Top Black Leggings That Surpassed Our Expectations

Ideal for Fitness Enthusiasts

For those with an active routine, the Athleta Interval Leggings are a versatile choice, whether you're exploring trails or working out at the gym. We appreciated their exceptional comfort, courtesy of the PowerMove fabric that delivers compression without restricting movement. The adjustable drawstring ensures a customized fit, eliminating issues like pinching or bunching. Their 7/8 length offers a timeless, flattering look, ending just above the ankle. 

During our evaluation, we subjected these leggings to a comprehensive bend test and discovered they remained completely opaque—even when paired with brightly colored undergarments. They also demonstrated excellent durability after numerous wears and multiple wash and dry cycles. However, it's worth mentioning that the fabric is on the thicker side. 

While this thickness ensures warmth during workouts in air-conditioned gyms or cold outdoor conditions, it may not be the best option for exercising in hot weather. Aside from this, we believe these comfortable leggings are well worth the investment.

Material: 77% recycled polyester and 23% elastane | Care Instructions: Machine washable and dryable | Size Range: XXS-XL (also available in tall and petite sizes)

Top Choice for Compression

If you're seeking excellent support and warmth, the Movement tights by On are a fantastic choice. The fabric is robust, opaque, and long-lasting, offering compression while adapting to your movements. During our tests, the tights maintained their shape without sagging or bunching, eliminating the need for adjustments. They also feature two pockets—one on the outer leg and another discreetly placed in the waistband.

These leggings not only provide exceptional workout support but are also ideal for cold weather, thanks to their breathable yet insulating design. However, being tights, they fit more tightly than standard leggings. Putting them on can require some effort, as we noticed they need to be pulled up and adjusted carefully.

Depending on your body type, they may feel overly tight around the midsection, making them less comfortable for all-day wear. Additionally, their close fit can result in visible panty lines. However, the thick fabric ensures complete opacity, with no risk of sheerness. 

Material: 80% recycled polyamide and 20% elastane | Care Instructions: Machine washable and tumble dry on low | Size Range: XS-XXL

Top Choice for Sculpting

The Spanx Booty Boost leggings combine exceptional support with flattering sculpting, making them ideal for a range of activities, from casual walks to intense gym workouts. True to their name, they enhance your silhouette with a contoured waistband that provides a lifted look. 

During our testing, these leggings proved most comfortable during active movement. They maintained their shape without sagging or pinching while in motion, though they felt slightly tight when sitting. For this reason, we recommend them more for exercise than for daily wear.

Designed without a center seam, these leggings eliminate visible panty lines. The nylon and elastane blend offers durability and a smooth finish, with no risk of sheerness due to the thick fabric. If you're in need of high-quality sculpting leggings for the gym, these are a worthwhile investment. 

Material: 64% nylon and 36% elastane | Care Instructions: Machine wash cold and tumble dry on low | Size Range: XS-3X

Top Pick for Plus Size

These high-waisted leggings from Spanx are a reliable choice for anyone seeking a comfortable, high-quality wardrobe staple. We particularly appreciate their inclusive size range, available from XS to 3X, catering to plus-size individuals as well. Soft and smooth, they feel like a second skin and are versatile enough for lounging, despite being marketed as activewear. 

During testing, we wore them in various settings, from airports to workouts, and they remained comfortable throughout. While they offer compression and stretch for exercise, they never felt restrictive. They fit perfectly without bunching or sagging, and we could wear them all day without discomfort from the waistband or seams. 

We also noted their durability—after four to five washes, they retained their opacity and thickness. The only drawback was their tendency to shift during yoga, making them better suited for standing activities rather than stretching. Though slightly pricey, their quality justifies the investment.

Material: 69% polyester and 31% Lycra® elastane | Care Instructions: Machine wash warm and tumble dry on low | Size Range: XS-3X

Top Choice for Lounging

Whether you’re out running errands or relaxing at home, these chic ruched leggings from Vuori ensure all-day comfort. Crafted from premium fabric with a soft, brushed jersey texture, the material is stretchy and moves with your body without restriction. Beyond comfort, these leggings are highly durable, showing no signs of wear or sheerness even after multiple washes. 

It’s worth noting that these leggings aren’t designed for intense workouts. The thicker fabric can feel overly warm during sweaty activities, and the waistband tends to roll down during movement. While we found them flattering and cozy overall, frequent adjustments were needed during exercise, making them better suited for lounging than active wear. 

Material: 87% recycled polyester and 13% elastane | Care Instructions: Machine wash cold and tumble dry on low | Size Range: XXS-XXL

Top Pick for Pockets

In addition to being durable and opaque, these ankle-length Stride leggings from Vuori include a highly sought-after feature: pockets! They come equipped with side stash pockets and a concealed zip pocket in the waistband. Whether you’re hitting the gym or exploring trails, you’ll have convenient storage for essentials like your phone, wallet, and keys. 

Constructed from a windbreaker-like material, these leggings provided excellent compression and support during our tests. The moisture-wicking fabric kept us cool, making them perfect for high-intensity workouts. While the drawstring cord was a nice touch, we rarely needed to adjust the fit. However, the snug fit might require sizing up for those seeking comfort during lounging.

