Buzz
I am unwavering in my conviction that the 'Top That' sequence in Teen Witch ranks among the most iconic moments in cinema history—or at least within the 80s, if not specifically 1989. Naturally, I was thrilled to see this supernatural romantic comedy experience a resurgence, fueled by a special one-night performance by The Groundlings in January and whispers of a potential remake. It’s worth noting that cameos from the original cast wouldn’t be surprising, as many of them remain active in the entertainment industry. Here’s an update on where they are now.
1. Robyn Lively, now running a bed and breakfast.
Getty Images
Louise Miller, famously known as Teen Witch, now owns and operates the Johnson Mill Bed and Breakfast in Midway, Utah. She is also the older sister of Blake Lively. In 2011, Blake was photographed kissing Ryan Reynolds in front of the Johnson Mill sign during their then-secret relationship, leading tabloids to speculate that Blake was giving her sister some publicity. However, Louise is more than just a bed-and-breakfast hostess. Over the years, she has appeared in several TV shows, including Psych, 30 Rock, The Mentalist, Saving Grace, and Criminal Minds.
2. Dan Gauthier, continuing his acting career.
Getty Images
For fans of Teen Witch and Son in Law, here’s a surprising fact: Dan is turning 50 this year. Since his role as Brad Powell, he has stayed active in the industry, with recurring roles on Ellen (the sitcom), Beverly Hills, 90210, Melrose Place, All My Children, and One Life to Live, along with numerous guest appearances on various TV shows. One standout role was as the co-pilot in a 2009 episode of Lost. Interestingly, Teen Witch had a significant impact on Dan’s life—not only was it his first major film, but he also married Randa, the popular blonde from the movie. They now have a son together, pictured here.
3. Joshua John Miller, now a writer.
IMDB
Interestingly, Louise’s younger brother, Richie, was part of Leonardo DiCaprio’s exclusive 90s circle (a group with a unique name worth Googling, though perhaps not at work). After his time in the spotlight, he earned a degree from Yale and later an MFA in Creative Writing from the University of Iowa. He has authored several novels and, as evident from his Tweets, is currently working on another. Additionally, he wrote the screenplay for a werewolf series titled Howl, which was reportedly acquired by Fox but seems to be stuck in development limbo or never fully materialized.
4. Amanda Ingber, now a celebrity yoga instructor.
Formerly recognized as Polly, the funky teenage rapper, Ingber now spends her days teaching yoga to A-list celebrities like Jennifer Aniston, Kate Beckinsale, and Jennifer Lawrence.
5. Zelda Rubinstein, who has since passed away.
Getty Images
Zelda, known for her distinctive voice and petite stature, was a favorite in Hollywood for supernatural roles. Standing at 4 feet 3 inches, she became iconic in Poltergeist before her memorable role as Madame Serena. After Teen Witch, she appeared in shows like Tales from the Crypt, Martin, Caroline in the City, Hey Arnold, and The Pretender. She also had a recurring role on Picket Fences and narrated 48 episodes of The Scariest Places on Earth. A passionate AIDS activist and advocate for little people, Rubinstein passed away in 2010 at the age of 76.
6. Noah Blake, now a SyFy star.
For those who adored Polly’s crush on Rhet Capaletti, you’ll be pleased to know he’s still active in acting. He recently appeared on The Office and starred in the SyFy film Piranhaconda, along with roles in early 2000s shows like V.I.P., JAG, ER, and LAX.
Blake is also the son of Robert Blake, as his name might suggest. Here, he discusses his father’s murder charges.
7. Shelley Berman, the actor who portrayed Larry David’s father.
Shelley Berman, a celebrated figure in both theater and film, has maintained a steady career since his minor role in Teen Witch. Even in his eighties, he remained active with appearances in Entourage, Pushing Daisies, Hannah Montana, and Boston Legal. However, his standout performance is undoubtedly as Nat, Larry David’s father in Curb Your Enthusiasm. In Teen Witch, Berman depicted a grumpy elderly man who humiliates Louise, while in Curb, he masterfully plays a similarly irritable character who constantly embarrasses Larry. One memorable scene features the duo debating over Larry’s sandwich.
8. Marcia Wallace, the iconic voiceover artist.
Getty Images
Marcia Wallace transitioned from playing Ms. Malloy, the quirky drama instructor, to voicing Mrs. Krabappel, the cynical, chain-smoking teacher. While Wallace is best known for her role as Bart Simpson’s fourth-grade teacher on The Simpsons, her voiceover talents extended to shows like Darkwing Duck, The Angry Beavers, Captain Planet, the Aladdin TV series, and the Batman TV series. Additionally, she portrayed Annie Wilkes on The Young and the Restless and had a significant role as Maggie the maid in That’s My Bush back in 2001.
9. Rita Wilson, a multifaceted talent known for her work as an actress, producer, singer, and as the spouse of Hanx.
Getty Image
If you don’t recall Rita Wilson’s role in Teen Witch, you’re not alone—IMDB lists her as a dancer, though her exact scene remains elusive. She likely appeared in the iconic choreographed high school dance sequence at the film’s conclusion. Fast forward to today, and Rita has carved out an impressive career. She produced My Big Fat Greek Wedding and its subsequent projects, maintained her acting career, and even released an album featuring covers of 60s and 70s hits last year.
