Buzz
An ancient civilization. Altmodern/Getty ImagesMain Insights
- Progress in genetic research and the Neanderthal Genome Project has greatly enhanced our understanding of Neanderthal biology, yet reviving a Neanderthal is still not feasible with today's technology.
- Potential cloning techniques involve modifying the human genome or inserting artificially constructed Neanderthal DNA into a human embryo, though these approaches come with significant technical and ethical dilemmas.
- In addition to scientific obstacles, ethical issues regarding the well-being and cultural integration of a revived Neanderthal raise serious concerns about the practicality and morality of such an endeavor.
Neanderthals and humans lived side by side for millennia, yet their relationship was often fraught with tension. Some theories suggest interbreeding, while others propose more grim scenarios, but regardless, humanity doesn't come off looking particularly noble.
Many anthropologists argue that as resources grew scarce and human populations expanded, we outcompeted Neanderthals for survival. Though they vanished around 30,000 years ago, modern science is now striving to uncover every detail about our closest evolutionary relatives. Perhaps it's driven by a sense of remorse.
Archaeological discoveries continue to reveal insights into Neanderthal life, while breakthroughs in genetics bring us closer to understanding their biology. The Neanderthal Genome Project, a joint initiative involving U.S. firms 454 Life Sciences and Illumina, along with Germany's Max Planck Institute, is at the forefront. This involves extracting DNA from ancient bones, purifying it from contaminants, and reconstructing the genome from fragmented and degraded remains.
In May 2010, scientists unveiled a preliminary sequence of the Neanderthal genome. While this data has clarified aspects like their linguistic abilities and genetic contributions to humans through interbreeding, reviving a Neanderthal remains a distant possibility. Even with a fully sequenced genome and synthetic DNA, cloning a Neanderthal is either extremely challenging or currently impossible.
First, synthetic DNA would need to be encapsulated within a cell, a feat not yet achievable. Alternatively, scientists could attempt to modify the human genome by making an estimated 10 million alterations [source: Zorich]. If this modified cell were a stem cell, it could be grown and implanted into a human or blastocyst, an early-stage embryo. The resulting offspring would exhibit predominantly Neanderthal traits, with some human characteristics.
But would this truly mean reviving Neanderthals? The resulting individual wouldn't emerge with primitive tools or attire. While physiologically ancient, its culture and language would be shaped entirely by its environment. Recreating the extinct way of life of early hominids is an impossible feat.
Additionally, ethical dilemmas abound. Given the experimental nature of cloning, is it morally acceptable to replicate beings so akin to us? If successful, would it lead a fulfilling life? Could it succumb to modern illnesses it has no defenses against?
As we delve deeper into the Neanderthal genome, we uncover more about our own origins and human evolution. While science may one day make their revival possible, will it suffice when the first neo-Neanderthal gazes at us with wide eyes and inquires, "Who am I?"
