A crop circle spotted in Alton Barnes, England, in June 2004.
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgAs the sun dips below the horizon in southern England, a field lies undisturbed. By dawn, it transforms into a sprawling canvas of art, adorned with intricate designs of circles, rings, and complex geometric patterns. The question lingers: who is behind this creation?
Could crop circles be the handiwork of extraterrestrial beings? Do they hint at otherworldly phenomena, or are they simply the result of natural forces like powerful wind patterns? Alternatively, might they be sophisticated pranks orchestrated by skilled and determined individuals? While enthusiasts and skeptics debate, the mystery endures.
This article delves into the enigma of crop circles — their nature, locations, creation methods (as claimed by some), and the scientific efforts to differentiate between the extraordinary and the plausible.
This "optical labyrinth" formation, found near Savernake Forest in Wiltshire, features 180 distinct standing and flattened elements and spans roughly 200 feet (60 meters).
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgCrop circles are intricate patterns that emerge in fields, created by selectively flattening certain areas of crops while leaving others untouched. The edges are remarkably precise, resembling machine-cut precision. Despite the bending of stalks, they remain unharmed, and the crops typically continue to grow unaffected.
These patterns range from simple circular shapes to complex designs featuring interconnected geometric forms.
For centuries, farmers have reported discovering strange circular patterns in their fields. Historical records trace these phenomena back to the 1500s, with a 17th-century English woodcut depicting a devilish figure creating a crop circle. Locals referred to this figure as the "mowing devil."
Early Studies of Crop Circles
In an 1880 edition of the journal "Nature," amateur scientist John Rand Capron documented a peculiar formation near Guildford, Surrey, in southern England. He noted, "a wheat field with patches of crops flattened in circular patterns, visible from a distance." He added, "... I found no local explanation for these unusual shapes ... They seemed to me to result from some cyclonic wind activity ..."
Reports of crop circles were infrequent until the 20th century, when they began appearing in the 1960s and '70s in England and the United States. However, the phenomenon gained widespread attention in 1980 after a farmer in Wiltshire County, England, discovered three large circles, each approximately 60 feet (18 meters) wide, in his oat field. UFO researchers and media flocked to the site, bringing global awareness to crop circles.
By the 1990s, crop circles had evolved into a popular tourist attraction. In 1990 alone, over 500 circles appeared across Europe. Within a few years, the number grew to thousands. Visitors traveled globally to witness these formations, and some farmers even began charging fees to view their mysterious fields.
Cereology
Enthusiasts of crop circles, known as cereologists — named after Ceres, the Roman goddess of agriculture — often attribute these formations to extraterrestrial beings or plasma vortices. They are sometimes referred to as "croppies."
Crop Circle Designs
A crop circle formation located in Ogbourne St. George, Wiltshire.
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgCrop circles are not limited to simple circular shapes; they can appear in a variety of forms. The most common design is a single circle, but they can also appear in pairs (doublets), triplets, or quadruplets. Often, these circles are surrounded by a thin outer ring.
Inside a crop circle, the stalks are usually bent into a swirling pattern, with the swirls rotating either clockwise or counterclockwise. In designs with multiple circles, one might swirl clockwise while another swirls counterclockwise. Some circles even feature two layers of stalks, each swirling in opposite directions.
A crop circle near Silbury Hill in Wiltshire, England, that bears a striking resemblance to an Aztec sun stone.
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.org
A formation in West Kennett, Wiltshire, resembling the Celtic symbol known as the Triskell.
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgCrop circles vary in size from just a few inches to several hundred feet in diameter. Early designs were typically simple circles, but after 1990, they evolved into more intricate patterns known as pictograms. These designs can depict a wide range of imagery, including smiling faces, flowers, or even words. While some are original creations, others draw inspiration from ancient symbols.
Certain complex crop circle patterns are based on mathematical principles. Gerald S. Hawkins, an astronomer and former professor at Boston University, analyzed several formations and discovered precise numerical relationships between the positions of circles, triangles, and other shapes.
In one formation featuring an outer and inner circle, the outer circle's area was exactly four times that of the inner circle. This precise arrangement suggests that the creators, whoever they may be, possess a deep understanding of Euclidean geometry, the study of flat surfaces pioneered by the mathematician Euclid of Alexandria.
Some crop circles feature thin lines extending outward, known as spurs. These lines are not part of the original design but are instead created by the tracks of a farmer's tractor.
Crop Writing
In 1987, a crop formation spelled out the message "WEARENOTALONE." Skeptics pointed out that if extraterrestrials were responsible, the message would likely have read "YOUARENOTALONE."
Crop Circle Locations
A crop circle formation located in Avebury Trusloe, Wiltshire.
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgThe majority of crop circles have appeared in southern England, particularly in Hampshire and Wiltshire. Many of these formations are found near Avebury and Stonehenge, two ancient sites known for their large stone monuments and mystical significance.
Crop circles are not exclusive to England; they have also been found in the United States, Canada, Australia, Japan, India, and various other countries worldwide.
The crop circle "season" spans from April to September, aligning with the growing period. These formations are usually made under the cover of darkness, shielding their creators—whether human or otherwise—from prying eyes.
Crop circles can form in a variety of fields, including wheat, corn, oats, rice, rapeseed, barley, rye, tobacco, and even weed-covered areas. Many of these formations are found in low-lying regions near steep hills, lending some credence to theories involving wind patterns.
Who Makes Crop Circles?
Doug Bower and Dave Chorley, photographed in Doug's Southampton studio in 1992.
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgDetermining who or what is responsible for creating these crop formations is no simple task. Some believe they are the result of UFO activity, while others argue they are natural occurrences. There are also those who insist they are intricate hoaxes crafted by skilled teams of circle makers.
