Our Toilet Testing Revealed the Top Picks

Top Choice

For those seeking a dependable and efficient toilet that’s simple to upkeep, the Toto Drake is an excellent choice. During our evaluation, we discovered its robust tornado/cyclonic flush not only eliminates the need for double flushing but also ensures 360-degree cleaning coverage, reducing the frequency of deep cleanings with a brush and cleaner. 

We also favored the traditional handle over dual-flush buttons, as it simplifies the installation of practical over-the-toilet storage solutions. Despite being a two-piece model, which demands extra care during exterior cleaning, we were impressed by its robust and durable build (no leaks or scratches), earning it the title of the best overall toilet in our assessment. 

It’s worth mentioning that this toilet does not come with a seat. While this adds an extra cost, it allows flexibility for those who prefer a specific seat, such as one with bidet functionality or heating features. We believe this minor inconvenience is outweighed by the toilet’s efficiency, comfort, and affordable price. 

Type: Two-piece | Bowl Shape: Elongated | Flush Mechanism: Tornado | Gallons Per Flush: 1.6 | Height: 30.1 inches (seat not included)

Top One-Piece Pick

One-piece toilets are ideal for those seeking easier maintenance, as they feature fewer hard-to-reach crevices and corners. The Swiss Madison St. Tropez toilet impressed us with its sleek, modern design and effortless cleaning capabilities. 

During our evaluation, we found the smooth porcelain surface and minimal angles made cleaning the sides and entire unit quick and hassle-free. We also appreciated the soft-close seat and the tool-free, quick-release mechanism, which simplifies removal and cleaning. Additionally, its availability in multiple colors makes it a versatile choice for modern spaces.

While we admire the toilet’s aesthetics and comfort, our testing revealed that its flushing power was less forceful compared to other models. Although there were no clogs or overflows, the weaker flush was noticeable. Nonetheless, we believe it offers excellent value and is a great fit for guest bathrooms. 

Type: One-piece | Bowl Shape: Elongated | Flush Mechanism: Tornado | Gallons Per Flush: 1.6 | Height: 31.18 inches

Top High-Efficiency Pick

For eco-conscious individuals aiming to minimize water consumption, the Toto Aquia IV high-efficiency toilet is an excellent choice. During our tests, we were impressed by its effortless cleaning and the powerful tornado flush mechanism, which consistently performed in a single flush. 

This model offers both single and dual-flush options, each designed to conserve water, and includes a soft-close seat. The ceramic glaze further enhances its appeal by preventing debris and mold buildup. 

We also appreciated its compatibility with the Toto Washlet, which Adams highly recommends. Remarkably, this toilet’s durability was proven when it survived a house fire, showcasing its solid construction.

The standard height of this toilet is a few inches shorter than typical models, which may be a consideration for those requiring extra height. While it’s the priciest option on our list, its advanced features, efficiency, and durability justify the investment.

Type: One-piece | Bowl Shape: Elongated | Flush Mechanism: Tornado | Gallons Per Flush: 1.28 | Height: 28.12 inches

Final Recommendation

Our top choice for the best overall toilet is the Toto Drake Cotton Elongated Standard Height 2-piece Toilet, praised for its powerful flushing technology, ease of maintenance, and comfortable height. Adams also endorses the Toto Drake due to its exceptional quality, affordable price, and versatility in fitting most bathroom designs. For a one-piece model, we highly recommend the Swiss Madison Well Made Forever SM-1T254 St. Tropez One Piece Toilet, and for a high-efficiency option, the Toto Aquia IV Toilet is our preferred choice.

Our Comprehensive Evaluation Method

To identify the top-performing toilets, we conducted an extensive six-month evaluation of six leading models. Our assessment criteria included water efficiency, available features, cost, maintenance simplicity, and user comfort. We replaced existing toilets with the test models, meticulously documenting the installation procedure and duration.

During the testing phase, we utilized all functionalities, including dual flush mechanisms, and performed cleaning routines to assess ease of maintenance. We also monitored noise levels, water flow strength, and recorded any occurrences of blockages, leaks, or overflows.

Expert Tips for Selecting the Perfect Toilet 

Style and Design

With a wide array of designs and styles available, narrowing down your options helps you envision your bathroom’s overall look and determine which model suits your needs best. Our curated list features one two-piece and two one-piece toilets for comparison. 

One-piece toilets are seamlessly constructed, making them heavier but simpler to maintain and more hygienic due to fewer crevices. In contrast, two-piece toilets consist of a separate tank and bowl, offering easier handling and installation, especially in compact areas, though they may appear less streamlined.

Flushing System

While all toilets perform the essential function of flushing, the mechanisms vary widely. Options range from dual-flush buttons to traditional handles, with choices influenced by factors like water conservation goals and the bathroom’s purpose, such as a guest bath versus a primary one.

“From a plumber’s perspective, a standard handle toilet works perfectly fine,” Adams notes. “Repairs for conventional toilets are typically simple and affordable, whereas more complex models may involve higher costs and scarce parts. If water conservation is a priority, a dual-flush toilet is a solid choice, but it’s most effective in a private, high-traffic area like the master bathroom.”

