsole with Spider Rubber technology. The sole is designed to prevent slipping on various surfaces, including sidewalks, streets, grass, and mud. We tested them in heavy rain and light snow, and they performed exceptionally well.

We found these boots to be incredibly comfortable, breathable, and warm, though they may feel narrow for those with wider feet. They are fully waterproof and excel at keeping out the cold. While they have a stiffer build than some alternatives, this didn’t cause blisters or discomfort, though they required a week or two to break in. Their durability is impressive—after rigorous testing, they still look new, and a simple wipe removed any mud.

Available Sizes: 5–8 | Material: Nubuck and suede | Insulation: None

Final Verdict

Our top choice for the best duck boots is the Columbia Moritza Shield Omni-Heat Boots, which combine functionality, comfort, and style. These boots feature a high-quality, lightweight design that feels like a warm embrace for your feet, offering breathability and complete waterproofing. For superior traction, we recommend the Hunter Explorer Duck Boots.

Our Testing Process

To identify the best duck boots, we tested 19 popular models over several weeks, wearing them for at least two hours per session across various scenarios. We assessed the quality and construction, including the outer and inner soles, exterior fabric, and any laces, straps, or hardware. We also considered factors like weight. After trying them on indoors, we evaluated how easy they were to put on and remove.

We wore each pair for at least an hour to break them in, noting the time required. We evaluated sizing accuracy, fit, comfort, shaft height, and toe box space. We then tested the boots outdoors in diverse weather conditions, including rain, snow, ice, and dry days, to assess their performance.

We evaluated each boot’s comfort, traction, and breathability, as well as their supportiveness, including arch and ankle support. We tested their waterproofing by wearing them in wet conditions and pouring water over them to check for leaks, drying speed, and overall water resistance. We also monitored any unusual signs of wear and tear.

The winners in this roundup were tested over three months to assess their durability and performance during extended use, and our findings have been included.

How to Shop for Duck Boots Like a Pro

Style

When imagining duck boots, the classic L.L.Bean design in tan and dark brown often comes to mind. However, since its inception, many brands have introduced their own unique styles and color variations. Today, duck boots are available in nearly every color imaginable.

Some duck boots feature a polished look, making them suitable for work attire, while others have a more athletic appearance. They come in various shaft and heel heights, as well as different materials. Options include laces, zippers, or slip-on designs for convenience. “You can even find duck boots with a streetwear vibe, as sportswear brands have introduced sneaker-inspired versions,” Herbert notes.

“I adore Chelsea-style duck boots for their fashionable appeal, especially when paired with straight-leg jeans or workout leggings and high socks that peek above the boot,” Wendler shares. “I also appreciate the timeless look of the original L.L.Bean model, where the combination of rubber and leather adds visual interest.”

Materials

While traditional duck boots featured a leather upper and rubber sole, modern versions can be crafted from various waterproof materials, such as suede, polyester, nubuck, neoprene, as well as leather and rubber. “Rubber and leather remain the core materials,” Wendler explains. “Choose a pair that is fully waterproof and sealed to ensure your feet stay dry during rainy or damp weather.”

A standard duck boot includes a rubber sole and molded toe, though some budget-friendly “fashion” options may have a thinner rubber section. “This could compromise water resistance in puddles or snow,” Herbert notes. “The upper part may vary between leather or high-performance fabrics like Gortex or technical membranes. Some designs even feature neoprene uppers, which are both insulated and waterproof, making them a solid choice.”

Insulation

The Temperature Rating System helps customers gauge the thermal insulation of footwear, indicating the lowest temperature at which the boots can keep feet warm. These ratings, often provided in Fahrenheit or Celsius, vary by manufacturer and may not always be exact, but they serve as a useful guide.

For insulation, brands commonly use synthetic fibers like Thinsulate, Thermolite, ThermaFill, or PrimaLoft. Alongside temperature suitability, insulated boots often specify the weight of the insulation material. Generally, a higher number indicates greater insulation and warmth.

Insulation is typically measured in grams, ranging from 200 to 800. Boots with 200-gram insulation are ideal for moderately cold weather, 400-gram insulation suits colder temperatures, and 800 grams or more is perfect for extreme cold or prolonged exposure to freezing conditions. Factors like activity level and personal sensitivity to cold should also influence your choice of insulation.

