Top 7 Most Comfortable Flats: Tested and Reviewed

Flats aren’t always synonymous with comfort, but that doesn’t mean finding a comfortable pair of flats is out of reach. You don’t have to compromise on style either. Factors like proper arch support, high-quality materials, and a well-designed sole can transform a flat from a closet-dweller to an everyday favorite.

We understand the importance of all-day comfort, which is why we rigorously tested 29 pairs of flats to identify the top seven. Each pair was assessed for fit, durability, support, and, most importantly, comfort. This wasn’t a quick test—we wore each pair for two months, evaluating arch support, sole thickness, sturdiness, and overall comfort. Check out our top picks below and discover your next go-to pair of flats.

Our Team of Experts

Top Pick

Among 29 pairs of flats tested, these claimed the top spot due to their unique material—crafted from nine recycled plastic bottles, a hallmark of Rothy’s—and exceptional support. This makes them an eco-friendly choice, and we found them breathable in both warm and cool climates. Their ability to mold to the foot, similar to Birkenstocks, was particularly impressive, even for someone with swollen feet during late pregnancy, making them a standout option.

The absence of a break-in period was a major advantage, as we experienced no pinching or rubbing even during extended wear. They performed well on various surfaces, including pebbles and concrete, though they felt slightly slippery at first. The sturdy sole ensured durability, preventing any discomfort or bending. After consistent use, they showed no signs of wear, maintaining their quality over time.

Their versatility stood out, as they paired seamlessly with both formal and casual outfits for different occasions. The minimalist design is available in 10 colors, offering plenty of options. While the straps are non-adjustable, their flexibility and comfortable fit made this a minor issue. Overall, these flats provided excellent support and security, making them a reliable choice.

Size Range: 5–13 | Material: Recycled plastic | Sole: Not specified

Top Budget Pick

Priced at just $40, these flats earned our top budget pick. Despite the affordable price, they didn’t compromise on quality. Even after walking 15,000 steps, we experienced no blisters or discomfort, and they stayed breathable and comfortable throughout. They closely resembled our favorite Allbirds flats, which cost more than twice as much, making these an excellent value. In fact, we found them versatile enough to occasionally replace our pricier options.

The timeless, minimalist design makes these flats an excellent choice for everyday wear, pairing effortlessly with jeans, skirts, and even dress pants. During testing, we wore them for work, errands, and social outings, and they required no break-in period. Their secure fit and true-to-size design made them easy to walk in, and they proved durable enough to withstand a machine wash after stepping in mud, making them suitable for unexpected situations.

However, we noted that the padding’s support could be enhanced, as it varied slightly between colors, with some offering less cushioning. Additionally, the grip on the sole could be improved, as they felt less stable on slippery surfaces. Despite these minor drawbacks, their flexibility allowed them to be easily wrung out and cleaned after getting wet, making them a practical choice for various weather conditions.

Size Range: 6–12 | Material: Knit | Sole: Rubber

Top Pick for Warm Weather

These huarache sandals are ideal for summer, earning our top spot. While the website suggests sizing down by half, many reviewers found them true to size. During testing, our regular size provided a secure and comfortable fit. The woven design kept our feet cool and sweat-free, though we did experience some chafing and blisters on our toes and heels during the initial wear.

The firm soles provided excellent support, and the soft leather material adapted to our foot movements rather than remaining stiff. We also appreciated the rubber outer sole’s reliable traction. The unique design stood out, and they performed exceptionally well during testing, even after walking 10,000 steps in a single day.

Size Range: 5–11 | Material: Leather | Sole: Rubber

Top Sandal Pick

Finding a comfortable sandal can be challenging, but the Margaux The Wrap Sandal stood out as the best lace-up flat we’ve ever tried. Despite the laced design, the luxurious leather prevented blisters, and they stayed securely on our feet even during extended wear and various activities. We tested two lace styles—ankle-tied and criss-crossed—and both provided a comfortable fit with no irritation. The 5-millimeter foam padding in the sole offered a soft, cushioned feel.

The soles were thin yet durable, molding to our feet with each use. While the Italian leather lining limited flexibility, it contributed to the shoe’s high quality. To maintain their condition, we recommend using the included dust bag. These sandals are perfect for transitioning from office to evening outings, thanks to their elegant design.

