The Transformation of 'Uncle Tom': From Champion of Freedom to Symbol of Betrayal

Harriet Beecher Stowe's groundbreaking antislavery novel, "Uncle Tom's Cabin," became America's inaugural bestseller. It sold 310,000 copies domestically and over 1.5 million internationally, translated into 16 languages, as reported by the Christian Science Monitor. Published in 1852, its most profound effect was enlightening predominantly white northern audiences about the brutal and unchristian nature of slavery.

"Stowe, a dedicated abolitionist, seized the historical moment with precision," explains Patricia Turner, a UCLA professor of African-American studies. "She strategically crafted a narrative to compel readers to recognize the moral contradiction of being a devout Christian while supporting slavery. Her creation of Uncle Tom as a hero, the situations he endured, and the portrayal of slaveholders were meticulously designed to evoke empathy and outrage."

In the novel (which might seem excessively sentimental to contemporary readers), Uncle Tom is portrayed as a devout Christian, a brave and altruistic family man. He risks his life to rescue a young white girl, Little Eva, and ultimately sacrifices himself rather than reveal the whereabouts of two escaped female slaves. He is brutally beaten to death by his merciless owner, Simon Legree, but not before forgiving his oppressor in a manner reminiscent of Jesus Christ on the cross.

"Uncle Tom's Cabin" and its protagonist played a pivotal role in advancing the abolitionist movement before the Civil War. A popular anecdote claims that Abraham Lincoln, upon meeting Stowe, remarked, "So you are the little woman who wrote the book that started this great war."

However, the narrative of Uncle Tom takes a surprising twist.

Considering Uncle Tom was the heroic martyr in one of the 19th century's best-selling books, how did his name evolve into a contemporary slur aimed at Black individuals labeled as 'race traitors'? How did the name of a cherished literary figure become, as Henry Louis Gates Jr. describes it, 'the ultimate tool for black-on-black disparagement'?

'Uncle Tom' Takes to the Stage

Turner argues that the shift of Uncle Tom from hero to 'traitor' began with the countless stage adaptations of 'Uncle Tom's Cabin' that captivated audiences worldwide from the 1850s to the 1930s. Many of these were minstrel shows with white actors in blackface, drastically altering Uncle Tom's character and the novel's plot to appeal to predominantly white, working-class viewers.

"To attract audiences, producers crafted stage performances filled with music, humor, and uplifting conclusions," Turner explains, despite the fact that Stowe's novel was a serious tragedy. "Uncle Tom was depicted as an overly obedient, submissive, and inarticulate Black man who catered to the desires of white slave owners or any white individual, a portrayal starkly different from the book."

The stage adaptations also transformed Tom into a frail, elderly man with white hair, unlike the robust forty-something character in the novel. Turner notes that 19th-century white audiences were uncomfortable with a strong Black male figure on stage unless he was villainized as a 'brute.'

Experts like Turner suggest that the term 'Uncle Tom' as an insult emerged when post-Emancipation Black America sought to dissociate itself from the demeaning image of the submissive slave. For a new generation of Black individuals striving for genuine freedom from white dominance, those who embodied the 'Uncle Tom' stereotype from minstrel shows were viewed as betraying their race.

Or Maybe It Wasn't the Stage Plays...

During her graduate studies at Harvard, Adena Spingarn was struck by the stark contrast between the Christlike portrayal of Tom in "Uncle Tom's Cabin" and the derogatory use of 'Uncle Tom' as a racial slur. After learning about Tom's altered character in minstrel shows, Spingarn examined hundreds of newspaper reviews of various stage adaptations of the novel and uncovered another surprising revelation.

"Both white and Black newspapers portrayed Uncle Tom as a figure of virtue and dignity," Spingarn notes, rejecting the image of him as a submissive elder or a fool. "Some conservative white critics even complained that he spoke too intelligently, too wisely, and was an overly perfect Christian," echoing criticisms of the novel itself.

Spingarn began to doubt the widely accepted notion that the insult 'Uncle Tom' originated from the stage adaptations, particularly since these productions were still considered 'dangerous' in former Confederate states like Kentucky, which prohibited touring performances of 'Uncle Tom's Cabin' as late as 1906.

Rather than attributing the modern derogatory use of 'Uncle Tom' to the 'white imagination,' Spingarn argues in her book, 'Uncle Tom: From Martyr to Traitor,' that the character and his name were shaped by 'fundamental debates within the Black community about who should represent the race and how it should be portrayed.'

'Uncle Tom' as the Ultimate Insult

For modern readers, it's challenging to comprehend the profound influence of 'Uncle Tom's Cabin' in the 19th century and how the character and name of Uncle Tom became synonymous with the image of the American slave.

"Uncle Tom was so universally recognized as a symbol of American slavery that both white and Black Americans referred to the era of slavery as 'the days of Uncle Tom,'" Spingarn explains.

This connection between Uncle Tom and the oppressive era of slavery, marked by enforced white dominance, deeply angered emerging Black political leaders in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Spingarn notes that the term 'Uncle Tom' first acquired a negative meaning within the Black community as early as the 1880s, when a Black lawyer criticized what he described as a submissive, 'Uncle Tom' style of masculinity, stating, 'I despise that as much as anyone.'

The phrase 'Uncle Tom' became a powerful political insult in the 1910s, used by figures like Rev. George Alexander McGuire, a follower of the Black nationalist Marcus Garvey.

"The Uncle Tom n----- must be eliminated, and his role must be assumed by the new leader of the Negro race," McGuire declared at the 1919 Universal Negro Improvement Association convention, "not a Black man with a white heart, but a Black man with a Black heart."

By the 1960s, 'Uncle Tom' had become the go-to insult for any Black individual (primarily men) accused of 'betraying their race.' Malcolm X labeled Martin Luther King Jr. an 'Uncle Tom.' Stokely Carmichael referred to Roy Wilkins, the NAACP executive director, as an 'Uncle Tom.' Muhammad Ali called at least three of his Black opponents 'Uncle Toms.'

In recent times, the term "Uncle Tom" has been used to criticize Black conservatives such as Justice Clarence Thomas and Black individuals who support President Donald Trump. For instance, in 2018, Snoop Dogg labeled Kanye West an "Uncle Tom" after he was seen wearing a "Make America Great Again" hat.

According to Spingarn, the evolving and peculiar history of Uncle Tom is deeply intertwined with America's continuous battle against its foundational sin of slavery and the persistent issue of racism.

"The portrayal of Uncle Tom has shifted over time as it has consistently served as a focal point for discussions on race," Spingarn explains. "These discussions often revolve around defining true Black identity, determining effective protest methods, and shaping the ideal representation of Black individuals."

Uncle Tom remains a relevant figure as long as the United States continues to confront and debate racial issues.

Mytour receives a modest affiliate commission from purchases made via links on our website.