Buzz
We place our lives in the hands of the medical community, often without a second thought. After all, we have no choice, right? They are the ones who prescribe those powerful medications that relieve our pain, and for that, we trust them. However, the industry is run by humans, and as we all know, humans are prone to mistakes. In some cases, these mistakes are more than just errors—they reflect a lack of concern for the public's well-being. Whether intentional or a result of negligence, a scandal remains a scandal.
Here are 10 of the most jaw-dropping medical scandals to have ever occurred.
10. Thalidomide
Thalidomide was first created in Germany in 1954 and marketed as a sedative as well as a treatment for morning sickness in pregnant women, colds, flu, and nausea. However, it was during pregnancy that the drug caused the most destruction. Animal testing showed that it was nearly impossible to administer a lethal dose of thalidomide to animals, which led to the conclusion that it was safe for human use.
The first baby affected by the drug was born in Germany on Christmas Day in 1956, and the birth defects caused were nothing short of horrific. These included missing or shortened limbs, malformed hands and ears, underdeveloped eyes, sensory impairments, and brain damage—just to name a few.
For five years, the drug continued to harm babies before the link between pregnant women taking the drug and its devastating effects on their unborn children was finally established. Around 100,000 babies were impacted by the drug.
9. Atherectomy for Peripheral Artery Disease
When the government altered the way doctors were compensated for performing atherectomies, the dynamics shifted. Private practitioners were given incentives to conduct outpatient atherectomies, helping to alleviate pressure on the hospital system.
A low standard was set for treating arterial blockages, leading to an influx of patients. Between 2017 and 2021, Medicare paid out $1.4 billion for atherectomy procedures—roughly half of all the payments for the procedure—going to about 200 providers who performed the procedure in large volumes.
The aftermath included a series of amputations resulting from the risky artery surgery, procedures that could have been avoided with equally effective but more affordable treatments. Researchers and doctors soon uncovered widespread misuse of the surgery, leading to a wave of lawsuits.
8. The Tuskegee Syphilis Study
When government agencies decide to experiment, they don't hold back. Back in the day, when the U.S. Public Health Service was attempting to understand syphilis, they saw an opportunity to conduct an unethical experiment on their patients to observe the full progression of the disease.
It was 1932 in Tuskegee, Alabama, where nearly 600 African American men were recruited under the false promise of receiving free medical treatment. Among them were 399 men who were diagnosed with latent syphilis. They were told they had 'bad blood,' while the remaining 201 men were used as a control group.
To study the disease, the men suffering from syphilis were denied effective treatment. One by one, they fell victim to the devastating effects of the illness: blindness, insanity, various ailments, and eventually death. In total, 128 men died, 40 wives became infected, and 19 children were born with congenital syphilis as a direct result.
7. The Soothing Syrup
When a new patent medicine hit the market, it was touted as a cure-all for small children—promising to ease teething, freshen breath, and relieve constipation. And what better way to achieve these benefits than with morphine? In the 19th century, Mrs. Winslow’s Syrup was introduced, but mothers were unaware that each bottle contained dangerously high levels of morphine and alcohol. Unsurprisingly, the syrup delivered on its promises all too effectively.
Morphine, a potent and addictive painkiller, can be fatal to infants even in small doses. Babies who consumed Mrs. Winslow's Syrup would fall asleep, only to never wake up, triggering widespread outrage. This public outcry over poisonings and contaminated products eventually led to the passage of the Pure Food and Drug Act in 1906. However, it wasn't until the 1930s that the product was finally removed from the shelves.
6. The Organ Racket
We've all heard the horrifying urban legend—you go out for a night on the town, drink too much, black out, and wake up in a bathtub full of ice with a note saying your kidneys have been stolen. It’s the stuff of nightmares.
In 2008, it was revealed that an estimated 400 to 500 kidney transplants had been carried out over nearly nine years, all under sinister circumstances. Victims were promised job opportunities, only to be coerced into giving up their organs. These individuals, mainly impoverished laborers from villages near Delhi, were often drugged, and those who resisted had their kidneys removed without consent.
The arrests of five individuals—two from the U.S. and three from Greece—at a luxury guesthouse in Gurgaon, India, exposed the dark underbelly of a particular criminal operation. This was the beginning of the collapse of a shocking racket orchestrated by a doctor in a city that was booming with illicit activity.
5. Asthma Cigarettes
We all know the dangers of smoking—how it leads to lung disease and cancer, just like the sun causes sunburn and a bee can sting. But imagine a time when this knowledge wasn’t common. This was the early 20th century, a time when the harmful effects of bad habits on our bodies were not fully understood. Smoking was a prime example of this ignorance.
When smoking became popular, it wasn’t just considered a fashionable activity; it was also recommended as a treatment for various respiratory conditions, including asthma. Page’s Inhalers were nothing more than medically endorsed cigarettes, prescribed to provide temporary relief from asthma, hay fever, and basic nasal irritations.
4. Defective Silicone
Just like you can't take the crankshaft from an old Nissan Skyline, melt it down, and reshape it into a bracket for hip replacement surgery, you shouldn't use random materials found in the workshop for silicone breast implants. Yet, that's precisely what the French company Poly Implants Prothèse did when they used industrial-grade silicone in breast enhancement procedures.
These implants were pulled from the market in 2010 after it was discovered that the silicone used was substandard and posed a significant risk for rupture. It was also found that the non-medical grade silicone was contaminated with high levels of cyclic siloxanes, leading to investigations into potential toxicological effects.
An estimated 30,000 women in France had received the implants. After the product was withdrawn, an inquiry determined that the former owner, Jean-Claude Mas, was guilty of aggravated fraud. He was sentenced to four years in prison and fined €75,000.
3. Monster Stuttering Study
The concept was straightforward—drawing attention to a child's natural pauses in speech could trigger stuttering. To test this idea, researchers at the University of Iowa placed a group of normally fluent orphans (yes, orphans) into a controlled environment.
For six months, these orphans were yelled at, humiliated, and threatened to see if the pressure would lead them to stutter in fear or confusion. The results of the study concluded that pushing a child to speak more fluently could indeed result in them developing a stutter.
What also became evident was that the children involved endured lasting psychological damage. As a result, they received compensation to avoid prolonged legal battles, although neither the University nor the government admitted any fault.
2. HIV Blood
For hemophiliacs, even the smallest injury can be fatal, as blood loss can quickly spiral out of control. Because of this, they may require significant blood transfusions. When a tape surfaced of Akihito Matsumura and his team discussing the use of non-heat-treated blood products for their patients, a scandal broke.
Despite the government's partnership with the Red Cross, they failed to stop the use of contaminated blood products. This negligence resulted in over 1,800 hemophiliacs contracting HIV in the 1980s, and tragically, 400 of them later succumbed to AIDS.
The issue wasn't that the technology to properly treat the blood didn’t exist—it was a matter of profit. Discarding the stock of untreated products would have led to financial losses. Years later, three executives were found guilty, receiving prison sentences of 2, 18, and 16 months respectively.
1. Cancer Injections
When Chester Southam proposed continuing a cancer research project he had been working on for over a decade, it initially appeared to be a valid idea. He informed patients that they were receiving human cells in growth tubes, but the concept of informed consent was far from consideration.
The scandal only broke when three of Southam’s colleagues resigned in protest, accusing him of injecting liver cancer cells into patients at a facility that specialized in elderly and physically dependent individuals, all in the name of advancing his research.
In total, 22 patients were injected with cancer cells. While Southam was never formally charged, he was put on probation for a year. Fun Fact: Just a few years later, Southam became the president of the American Association for Cancer Research.