The high quality justifies the $225 price, though it may be a stretch for some budgets. However, for those seeking a lace-up sandal that avoids digging into heels or leaving marks—and is even comfortable enough to wear during pregnancy—it’s a worthwhile investment.

Size Range: 3–14 (narrow, medium, and wide) | Material: Italian Nappa leather | Sole: Not specified

Top Picks for Pointed-Toe Flats

Ideal for fans of pointed-toe designs, Vivaia’s flats seamlessly transitioned from lengthy office hours to casual outings like baseball games, brunches, and even rainy days. The cushioned heel ensured a secure fit, even during quick movements, eliminating the mid-step gaping common in other flats. Remarkably, there was no need for a break-in period—no pinching, rubbing, or blisters occurred. 

The flexible knit upper maintained its shape without stretching during testing. The generous cushioning, especially under the ball and heel, combined with a flexible insole, ensured comfort during extended walks. Additionally, the arch support was noticeable yet not overly rigid, striking a perfect balance between flexibility and stability.

We were particularly impressed by the textured rubber sole, which provided excellent grip on slippery surfaces like marble, tile, wet sidewalks, and even damp subway stairs. The water-resistant feature worked as advertised, with water beading up rather than soaking into the material. The knit upper felt substantial and well-made, showcasing the shoe's overall quality. However, the knit fabric's durability over time raised some concerns, suggesting these might not last as long as other alternatives.

Size Range: 5–11 | Material: Knit | Sole: Rubber

Top Ballet Flats

Ballet flats are a wardrobe essential, and this pair stood out as the most comfortable in our tests. They quickly became our favorite, accompanying us to dinners, work, bars, and shopping trips. The adjustable bow cords allowed us to customize the fit, ensuring they molded perfectly to our feet. Over time, the leather softened, enhancing their comfort. While we experienced minor rubbing during the first wear, it resolved completely afterward.

These flats excelled during long walks, even supporting us for up to eight hours straight. However, extended walks on hard surfaces caused some fatigue. As Rosson advises, “If a style isn’t the most comfortable, reserve it for occasions with minimal walking or standing.” This classic ballet flat, crafted from soft Italian nappa leather, offers a high-end look suitable for both casual and formal settings. Available in 10 timeless colors, it’s an ideal addition to any capsule wardrobe.

The sturdy yet slim leather sole provided durability without compromising comfort. The upper material remained flexible, though the lack of traction, aside from the rubber heel, made them less ideal for wet conditions. Overall, these flats proved that style and comfort can coexist, even replacing sneakers for city strolls in New York.

Size Range: 3–14; narrow, medium, and wide | Material: Italian Nappa leather | Sole: Leather

Ideal for Narrow Feet

These Everlane flats stood out for their plush sole and exceptional leather quality, showcasing excellent craftsmanship. Their flexibility made them easy to put on without any risk of slipping off.

The cushioned sole and breathable perforations ensured comfort during walks. Unlike other flats, these prevented our feet from feeling too close to the ground, a common issue we’ve faced before.

While the shoes are designed to “fit like a glove,” they were so tight that the tops of our feet didn’t fully fit inside, even after several wears. We wished for an elastic or stretch feature, or a wide-width option for those with larger feet. Additionally, the price felt slightly high for such a minimalist design.

Size Range: 5–11 | Material: Leather | Sole: Rubber

Final Verdict

After thorough testing, the Rothy's Square Mary Jane emerged as the most comfortable flat. They adapted well to our feet, complemented various outfits, and provided excellent support even during extended walks. For a budget-friendly option, the Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flat impressed with its timeless design, durability, and all-day comfort.

Our Testing Process

Over two months, we tested 29 pairs of flats in real-world scenarios. Each pair was worn at least twice for a minimum of two hours across various settings, including work, dining out, and running errands, to assess their support and comfort. 

During testing, we monitored for discomfort, redness, or pain, as well as the break-in period. We also evaluated breathability, versatility with different outfits, and any signs of wear and tear by the end of the testing phase.

We also tested each shoe’s arch support by bending them in half and twisting them like dish towels to gauge their flexibility, sturdiness, or lack thereof. 

Finally, we examined the fit, noting how securely they stayed on our feet and whether there was any pinching or rubbing.

