Buzz
Laundry detergents have been a staple in most homes since the 1940s, playing a crucial role in cleaning fabrics.
©iStockphoto.com/ sb-borgMain Insights
- Laundry detergents are effective at cleaning fabrics, thanks to surfactants, which help remove dirt and stains by interacting with both oil and water.
- Contemporary detergents combine surfactants, enzymes, and other ingredients to address a variety of stains and fabric care concerns.
- Choosing between powder and liquid detergents often depends on personal preference, though environmental impact and packaging waste have become increasingly important factors for shoppers.
There’s nothing quite like the sensation of slipping into a freshly laundered T-shirt after a shower, leaving you feeling refreshed and ready for the day ahead. But where does this clean clothing come from? Oh yes—laundry, that never-ending household chore. And the statistics back it up: The average American family tackles roughly 300 loads of laundry annually [source: Wall Street Journal].
You might find yourself frequently throwing clothes and linens into the wash, and here's why: simply put, people are messy. We sweat, shed skin cells, and come into contact with food, dirt, and countless other particles each day. As a result, we need an effective way to clean our clothes and fabrics, not only for personal hygiene but also to keep our garments looking fresh. But what exactly happens inside the washing machine to make our clothes clean? The answer lies in laundry detergent.
Before laundry detergents were invented, Americans used soap flakes to clean their clothes. But in the 1930s, Procter & Gamble introduced the first true laundry detergent, Dreft. Then, in 1943, they launched Tide, which was more powerful at removing tough stains thanks to some groundbreaking chemical ingredients. Since then, laundry detergents have become essential in households worldwide. So, how do these detergents work their magic? In this article, we’ll dive deep into the process of what happens when detergents enter your washing machine.
Next: the key ingredients in laundry detergent.
Surfactants: The Power Behind Laundry Detergent’s Cleaning Ability
While every ingredient in laundry detergent serves a purpose, the most vital ones for cleaning clothes are surfactants. Surfactants get their name from the words "surface-active agents." These agents have a special chemical structure that allows them to interact with two different types of surfaces, such as water and oil. The tail of a surfactant molecule is hydrophobic, meaning it doesn’t like water but is drawn to grease and dirt. The head of the molecule is hydrophilic, meaning it’s attracted to water [source: Silberberg].
When a greasy garment is submerged in water with detergent containing surfactants, the hydrophobic tail of the surfactant molecules binds to the grease, while the hydrophilic head is attracted to the water. As the washing machine agitates, these molecules form tiny clusters, remaining suspended in the water and being rinsed away when the water drains. This process ensures that the grime is removed from the fabric and prevented from reattaching, making surfactants crucial in keeping clothes clean.
There are essentially four primary types of surfactants, with the first three being the most common in laundry detergents. Their actions depend on how they interact with ions, which are charged particles created by the loss or gain of electrons. Ions can be positive, like calcium (Ca2+), or negative, like chloride (Cl-).
- Anionic surfactants carry a negative charge in solution, but they don't perform as well in hard water, which contains positively charged ions like calcium (Ca2+) and magnesium (Mg2+). The negative charge of anionic surfactants attracts these positive ions, preventing them from binding to other molecules.
- Nonionic surfactants lack a charge, which allows them to function better in hard water conditions since they aren’t drawn to positive ions.
- Cationic surfactants have a positive charge and assist anionic surfactants by helping them adhere to dirt at the water-dirt interface, thus enabling more dirt removal.
- Amphoteric or zwitterionic surfactants have both positive and negative charges. These are gentle surfactants commonly found in products like hand soaps, shampoos, and cosmetics. [source: Silberberg].
Keep reading to discover more ingredients that enhance the effectiveness of detergents.
Researchers at Wright State University studied how effectively mites and mite allergens were removed from clothes washed with just water versus with detergents. Surprisingly, they found both methods to be equally effective in eliminating mite allergens. The study suggests that washing with just water works as well as using detergent because both allergens and mites are water-soluble, and contact with water is sufficient to remove them [source: Arlian].