“Duck boots excel in cold weather and snow,” Herbert explains. “A quality pair will feature a shearling, microfiber, or microfleece lining for warmth and comfort. While keeping your feet cozy is essential, well-designed boots also ensure breathability to prevent excessive sweating.” Wendler also recommends insulated duck boots, especially for those in consistently cold and damp regions, paired with wool socks for added warmth.

Features

Modern duck boots offer various features like fur linings, insulation, laces, zippers, and different heel heights. However, experts emphasize that waterproofing and traction are the most critical factors. “Choose duck boots with excellent grip and traction,” Wendler advises. “Wet and damp conditions often mean slippery surfaces.” For added safety, she recommends flat boots with no more than 0.5 to 1 inch of heel height.

Beyond being waterproof, Herbert highlights that duck boots should provide “ankle and arch support, warmth through lining, and reliable grip for outdoor activities in wet or dry conditions.” He adds, “If the boots have zippers or laces, ensure the seams are sealed to prevent water from seeping in.”

Questions You Might Ask

Are duck boots worth it?

“I firmly believe duck boots are a worthwhile investment,” Wendler states. “They essentially serve as rain boots, ensuring your feet stay dry during commutes, school drop-offs, or errands. Dry feet are far more comfortable than soggy sneakers or flats. Consider your outdoor lifestyle and activities. As a mom, I’m often outside with my kids or running errands, so wearing duck boots during heavy rain keeps my feet dry and comfortable.”

While duck boots are often pricier than standard winter boots, Herbert believes they are a worthwhile investment due to their warmth, waterproofing, and durability over the years. “Invest in quality, and you’ll only need to buy once,” he advises. Herbert also cautions that cheaper alternatives may lack performance or comfort. “Ensure they come from a reputable brand and scrutinize the technical features if the price seems too good to be true,” he adds.

What activities are duck boots ideal for?

Duck boots are highly versatile and suitable for a wide range of activities. “Their waterproof and warm design makes them perfect for outdoor adventures in wet and cold conditions, such as woodland hikes, horse care, gardening, and snowy trails,” Herbert explains. “Beyond their practicality, duck boots align with current fashion trends, pairing well with leggings or rolled-up jeans, making them suitable for both functional and social settings.”

Wendler notes that duck boots are excellent for commuting in wet, rainy, or damp weather. “Unlike sneakers or regular shoes, duck boots are designed to be waterproof,” she says. “I appreciate their shorter, more compact design compared to traditional tall rain boots, which can be cumbersome to walk in.”

Are duck boots waterproof?

Similar to traditional rain boots, high-quality duck boots should be fully waterproof. Herbert emphasizes that they should feature rubber soles, sealed seams, and a waterproof upper material like treated leather or technical membrane fabric. Wendler adds that ensuring the rubber sole is entirely sealed is crucial for complete waterproofing.

Are duck boots good for snow?

While some duck boots perform well in snow, not all are suitable. For snowy conditions, prioritize features like insulation for warmth and a taller shaft to prevent snow from entering the boot. Duck boots are typically waterproof, keeping feet dry in snow and slush. However, for heavy snow, you might consider investing in a pair of dedicated snow boots.

Are duck boots good for hiking?

Duck boots can handle certain hiking conditions, particularly wet and muddy terrains, due to their waterproofing and excellent traction. However, they aren’t ideal for dedicated hiking. Their stiffer construction compared to hiking boots may cause discomfort during long walks. While some duck boots can be comfortable for extended periods, avid hikers are better off with boots specifically designed for hiking.

Trust Our Expertise

This piece was authored by Kat de Naoum, a seasoned writer with over a decade of experience and the editor-at-large at Thomas-Xometry, a leading U.S. platform for supplier discovery and product sourcing. For this review, we rigorously tested numerous duck boots, evaluating aspects like size range, materials, insulation, traction, waterproofing, and overall value. Kat also consulted Josh Herbert, founder of Captain Creps, and Liz Wendler, a style coach and founder of Liz Wendler Styling.