The Top 6 Water Filter Pitchers, Tested and Reviewed

Best Overall

The Brita 10-Cup Rapids Stream Water Filter Pitcher is our top choice due to its ease of use and outstanding performance during our testing. Setting up this pitcher is simple—just rinse it with cold water, clean the container, and fill it. Unlike many other pitchers, it filters as you pour, meaning there’s no long wait for it to fill up. The filter began working as soon as we started pouring, and in moments we had fresh, clean water. It’s also easy to fill and pour, and fits comfortably under the sink without any issues. 

We were also impressed with how this pitcher enhanced the taste of our water. The control water had a noticeable chlorine aftertaste, while the filtered water tasted refreshing and clean, thanks to Brita's activated-carbon stream filter. Additionally, the filtered water appeared slightly clearer than the control water. However, if water quality is a top priority for you, it’s important to note that this filter primarily removes chlorine and does not address other contaminants like heavy metals and bacteria. 

During our testing, we found no significant downsides to this pitcher. Its compact size fits comfortably in most refrigerators, and it’s both lightweight and easy to pour. It also features an electronic indicator on top to let you know when it’s time to replace the filter (approximately every two months). 

Capacity: 10 cups | Dimensions: 11.02 x 5.43 x 16.38 inches | Filter Replacement Interval: Every 40 gallons (about 2 months) | Dishwasher Safe: No

Best Compact

This compact pitcher stands out with its coconut shell carbon filter, a newer type of filter that boasts increased porosity, improving its ability to remove contaminants. It’s also more eco-friendly to produce. After filling it for the first time, we noticed a slight metallic aftertaste in the filtered water compared to the control tap water, but this disappeared after we filtered the water a second time. 

The Hydros Glass Slim Pitcher features a slim design, measuring less than 5 inches wide, making it easy to fill with one hand. Even without a handle, it was simple to grasp and pour smoothly. We appreciated its glass construction for sustainability and easy cleaning. However, it’s not ideal for households with young children as it could break easily. Also, its smaller size requires more frequent refilling, which could be inconvenient in larger households.

We were particularly impressed by how quickly the filter worked, filling up almost instantly as our tap water flowed into it. However, there are no indicators to signal when the filter needs replacing, so you'll have to set your own reminders. 

Capacity: 5 cups | Dimensions: 4.25 x 4.25 x 10.5 inches | Filter Replacement Interval: 40 gallons (around two months) | Dishwasher Safe: Yes

Best Large

For larger households, we recommend the Pur 11-cup pitcher. During our testing, we were impressed by how light it felt for its size. Even when it was half full, we could comfortably hold it with one hand and pour a glass. The handle is slim and easy to grip, enhancing its practicality. Although the pitcher was heavier when completely filled, it was still manageable.

In our taste test, we noticed a faint metallic aftertaste compared to our control tap water, but it was still crisp and refreshing. Filtering the water took about three minutes, which is fairly quick, though it took a little longer than the package suggests. Filling the basin once provided roughly half a pitcher of filtered water.

The Pur filters are effective at eliminating contaminants such as mercury, copper, and chlorine, which helps make your water both safer to drink and better tasting. We also liked the built-in electronic indicator that reminds you to replace the filter every two months. While the arrows that guide you on how to insert the filter could be clearer, overall, this pitcher is an excellent choice for those needing a larger capacity.

Capacity: 11 cups | Dimensions: 6.6 by 9.9 by 10.3 inches | Filter Replacement Frequency: Every 40 gallons (about 2 months) | Dishwasher Safe: Yes

Best Filter for Durability

This pitcher utilizes Brita Elite filters, which only require replacement twice a year, compared to the typical two-month intervals for regular filters. In addition to eliminating chlorine for better taste and odor, the activated carbon filters also reduce other contaminants like cadmium and mercury. The top-mounted electronic indicator keeps you on track for filter replacements.

In our blind taste test, the difference in taste was clear. While the control water had a thicker texture and a lingering chlorine aftertaste, the filtered water was light, crisp, and refreshing. It genuinely encouraged us to drink more water and stay hydrated.

Not only did this pitcher enhance the taste of our water, but it was also incredibly easy to use. It fit perfectly in our sink and fridge, even with its generous 10-cup capacity. The handle is comfortable to grip, and it's light enough to pour with one hand. The easy-fill lid with a simple press-to-open feature saved us from struggling with the top. The only downside was that it required multiple fills to reach its full capacity, but overall, this pitcher was very practical and helped us reduce the need for frequent filter replacements.

Capacity: 10 cups | Dimensions: 10.22 by 5.68 by 10.39 inches | Filter Replacement Frequency: Every 120 gallons (approximately 6 months) | Dishwasher Safe: No

Best for Well Water

The Epic Nano Water Filter Pitcher is among the most durable pitchers we tested, making it ideal for those using well water. Featuring an NSF-certified sub-micron filter, it combines nanofiber technology and activated carbon to eliminate 99.9% of contaminants, including bacteria, heavy metals, and fluoride. The filter only requires replacement after 150 gallons, or about three to four months of regular use. However, due to its thorough filtration process, it took roughly 12 minutes for the water to pass through the reservoir.

