Buzz
In October, TikTok user @notmycarl shared a video titled "How to Get Free Tools from Home Depot," where they explained and appeared to show how to achieve this. The process involves taking an old tool with a lifetime warranty—from brands such as Milwaukee, Husky, Channellock, or Crescent Tools—to a Home Depot without a receipt and swapping it for a new tool of the same brand and model.
Although the new tool comes at no cost, you must have an old tool to trade in. The video creator recommends searching through your father’s old toolbox or scouting yard sales for tools from the mentioned brands. This suggestion hinges on the idea that newer hand tools are better than older ones, even if the older versions are still functional. But is this true? I consulted several home improvement experts to get their opinions.
Has the quality of hand tools gotten better over the years?
While the original TikTok video—now boasting 5.3 million views—brings up several points worth discussing, I’ll concentrate on the quality of hand tools and whether it has evolved over the last few decades. Growing up, I was taught that hand tools aren’t made as well as they used to be, and my toolbox is mostly filled with inherited tools and estate sale discoveries. But would I really benefit from swapping them out for newer versions?
Michael Branover, a home contractor and founder of Branover Contractors Inc, explains that it varies by brand and tool. "Assess the build quality, materials, and any design improvements in newer models," he advises. "Sometimes, newer tools may have altered designs or use less durable materials. It’s essential to research and compare reviews to confirm that the new tools match or surpass the quality of older ones."
Similarly, Matthew Ferris, a master plumber, HVAC specialist, and founder of Ferris Plumbing, notes that determining whether modern tools are as durable as older ones isn’t black and white. "It varies by brand," he says. "Some now use superior materials like stronger alloys, while others may compromise on quality compared to tools made decades ago."
Home Depot’s statement on their exchange policy
What does the major home improvement retailer think about this so-called "hack" for obtaining free tools? When I inquired about the use of their exchange policy for Milwaukee or Husky tools—or any with a full lifetime warranty—a Home Depot spokesperson provided the following emailed statement:
The Husky Lifetime Warranty declares: “If your Husky product ever malfunctions, return it, and we’ll provide a free replacement. This comprehensive warranty grants you specific rights, and you may have additional rights depending on your state.” For further details about Husky warranties, visit this link. Customers are encouraged to consult their nearest Home Depot store for more information.
That’s the complete statement, so reaching out to your local store is advisable for details on exchanging tools from other brands that are still covered under warranty.