Water Efficiency

Adams highlights that water-efficient toilets are now widely available. Russum adds that beyond conserving water, modern flushing systems in efficient toilets are better equipped to manage waste, minimizing the need for multiple flushes. 

“All modern toilets use a maximum of 1.6 gallons per flush,” Adams explains. “Some models save an extra 0.3 gallons per flush, offering 19% greater efficiency than standard options. Opting for a high-quality toilet from a trusted brand ensures you don’t sacrifice flushing performance for water savings.”

Bowl Design

Toilet bowls and seats are generally available in two designs: round and elongated. Adams notes that elongated bowls are now the modern standard, as round bowls can appear outdated. However, Russum points out that round bowls are ideal for smaller spaces, such as kids' bathrooms. 

“Elongated bowls provide extra comfort and better splash containment for adults, whereas round bowls are easier to clean due to their smaller surface area,” Russum explains.

Seat Elevation

Similar to bowl shapes, toilet seats come in two heights: standard and comfort. Adams mentions that comfort height is increasingly becoming the norm for new toilets, and Russum agrees, emphasizing its benefits for reducing knee and back strain, especially for individuals with mobility challenges, circulation issues, or those who are taller or elderly. 

Standard toilets usually measure between 14.5 and 16 inches in height, while comfort-height models range from 17 to 19 inches. According to Adams, 16.5 inches is the most commonly installed height. All the toilets featured on our list come with a 16-inch seat height.

Intended Use

Identifying specific needs for a toilet simplifies the selection process. For instance, a toilet in a guest bathroom used sporadically can differ from one in a frequently used home office.  

“Guests prefer familiar toilets. They don’t want to struggle with confusing buttons or worry about flushing reliability,” Adams explains. “For guest bathrooms, opt for a straightforward, dependable toilet with a traditional handle.”

Russum also recommends selecting a toilet designed for its main users. “Comfort-height models suit seniors, while soft-close lids are ideal for children, ensuring ease of use and preventing damage,” he advises. Both our top one-piece and high-efficiency toilets include soft-close lids.

Cost Considerations

While high-end toilets can be pricey, there are many budget-friendly options that maintain quality and efficiency. Russum advises evaluating the toilet’s long-term costs, such as water savings, maintenance needs, and durability over time, rather than just the initial purchase price.

“Toilets are a prime example of getting what you pay for,” Adams states. “A basic builder-grade toilet often feels inferior, sits lower than modern standards, and frequently requires double flushing, negating water savings. Additionally, cheaper models are prone to clogging, and any savings can vanish if you need plumbing repairs, replacements, or face water damage.” 

Adams also cautions against overspending on high-end toilets with unnecessary features. Instead, he recommends opting for dependable mid-range models priced between $350 and $900. Our top overall pick fits within this range, while our best high-efficiency option is slightly above and our best one-piece choice is just below.

“There’s no need for toilets with self-flushing mechanisms or built-in music players—yes, those exist! Repairs can be costly, and finding the right parts might delay the process,” he explains.

Common Questions 

Which is better: a one-piece or two-piece toilet? 

“While some argue that two-piece toilets are advantageous because you can replace the tank or bowl separately, we rarely suggest this as plumbers,” Adams says. “Typically, if a toilet is old enough to require replacing one part, it’s better to replace the entire unit at that point.”

From a plumbing standpoint, one-piece toilets are superior because their integrated tank and bowl design reduces potential leak points, Russum explains. “They also prevent hidden mineral deposits that can accumulate between the tank and bowl in two-piece models—over time, this buildup can weaken seals and cause minor leaks or inefficiencies. Their streamlined design also lowers the chance of installation errors due to misaligned components.”

Which flushing technology is best for toilets?

The ideal flushing technology varies based on factors like your plumbing setup, local water pressure, and personal preferences. However, Adams highlights that the Toto Drake, our top overall toilet pick, features one of the most popular and efficient systems. 

“Toto’s Tornado Flush system uses dual water entry points and siphoning technology to ensure thorough and efficient drainage,” he notes.

Which brand offers the best bidet toilets?

After selecting the ideal toilet, you might still feel it’s incomplete. That’s where bidet attachments come in. These practical accessories provide a deep clean without requiring a standalone bidet. Adams suggests the Toto Washlet for its user-friendly and adjustable features.

Trust Our Expertise

This piece was authored by Kat de Naoum, a seasoned contributor to Mytour with a decade of experience covering shopping-related topics. To curate this list, we evaluated six toilets in our lab and at home, focusing on aspects like design, cleaning ease, efficiency, flushing systems, and more. We also gathered expert advice from Aaron Adams, a licensed Master Plumber and founder of Aaron Services: Plumbing, Heating, and Cooling, and Kelly Russum, a plumbing specialist and owner of KC's 23 ½ Hour Plumbing & Air Conditioning.