In addition to its highly effective filter, we were impressed with the pitcher’s thoughtful design. Despite holding 10 cups, it has a sleek, space-saving shape that fits easily onto fridge shelves, keeping them uncluttered. The built-in LED timer is a nice touch, reminding you when it’s time to replace the filter. We also appreciated how lightweight it is, even when fully filled, and the smooth pour it offers.

We were thoroughly impressed by the improvement in taste this pitcher delivered. Our tap water, which had a faint metallic taste, was transformed into crisp, clean water with no aftertaste. It also cleared up any slight cloudiness in the tap water, leaving it perfectly transparent. Though on the pricier side, we believe the investment is worthwhile due to its excellent performance, ease of use, and noticeable improvement in taste.

Capacity: 10 cups | Dimensions: 10 by 10 by 8 inches | Filter Replacement Frequency: Every 150 gallons (approximately 3-4 months) | Dishwasher Safe: No

Top Dispenser Choice

For gatherings or shared spaces, a water dispenser is an excellent choice, offering a larger capacity and an easy-to-use spout. This Pur dispenser, with a 30-cup capacity and sleek design, fits perfectly in most fridges. It features convenient handles for portability and a powerful filtration system that removes harmful substances like lead. After filling the top section, the water took approximately 30 minutes to filter through, filling the bottom tank halfway.

During our blind taste test, we immediately noticed a difference in the taste and smell of the water. The control tap water had an unpleasant odor, while the filtered water was crisp and refreshing. The taste difference was stark: the tap water had a chlorine-like flavor, whereas the filtered water was much cleaner and more palatable. We were much more confident drinking from the dispenser.

Setting up this dispenser was a breeze. We simply soaked the filter for 15 minutes and cleaned the pitcher, which is divided into three parts for easy maintenance. The filter was easy to insert, and the activation of the indicator light was straightforward. While the larger bottom tank was a bit tricky to clean due to its size, the process was otherwise smooth. A max fill line would make it even better, but we highly recommend this large-capacity dispenser for its user-friendliness and ease of use.

Capacity: 30 cups | Dimensions: 5.3 by 15.3 by 10.1 inches | Filter Replacement Frequency: Every 40 gallons (roughly 2 months) | Dishwasher Safe: Yes

Final Thoughts

Our top choice is the Brita 10-Cup Rapids Stream Water Pitcher, praised for its easy setup, rapid filtration, and noticeable improvement in water taste. If you're seeking a pitcher with a stronger filter, we suggest the Epic Nano Water Filter Pitcher, known for its ability to eliminate bacteria and heavy metals, especially in well water. 

Our Evaluation Process

To identify the best water filter pitchers, we collected water samples from our offices in New York City, Birmingham, and Des Moines, and sent them for analysis. Rick Andrew, a seasoned consultant with 30 years of expertise in water purification, analyzed the results. Although all water was deemed safe for consumption, the Des Moines water had the highest turbidity, prompting us to evaluate 18 water filter pitchers at their lab. 

For our first test, we compared the taste and odor of untreated tap water with that of water filtered through the pitchers. Afterward, we used the pitchers daily for two weeks, filling them and consuming the filtered water. Throughout the testing period, we evaluated how the water tasted, the ease of setup and usage, and whether the filter justified its price. 

Expert Tips for Choosing the Right Water Filter Pitcher

Key Materials to Consider

The most popular materials used for water filter pitchers are glass and plastic. Each has its own set of benefits and drawbacks, so your choice will depend on your personal needs. Plastic is lighter and more durable, making it a better option for households with young children where breakage might be a concern. Conversely, glass is more eco-friendly, and while it’s heavier and more prone to breaking, it can add a sleek, stylish touch to your fridge. 

Capacity

Water filter pitchers are available in a range of sizes, and there’s no definitive ‘best’ capacity. As Ajami explains, “It’s all about how much time you have and how much water you need.” Smaller pitchers typically hold around 5 to 6 cups, making them great for solo dwellers or smaller spaces. Standard models hold between 7 to 10 cups, but if you need to filter large quantities, consider a filtered dispenser that can accommodate up to 30 cups of water. 

Filter

Despite the wide variety of water filters, Ajami notes that the differences are often smaller than they seem. The majority of water filter pitchers use activated carbon to eliminate contaminants. The most efficient filters are carbon block types, where the activated carbon is molded into bricks. These offer more surface area for contact with the water, making them better at removing impurities, but they can be pricier and may become clogged with debris over time. 

Granulated activated carbon filters are the most frequently used type, although they tend to be less effective due to their smaller surface area. While they are less prone to clogging than carbon block filters, they can allow water to pass through once their effectiveness diminishes. If you opt for a granulated activated carbon filter, it’s essential to regularly replace it to maintain its efficiency.