Expert Tips for Shopping Comfortable Flats

Arch Support

“Arch support is crucial in any shoe, even flats,” Dr. Sharma explains. “Since everyone’s arch profile varies, choosing a flat that matches your arch type—whether high, neutral, or low—is vital. Poor arch support can result in foot fatigue, plantar fasciitis, and other issues.”

Ensure the flats you select provide adequate support underneath, avoiding options that feel overly thin or lacking in structure. For excellent arch support, we suggest the Vionic Caroll Ballet Flat, which features a removable microfiber-wrapped EVA footbed.

Material

Dr. Abdoo and Rosson both advocate for leather or suede flats, as they combine comfort with style. These materials soften over time, improve breathability, prevent moisture and odors, and mold to the shape of your feet with wear.

Even with leather or suede flats, a break-in period may still be necessary, as seen in many of our tested shoes. Flexible materials, like the knit fabric in the Rothy's Square Mary Jane and the Frank Mully Ballet Flat, can help reduce this adjustment time.

The sole material is equally important. “Dense options like wooden soles don’t absorb shock well and can strain the musculoskeletal system,” Dr. Abdoo explains. “Rubber and cork are better choices for soles.”

Fit

Dr. Sharma offers these guidelines to ensure a proper fit:

• The shoe should feel snug but not constricting.
• Leave about a thumb’s width of space between your longest toe and the shoe’s tip.
• The heel should rest comfortably against the back without slipping.
• The widest part of your foot should match the shoe’s widest point.

Shape plays a crucial role in finding the right fit, as "narrow, pointed tips can force toes into unnatural positions, worsening conditions like bunions and hammertoes," Dr. Sharma notes. "Rounded or squared toe boxes offer a similar stylish look without causing discomfort or pressure."

However, pointed-toe flats like the Vivaia Aria 5° Ballet Flats can still be comfortable due to their knit design, which provides flexibility. Another great option is the Naturalizer Samantha D’Orsay Flat, which features stretchy sides for enhanced movement.

Additional Comfortable Flats to Explore

Aerosoles Big Bet Ballet Flat: These shoes stood out for their well-cushioned insoles and plush material, ensuring a comfortable fit without rubbing or pinching. However, we noted a lack of arch support and stiffness around the heel, which caused minor redness initially.

Allbirds Tree Breezers: These flats required no break-in period, offering instant comfort with their cushioned insoles and smooth lining. However, they fell short in breathability, making them less ideal for summer wear despite their name.

Musshoe Pointed Toe Flat: We were impressed by the soft material and stylish, colorful designs of these flats. While they featured good cushioning and heel padding, they lacked arch support, and signs of wear appeared after just a few uses, raising concerns about durability.

Common Questions Answered

Is it okay to wear flats all day?

“Flats aren’t designed for extended, all-day wear,” Dr. Abdoo explains. “They lack the necessary support and cushioning for prolonged use, which can lead to potential foot problems.”

To address this, he suggests wearing flats only for short periods and switching to more supportive shoes when you anticipate being on your feet for longer durations.

How can you enhance the comfort of flats?

“If the flat lacks built-in arch support, using an over-the-counter or custom orthotic insert can help prevent foot problems,” Dr. Sharma advises.

Breaking in flats before extended use and adding supportive insoles can significantly improve comfort, making a noticeable difference in wearability.

When should you replace a pair of flats?

Valiente notes that many assume fading or scratches mean it’s time for new flats, but often, a visit to a shoe repair shop can restore them. 

“A cobbler can refresh the color, replace the sole, and even add new cushioning,” she explains. “I frequently recommend replacing the original sole with a Vibram sole for added comfort and slip resistance, as Vibram is known for its non-slip quality.” 

If the insole has lost its cushioning, the shoe has stretched to the point of being loose, or you feel discomfort or pain while wearing them, it might be time to retire your flats.

“No matter how much you adore them, once they show significant wear, replacing them is essential for maintaining foot health,” Dr. Sharma emphasizes.

Trust Our Expertise

This article was crafted by Camryn Dilger, an associate editor at Mytour with extensive experience in researching, testing, and reviewing products. We rigorously tested top flats in real-world scenarios, evaluating comfort, value, fit, support, and quality. Expert insights were provided by Dr. Shital Sharma, DPM, a board-certified podiatrist at Pinewood Family Care Co., Dr. David Abdoo, DPM, of Salinas Valley Foot & Ankle, and stylists Vanessa Valiente and Jennifer Rosson.