Material: 66% polyamide and 34% elastane | Care Instructions: Machine wash cold and tumble dry on low | Size Range: XXS-XXL

Our Testing Process 

To identify the top black leggings, we rigorously tested multiple pairs over a month, wearing each at least seven times. We evaluated their performance across various activities, including walks, workouts, and daily errands. Throughout the testing period, we focused on key factors like quality, opacity, fit, and overall performance. 

We observed whether the leggings pinched, rolled, or shifted during wear. Given their tendency to move, we monitored how often adjustments were needed. As leggings are essential for workouts, we also assessed their comfort and functionality during and after sweaty activities. 

Our testing process included washing each pair of leggings at least three times. After adhering to the care instructions provided by the manufacturer, we evaluated their durability, checking for issues like shrinking, fading, pilling, or distortion. We also inspected for loose threads or any signs of damage, such as holes. 

After completing the testing phase, we determined whether each pair of leggings justified its price. We considered their overall value and whether we would purchase them at full price or wait for a discount. 

Expert Tips for Shopping for Black Leggings

Material 

Black leggings are commonly crafted from blends of cotton, polyester, or nylon, often combined with elastane for added stretch. For casual wear, such as running errands or lounging, cotton blends offer breathability and comfort for extended use. However, cotton may lack sweat-wicking properties and can sometimes appear sheer. Polyester blends, on the other hand, are wrinkle-resistant, quick-drying, and generally more affordable than nylon. 

While nylon leggings tend to be more expensive, they are often considered the best for sculpting, compression, and durability. Suitable for both workouts and dressier occasions, nylon leggings offer versatility and a polished look. 

“I’m a fan of ‘scuba’ nylon leggings, which are comfortable and slightly more refined than standard cotton or jersey blends due to their added weight,” says Burnette. Typically made from synthetic fibers like nylon, scuba fabric features a double-knitted structure that ensures smoothness, stretch, and durability. 

Opacity

As a general guideline, leggings should be opaque, meaning they should not be see-through. Opaque leggings provide full coverage, ensuring your skin and undergarments remain concealed—thicker options can also offer warmth in cooler climates. They are typically heavier and more durable.

When shopping in-store, Burnette suggests stretching the leggings over your hand to check if your skin shows through. “For durability and opacity, consider faux leather or lined leggings,” Burnette advises. “Athletic styles are often heavier, as they are designed for performance.”

Fit

Beyond standard sizing, pay attention to additional measurements and details when selecting black leggings. Checking the inseam length—the distance from the crotch to the ankle—can help you avoid leggings that are either too long or too short. Also, decide whether you prefer high-waisted or mid-rise styles. 

The best way to determine if leggings fit is to try them on. If shopping online and unsure about sizing, Burnette recommends purchasing two sizes to find the best fit. She also emphasizes that leggings should feel snug but allow you to breathe comfortably, as they may stretch over time with repeated wear and washing.

Activity 

Not all leggings are created equal—some are designed for workouts, while others are ideal for lounging. For exercise, Burnette recommends selecting leggings made from sweat-wicking, breathable fabrics with pockets for essentials like your phone and keys. For casual, everyday wear, she suggests considering features such as built-in shapewear and stylish accents like zippers and pockets. 

Additional Black Leggings to Explore 

Quince Mongolian Cashmere Sweatpants: Crafted from 100% Grade-A Mongolian cashmere, these sweatpants by Quince are incredibly soft and comfortable. While not intended for workouts, they are ideal for casual wear in chilly weather. If you’re seeking warmth and comfort, these black leggings are an excellent option. 

Common Questions

What legging length is the most flattering?

According to Burnette, the most flattering legging length depends on your height and personal preference. Here are the most common legging lengths:

• Pedal pusher: Ends below the knee
• Capri: Ends at mid-calf 
• Midi (also called 7/8): Ends between the calf and ankle 
• Long: Ends at or below the ankle 

When shopping for leggings, consider your height and leg length. For instance, if you’re on the shorter side, full-length leggings might be too long unless you find petite sizes. Burnette prefers ankle-length leggings, which she pairs with “stylish sneakers or boots.”

Can black leggings be worn as pants?

While there’s no rule against wearing black leggings as pants, it’s important to consider the occasion and how you style them. “For a business casual setting, try pairing them with a blazer. In casual settings, an oversized shirt works well,” Burnette suggests. “Always check the opacity first and use your best judgment!”

What should you wear under black leggings?

Unless you’re in a cold climate, Burnette recommends wearing black underwear under your black leggings. To avoid visible lines, she suggests choosing a seamless thong or cheeky bikini. 

How should you clean black leggings?

Before cleaning your black leggings, always refer to the care label instructions. Typically, you can machine wash them in cold water and tumble dry on low heat. However, some brands recommend air drying to prevent damage to the elastic fibers. 

Even if the care label permits machine drying, air drying is a safer option to maintain the leggings' quality. This method also helps preserve any special details, such as leather accents. “I prefer washing black leggings inside out on cold and air drying them, especially if they have unique embellishments,” Burnette advises. 

Trust Our Expertise

This article was authored by Stacey Nguyen, a fashion shopping writer at Mytour with extensive experience in lifestyle and apparel content. To curate this list, we rigorously tested multiple pairs of black leggings, evaluating them on quality, opacity, fit, performance, and value. Stacey also sought advice from LA-based stylist Emily Burnette on selecting and styling black leggings.