The performance of both carbon block and granulated activated carbon filters can depend on how slowly water flows through them. Some filters are designed primarily to improve the taste of water and remove chlorine, while others have the capability to filter out substances like VOCs, asbestos, and various other contaminants.

An increasing number of water filter pitchers, including the Hydros Glass Slim Pitcher, are incorporating coconut shell carbon filters. These filters offer a larger surface area than regular activated carbon, making them more effective at removing contaminants from water. Additionally, coconut shell carbon is a renewable resource, making it a more eco-friendly choice, and it won’t leave unsightly black particles in your water. 

If you’re concerned about a specific contaminant in your water, Ajami suggests consulting resources such as SimpleLab (which is still expanding its database) or EWG. These resources can help you identify the contaminants present in your water, so you can choose the filter that best suits your needs. However, Ajami advises, “If there is a significant issue with the water source, pitchers won’t necessarily resolve it. Simply using a pitcher doesn’t guarantee you’ll be able to remove all the lead.”

Other Water Filter Pitchers You May Want to Consider

ZeroWater 12-Cup Ready-Pour 5-Stage Water Filtration Pitcher: This pitcher was highly effective in removing chlorine from both the odor and taste of our tap water, leaving it tasting crisp and refreshing. However, it is quite heavy, which may not make it suitable for households with children or individuals with limited mobility. Additionally, the spout at the bottom splattered water when used. 

Seychelle Gen 2 Dual pH2O Pure Water Pitcher: One feature we appreciated was the ability to fill the pitcher without needing to lift the lid. Unfortunately, the spouts provided for changing the filter didn’t fit our faucet, making the setup process more cumbersome. Considering the price, we feel there are more effective alternatives that offer better overall value. 

Frequently Asked Questions

How frequently should you change the filter in your water pitcher?

There's no universal answer, as how often you need to replace the filter depends on how regularly you use the pitcher. “It really depends on factors like where you live, the hardness of your water, and what you use the water for,” says Ajami. “If the water comes from a clean source that doesn’t require much treatment, the filter will last longer than for someone using hard water.” 

Another important factor in determining when to change your filter is how often you refill the pitcher. According to Ajami, “It’s less about time and more about the amount of water flowing through the filter.” Typically, filters last for about 40 gallons or two months of use, but always refer to the care instructions for your pitcher. If you notice slower water flow or a strange taste, it's time for a replacement. Many pitchers also feature an electronic indicator on the lid that alerts you when it's time to change the filter.

How do you clean a water filter pitcher?

It's important to clean your water pitcher every time you replace the filter to avoid mold and mineral build-up. Some pitchers are dishwasher-safe, while others must be hand-washed, so always follow the manufacturer's care guidelines. For a deeper clean, use mild dish soap and a toothbrush to scrub the hard-to-reach spots. To tackle mold, apply a white vinegar solution and scrub with a toothbrush. 

Most manufacturers suggest replacing filters rather than washing them. However, Ajami explains that if you're just filtering for better taste, you might try backwashing the filter. This involves pushing water through the filter in the opposite direction, but it might not work with all filters. She emphasizes that if you're concerned about contaminants, it’s better to simply replace the filter instead of backwashing it.

Do all water filter pitchers remove bacteria?

While many water filter pitchers can eliminate contaminants like lead, copper, and chlorine, not all are equipped to remove bacteria. Tap water is usually treated for bacteria, but if you're worried about it, look for filters that specifically mention bacterial removal. Many companies provide test reports on their websites so you can see how effective their filters are against various bacteria before buying. If you're concerned about bacteria, we recommend the Epic Nano Water Filter Pitcher, which has been shown to remove bacteria, giardia, cryptosporidium, and viruses.

Who should use a water filter pitcher?

Water filter pitchers are beneficial for everyone, not just those worried about tap water quality. Ajami clarifies that while tap water is thoroughly tested and treated, filtration needs can differ based on location. If your water contains high levels of contaminants, a filter pitcher can enhance its quality, offering reassurance.

Ajami also highlights that water filter pitchers can soften hard water. “If people are cooking or boiling water, filtered water will leave fewer marks in their pots or appliances,” she explains. Additionally, “many people enjoy water filter pitchers for the improved taste,” which could be helpful if you struggle with drinking enough water every day.

Take Our Word for It

This article was authored by Jen Woo, a seasoned design, lifestyle, and culture writer with over 10 years of experience in content strategy. To create this guide, we tested 18 water filter pitchers in our Lab, evaluating their ability to improve tap water’s taste and smell, ease of use, and overall value. Expert insights were provided by Newsha Ajami, PhD, a hydrologist and director of Urban Water Policy at Stanford University, and the results were analyzed by Rick Andrew, the principal consultant at Rick Andrew Consulting Services, who has over 30 years of expertise in maintaining clean drinking water.