UFOs and Aliens
One of the most debated theories suggests that crop circles are created by extraterrestrial visitors — akin to alien calling cards left behind.
Supporters of this theory propose that the circles are either marks from UFO landings or messages sent from distant worlds for humanity. Some witnesses have reported seeing UFO-like lights and hearing unusual sounds near crop circle sites.
Winds
One of the most scientifically grounded theories suggests that small, swirling wind currents known as vortices, akin to 'dust devils,' are responsible for the formation of crop circles. These rotating columns drive a powerful gust of air downward, flattening crops like wheat. Such vortices are frequently observed in hilly regions, including parts of southern England.
According to Dr. Terence Meaden from the Tornado and Storm Research Organization (TORRO) in Wiltshire, England, the vortices that form crop circles are energized, a concept known as the Plasma Vortex Theory. As dust particles are swept up in these charged, spinning air columns, they can emit a glow, potentially explaining the mysterious luminous lights often reported near crop circles.
However, a lingering question persists: How can a brief burst of spinning air create such detailed and geometrically precise crop circles?
Aircraft
Some researchers propose that small airplanes or helicopters generate downdrafts capable of pressing crops into patterns. Despite attempts to replicate this phenomenon, the precise downdrafts required to produce the flawless, rounded edges typical of most crop circles have yet to be achieved.
Earth Energy
Certain experts propose that the planet generates its own energy, which manifests in the creation of crop circles. One potential source of this energy is electromagnetic radiation. Notably, researchers have detected intense magnetic fields within these formations, and some visitors have described experiencing a tingling sensation when inside or near them.
During the early 1990s, Dr. William Levengood, an American biophysicist, observed that crops within these circles exhibited damage similar to plants exposed to microwave heating. He theorized that the crops were being internally and rapidly heated by a form of microwave energy.
Other scientists suggest that the energy originates beneath the surface or within the soil. This energy could either be natural, such as a fungal infection that weakens the crops and causes them to bend, or artificial, like the residual effects of World War II bomb explosions.
Humans
The simplest explanation for crop circles is that they are human-made hoaxes, crafted either for amusement or to baffle researchers.
One of the most notorious hoaxing teams is the British pair Doug Bower and Dave Chorley, famously known as 'Doug and Dave.' In 1991, they revealed that they had created hundreds of crop circles since 1978. To demonstrate their methods, they recorded themselves for the BBC, using a simple rope-and-plank device to form a circle in a Wiltshire field.
Joe Nickell, a Senior Research Fellow at the Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal (CSICOP), points out that crop circles exhibit classic signs of hoaxes: they predominantly appear in southern England, their designs have grown increasingly complex over time (suggesting improved techniques by hoaxers), and their creators avoid being observed in the act.
Despite numerous crop circle creators admitting to hundreds of designs, hoaxes cannot explain the thousands of formations documented. Colin Andrews, a cereologist and author of 'Circular Evidence,' acknowledges that roughly 80 percent of crop circles are likely man-made, but he suggests that the remaining 20 percent may be the result of some 'higher force.'
Energy Effects
Individuals near crop circle sites have reported unusual physical and emotional responses. Some describe feelings of dizziness, confusion, calmness, or anxiety, while others mention hearing a buzzing sound or experiencing a tingling sensation.
Following a visit to the Julia Set formation near Stonehenge in 1996, a group of women noted irregularities in their typical menstrual cycles. Most notably, several post-menopausal women unexpectedly resumed menstruation after being at the site.
How Do You Make a Crop Circle?
John Lundberg, a crop circle creator, demonstrates one of the 'stalk stompers' his team uses to craft formations, standing in front of a combine.
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgCrop circles often display intricate designs, featuring complex geometric shapes and interconnected patterns. However, the fundamental techniques and tools used to create them are surprisingly straightforward.
This is the final formation, crafted in a field across from Silbury Hill in Wiltshire. The team spent five hours creating it.
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgTypically, crop circle creators follow these steps:
- Select a location.
- Sketch a design plan (though some creators prefer to improvise upon arriving at the site).
- At the field, they use ropes and poles to measure and mark the circle.
- One member stands at the center, pivoting on one foot while pressing down the crops with the other to form the core.
- The team defines the circle's radius using a long rope tied to a 4-foot (1.2-meter) board called a stalk stomper (or a garden roller). One person remains at the center while another walks the perimeter, stepping on the board to flatten the outline.
To avoid detection, circle makers work at night and conceal their footprints within existing tractor tracks.
Crop Circles for Profit
Some crop circle creators are transforming their craft into a lucrative business, earning substantial profits. A team featuring artist and filmmaker John Lundberg, along with Rod Dickinson and Wil Russell, travels globally to design crop circles as advertisements for major corporations. Their clients include a billion-dollar computer chip manufacturer, an automotive company, and a digital television provider.
While they keep their exact earnings per design confidential, their project budgets often reach hundreds of thousands of dollars.
How Do Researchers Study Crop Circles?
This formation was found in Eastfield, England, in June 2004. The Western Daily Press described the design as 'strikingly similar to blueprints for one of Nikola Tesla's early inventions.'
Photo courtesy www.circlemakers.orgWhen researchers arrive at a crop circle site, they perform a detailed investigation using various methods, including:
- Interviewing potential eyewitnesses and local residents
- Investigating the site and weather conditions where circles appear
- Analyzing the impacted crops and soil using advanced methods like X-ray diffraction (using X-rays to identify material composition)
- Measuring electromagnetic energy levels within and around the crop circles
- Studying the patterns, such as comparing intricate designs to hieroglyphics or ancient symbols
For decades, researchers have debated the mystery of crop circles, yet a definitive explanation for their existence remains elusive.
