Are Blackhead Extractors Safe to Use? Expert Insights

With summer here, the sunshine brings sweat—and clogged pores. If blackheads are a recurring issue for you, you don’t need us to tell you how stubborn they can be. Fortunately, blackhead extractors are incredibly effective in helping bring these annoying blemishes to the surface. The downside: improper use can lead to more harm than good. To help, we’ve turned to Morgan Rackley, esthetician and owner of Luminous Skin Atlanta, to share her expert tips on using these tools safely at home.

What exactly are blackheads?

Blackheads are a form of acne, often referred to as open comedones, but they aren’t technically pimples. "Instead of being raised bumps filled with white or yellow fluid, blackheads are flat and dark, which is where their name comes from," explains Rackley. "They’re a common skin issue that occurs when hair follicles become clogged with excess oil and irritation."

What exactly is a blackhead extractor?

A comedone extractor, or blackhead remover, is a tool made of stainless steel designed to eliminate the dirt and oil responsible for blackheads and whiteheads. "It works by gently pressing out the clogged sebum from the pore," explains Rackley. Comedone extractors come in various types—there are the traditional ones with two loops at either end, tools resembling tweezers, and more modern pore vacuums that use suction to draw out debris from your skin.

Are blackhead extractors safe to use?

Rackley confirms that comedone extractors are safe when used correctly. "If you're using a comedone extractor at home, stick to the rounded side—some have a pointed end meant to open blackheads or whiteheads, but unless you're a professional, you risk cutting too deeply and causing injury," she advises. "Another important tip: if you see blood, stop immediately—you've removed everything! It may be tempting to keep going, but I assure you there’s nothing left, and continuing could lead to bruising or other injuries." For especially persistent breakouts, it’s best to seek help from a professional to avoid damaging your skin with the tool.

How to Properly Use a Blackhead Extractor

To prevent excessive pressure, Rackley suggests preparing the area with a warm compress. "This will help soften the skin and open the pores, making extraction easier," she explains. You should also sanitize your comedone extractor with alcohol.

Next, choose the wire loop you want to use. A smaller loop is preferable as it will focus the pressure on the target area. "Ensure both your skin and tool are clean, position the tool around the blackhead, and gently press to release the sebum and dead skin blocking the pore." If no debris comes out immediately, stop pressing and allow the area to rest before attempting again. Once you're done, follow up with a quick cleanse of your face.

Top Blackhead Extractors

When you have a stubborn blackhead that needs to be cleared quickly and you can’t visit a dermatologist, these are the best comedone extractors to use in a pinch.

1. Zwilling Beauty Twinox Black-and-Whitehead Remover

If you're looking for a tool that offers a touch of luxury without a high price tag, Rackley recommends the Zwilling Beauty Black And Whitehead Remover. "It's priced under $20 and the ergonomic handle feels secure and durable during use," she shares.

2. Tweezerman No-Slip Skin Care Tool

The Tweezerman blackhead extractor is the epitome of classic design. "It’s not overly fancy, but it gets the job done. Made from stainless steel, it features a textured handle for a secure grip," says Rackley.

3. Ulta Blackhead Extractor

Unlike traditional extractors with loops at each end, this one features a fine-point tip for precise blackhead removal. The ends are sharp, so be cautious when using it.

4. JPNK 6 PCS Blackhead Remover

With over 42,000 reviews on Amazon, this six-piece set is perfect for tackling both blackheads and whiteheads. Each tool is crafted from stainless steel and comes with a sleek case for easy storage and transport.

5. DERMAFLASH DERMAPORE Ultrasonic Pore Extractor & Serum Infuser

This isn’t your average blackhead extractor. The DERMAFLASH device uses ultrasonic technology to clear pores as you glide it over your skin. It features two modes: "Extract Mode" for cleaning out pores of oil, dirt, and blackheads, and "Infuse Mode" for enhancing the absorption of active ingredients in any skincare product you apply afterward.

6. Freeshow 2022 Newest Blackhead Remover Pore Vacuum

Similar to a traditional vacuum that sucks up dirt and debris from your carpets, this pore vacuum targets blackheads on your skin. The top-selling device on Amazon features five suction levels and five suction probes, making it safe for use on sensitive skin.

Frequently Asked Questions

• How do you soften a blackhead to extract it?

  To remove a blackhead, start by softening the skin. Gently cleanse your face and follow up with a steam treatment. Afterward, apply a warm, wet washcloth to your face, then use a rich moisturizer to further soften the skin before extraction.

• How do you draw out a deep blackhead?

  To help prevent blackheads, incorporate exfoliating products, such as those with salicylic acid, into your routine. Never use your nails to remove blackheads. Instead, steam your face and use proper extraction tools to prep the skin.

• Is extracting blackheads good for your skin?

  If done properly, regular extractions can help prevent breakouts. However, using unclean or improper tools may lead to infection. If you're unsure, it's best to visit a dermatologist.

• What happens to a blackhead if they are not extracted?

  Blackheads near the surface of the skin will usually clear up on their own, but deeper blackheads can develop into inflammatory acne if left untreated, caused by a build-up of oil and bacteria.