Buzz
My Little Pony is a timeless franchise that captivates audiences of all ages. Whether you grew up with it in the 1980s or are enjoying it now through modern films or TV shows with your kids, its charm remains undeniable.
The story began in 1981 with Bonnie Zacherle, who dreamed of owning a pony as a child. Starting her career in greeting cards, she later freelanced for Hasbro before joining them full-time in the early 1980s. Inspired by her childhood, she developed toy concepts that resonated with her own youthful imagination, as she shared in a 2016 interview.
Zacherle’s passion for ponies led to the creation of My Pretty Pony, which evolved into My Little Pony. Despite initial hesitation from Hasbro, the iconic toy line launched in 1982, becoming a beloved brand and a global success.
Although the original My Little Pony toys cherished by Xennials may not fetch millions, they still hold significant value today. Depending on their condition and rarity, First Generation (G1) My Little Pony toys can sell for several hundred dollars or more. Here are some of the most prized collectibles from the 1980s and early 1990s that you can list on eBay.
Contents
Mimic Twinkle-Eyed My Little Pony, G1 Year 5 (1987) // Valued up to $2000
Mimic's vibrant lime-green hue could be a key factor in her high value today. | Courtesy of heyirememberthat, eBayMimic, a standout among the Twinkle-Eyed G1 ponies, holds a special place in collectors' hearts due to her limited production and distinctive design. She made a brief appearance in the season two episode “Golden Horseshoes,” speaking only three lines, yet leaving a lasting impression. Her jeweled eyes and parrot-themed cutie mark, a unique symbol on her hindquarters, added to her charm.
Some fans believe Hasbro produced Mimic in limited quantities because her lime-green color was considered unconventional for girls' toys. A sealed Mimic recently sold for nearly $2000 on eBay, while used versions can still fetch between $250 and $300.
Rapunzel My Little Pony, G1 Year 9 (1990) // Valued up to $1500
Rapunzel, Rapunzel, let down your mane. | Courtesy of linlac6, eBay
Picture calling for Rapunzel to let down her hair, only to receive a pony’s flowing mane instead—it’s a dream come true. During the 1990s mail-order era, the Rapunzel My Little Pony emerged as one of Hasbro’s rarest and most sought-after toys.
Featuring a long strawberry blonde mane and a princess-themed cutie mark on her hindquarters, this pony quickly became a collector’s favorite. Her “Love Melody” pose, with one foot bent as if mid-trot, adds to her charm. Owning one today could net you between $1000 and $1500.
My Little Pony Mommy and Baby Pony, G1 Year 9 (1990) // Valued up to $776
Their adorable design has stood the test of time. | Courtesy of linlac6, eBayThe Mommy and Baby Pony set is another highly prized G1 My Little Pony collectible. This combo includes a baby bottle and playpen, allowing the mommy pony some downtime. The Mommy features a charming cutie mark of a cartoon kitten and her foal, while the Baby sports a diaper-like design.
A complete set with all accessories can fetch up to $776 on eBay. Even without the extras, pre-owned versions of this G1 duo can sell for around $280.
My Little Pony Paradise Estate, G1 Year 4 (1985) // Valued up to $700
Every pony deserves a home, and the Paradise Estate provided just that. This playset, though pony-less, came packed with toy furniture, an outdoor patio featuring a fillable pool, and a cozy bedroom. The original packaging even included a story about Shady the Pony losing her magic sunglasses at a party and needing help to find them.
If you own one, a brand-new, boxed version can sell for up to $700 on eBay. Used sets in good condition can bring in around $450, with individual accessories potentially worth up to $50.
My Little Pony Dream Castle Play Set, G1 Year 2 and Year 7 (1983, 1989) // Valued up to $450
The Dream Castle wasn’t the only playset available during the G1 era. It gained popularity after appearing in the 1984 animated special Rescue at Midnight Castle, making it a fan favorite.
The 1983 version, known as the pink castle, included Majesty and her dragon companion, Spike, along with various accessories. The 1989 Lavender Dream Castle, part of the Year 7 line, is rarer and recently sold for $450 on eBay. Even the box alone can fetch around $90, while the original pink version is valued at up to $200.
My Little Pony Waterfall Set With Sprinkles, G1 Year 2 (1983) // Valued up to $400
Imagine lounging inside a fluffy toy cloud. | Courtesy of ilove80stoys, eBayWho wouldn’t enjoy a relaxing waterfall retreat? This Year 2 playset, complete with a cloud, rainbow, and sun, offers ponies a perfect spot to bathe. It included Sprinkles, a pegasus with a rubber duck companion, along with a sponge brush, comb, curlers, a towel, and bubble bath. The set also featured a working pool and shower for added fun.
A complete set in good condition can sell for around $200 or more. If you own the rare mail-order Sprinkles pony, you could earn up to $400.
My Little Pony Sweet Scoops Pony, G1 Year 8 (1990) // Valued up to $350
Her mane gives her a sweet yet sassy vibe. | Courtesy of wegot80stoyscheap, eBayNot all mail-order ponies are highly valuable, but Sweet Scoops stands out. Released in the early 1990s, she came with a matching charm necklace for fans to flaunt. True to her name, her cutie mark features an ice cream scoop, reflecting her love for frozen treats.
A well-preserved Sweet Scoops pony alone can sell for up to $350 on eBay, while the charm necklace is worth around $100. Owning both makes it a rare find, potentially fetching a significant sum for collectors.
My Pretty Pony (1981) // Valued up to $300
Collectors tend to value the pink version more than the brown one. | Courtesy of Retro TV Toys and Collectibles, eBayBefore My Little Pony became iconic, it began as My Pretty Pony. Initially, it didn’t achieve the success Hasbro and Zacherle hoped for, leading to the introduction of uniquely colored ponies with distinct identities to attract a wider audience. Despite this, the original 10-inch My Pretty Pony, larger than its 5-inch successors, remains a treasured collectible.
While you might assume the original is the most valuable, it surprisingly isn’t. A pink Romper Room pony in its original box recently sold for around $300 on eBay, while brown versions typically fetch about $100.
My Little Pony Soft Sleepy Newborns, G1 Year 5 (1987) // Valued up to $200
Hushabye, pictured here, was among the three Soft Sleepy Newborns launched in Year 5. | Courtesy of Seven by Twelve, eBayNewborns are undeniably adorable (spiders aside), and the G1 My Little Pony newborns are no exception. Standing at 9 inches tall, they matched the size of My Pretty Pony but were much larger than standard My Little Pony toys. Their eyes opened and closed when tilted or when their tails were pulled, and they were crafted from soft fabric. Each even came with a tiny pacifier (how cute!).
Three versions were introduced in Year 5: Pink Dreams, Hushabye, and Sweet Dreams. All three hold similar resale value, typically ranging from $100 to $200 on eBay if you decide to sell.
