Top 8 Madame Alexander Dolls with Exceptional Collector Value

Long before Barbie became a household name, Madame Alexander dolls were making history. Established in 1923 by Beatrice Alexander, the Madame Alexander Doll Company pioneered the creation of officially licensed toys inspired by iconic characters like Heidi, Jo March, and Peter Pan. The brand also introduced innovative features, such as dolls with eyes that could open and close.

Over a century later, Madame Alexander dolls remain a favorite among collectors. Those in excellent or mint condition can fetch thousands of dollars on auction platforms. Here, we’ve compiled a list of the most valuable Madame Alexander dolls across various styles.

The most expensive Madame Alexander dolls ever sold are valued at tens of thousands of dollars and have been showcased in prestigious institutions like the Smithsonian and the Victoria and Albert Museum. While such museum-quality pieces are rare, you might discover a hidden treasure in your attic, basement, or garage—a vintage Madame Alexander doll passed down through generations. Its value could range from a few dollars to hundreds or even thousands, depending on its condition.

Discover some of the most sought-after Madame Alexander dolls recently sold on eBay by scrolling below.

Madame Alexander Cissy Welcomes Summer (1955) // Sold for $5433

This exclusive Madame Alexander Cissy Welcomes Summer doll, produced in 1955, is one of only 350 ever created, specifically number 38. It achieved a sale price of $5433 on eBay, thanks to its near-mint condition.

The doll features a delicate sheer black organza dress adorned with embroidered and appliquéd red and yellow flowers. Beneath the dress, there’s a fitted bodice and a yellow taffeta slip, complemented by matching hosiery and undergarments. The ensemble is accessorized with black sandals, a vintage faux-diamond ring, and a hat box containing sheer black gloves. The seller, krs1998, updated Cissy’s wide-brimmed black hat but included the original flowers, carefully removed, as part of the sale.

Madame Alexander Cissy in a Blue and Pink Clover Sundress (1958) // Sold for $5352

This Madame Alexander Cissy doll, dating back to 1958, is dressed in a rare blue and pink clover sundress featuring a rhinestone bodice. The outfit includes an ivory can-can petticoat, matching hosiery, and undergarments. Additionally, the doll comes with a pink faux pearl jewelry set, a floral garden party hat, and a silver faux diamond ring.

This Madame Alexander Cissy doll fetched $5352 on eBay.

Madame Alexander Quiz-Kin Peter Pan (1953) // Sold for $5779

Produced in 1953, coinciding with Disney’s release of Peter Pan, this 8-inch plastic Madame Alexander Peter Pan doll features a green wool cap with a vibrant red feather and brown knit leggings. The doll’s eyes can open and close, and a button on its torso allows its head to nod yes and no.

The doll’s former owner purchased it at the Madame Alexander Doll Club Convention in 1988, where it earned a first-place medal for its excellent condition. Recently, it sold for $5779 on eBay due to its pristine state and original, never-removed clothing.

Madame Alexander Cissy in a Wreath Print Dress (1957) // Sold for $5100

The Madame Alexander Cissy Wreath Print doll, crafted in 1957, sold for $5100 on eBay in nearly flawless condition. The doll wears a yellow sundress adorned with a wreath-and-dandelion print, featuring a square neckline, puffed sleeves, and a ribbon sash. It also comes with a variety of accessories, such as lilac strappy sandals, a vintage faux pearl necklace and bracelet, a lavender rhinestone ring, a lucite handbag, and a floral hat to complete the ensemble.

Madame Alexander Cissy in an Organdy Sundress (1958) // Sold for $4925

A Madame Alexander Cissy doll wouldn’t be complete without a floral sundress. This Cissy doll from 1958 wears a delicate organdy sundress with a light blue floral pattern, paired with a matching hat and shoes. This well-maintained collector’s piece sold for $4925 on eBay.

Madame Alexander Infant of Prague (1957) // Sold for $2076

Introduced in 1957 as part of Madame Alexander’s Biblical Series, the Infant of Prague doll, holding an orb and cross, is a rare find, particularly in near-mint condition. One doll, dressed in garments hand-stitched by the Sisters of Mercy of Omaha, Nebraska, sold for $2076 on eBay. While this is notable, it’s not the highest price paid for this Christ-inspired doll. In 2022, the antique doll auction house Theriault’s sold one for $3200.

Madame Alexander Cissy Doll With Blue Eyes (1959) // Sold for $4618

This 19-inch-tall Madame Alexander Cissy Doll from 1959, featuring striking blue eyes, sold for $4618 on eBay. The doll’s original attire includes a pink-and-white striped cotton top paired with matching shorts. The ensemble is accessorized with rhinestone drop earrings, leopard-print shoes, and a navy straw hat adorned with a tiny fruit basket.

Madame Alexander Cissy Redhead (1959) // Sold for $2325

Despite missing its original outfit, this Madame Alexander Cissy Redhead fetched $2325 on eBay due to its excellent condition and a meticulously crafted reproduction outfit. The 1959 doll also included its original pink and gold hatbox, along with a new matte seal to safeguard it from damage.