Other Ingredients in Laundry Detergent
While surfactants are central to how laundry detergents clean fabrics, other ingredients can enhance the detergent’s performance, brighten clothes, or improve fragrance. As mentioned earlier, certain surfactants don’t perform as well in hard water because of the excess positive ions. To address this, detergents often contain builders, which help the detergent work more effectively in hard water. Builders achieve this by binding to calcium (Ca2+) and magnesium (Mg2+) ions in the water, freeing up surfactants, especially anionic ones, to focus on grime instead. Builders also act as bases, neutralizing acids and disrupting chemical bonds. By including builders, manufacturers can reduce the amount of surfactant needed, making detergents more efficient. Common examples of builders are sodium tripolyphosphate (STTP) and zeolites [source: EPA].
Some laundry detergents include ingredients that help make clothes appear brighter or whiter. Bleaches are commonly used whitening agents, as they contain peroxides that oxidize fabrics [source: EPA]. Some detergents also contain fluorescent whiteners and brighteners that help prevent yellowing. These additives work by absorbing ultraviolet light and emitting visible blue light, which helps mask yellowing, making colors look more vibrant and whites appear cleaner.
Enzymes, which are naturally occurring biological agents, are added to many detergents in varying concentrations. These enzymes work similarly to those used by your body to digest food, and they are typically categorized as follows:
- Proteases: break down proteins
- Lipases: break down fats
- Amylases: break down starches [source: Basketter]
These enzymes aid in breaking down food residues that remain on clothing by speeding up the natural decomposition process. It's important to note that enzymes are biological agents, meaning they can degrade over time. To ensure their effectiveness, detergents often include enzyme stabilizers that help preserve these enzymes and ensure they continue to function properly.
Laundry detergents also often include fragrance and coloring agents, which give them their characteristic scents and visual appeal. While the amount of dye used is typically too small to affect the color of your clothes, these dyes serve a dual purpose: they enhance the detergent's appearance and help you see if any detergent remains on your clothing after the wash cycle.
Fillers are another essential component in detergents, as they help to dilute and distribute the active ingredients in the proper proportions. Different types of detergents use different fillers. In powder detergents, sodium sulfate is the primary filler, giving the detergent its granular texture. In liquid detergents, water is the primary filler.
On the following page, we will delve into further comparisons between powder and liquid detergents, highlighting their similarities and differences.
Both soaps and detergents serve as cleaning agents. Before detergents were introduced, people used lye-based soaps to wash clothes. However, soap-based laundry solutions could cause fabrics to lose their brightness, with whites becoming dull and colored fabrics fading. Soap also left behind soap scum rings in washing machines. Although soap is a surfactant, it lacks many of the additional ingredients found in detergents, such as builders, enzymes, whiteners, and brighteners, which make detergents far more effective at cleaning clothes.
Powder vs. Liquid Detergents
Over the past 60 years, laundry detergent has evolved significantly since the introduction of the first box of Tide. Today, the two primary forms of detergent are powders and liquids. Although both types contain similar active ingredients, the difference lies in the fillers used. Each type has its benefits and drawbacks, and because both offer comparable cleaning results, the choice often comes down to personal preference.
Here are some of the benefits and drawbacks of using powdered detergents:
- Pro: Typically more affordable.
- Pro: The cardboard packaging is a more eco-friendly choice.
- Con: Some users feel that powders don't dissolve as easily in water. While this was an issue with early formulas, modern powders are designed to dissolve more effectively.
- Con: Sodium sulfate can cause problems with septic systems.
- Con: Powders generally contain more chemicals due to the filler used.
The reasons people choose liquid detergents may differ from those for powders, and here are some of the key factors:
- Pro: The detergent is pre-dissolved, so it's ready to use immediately.
- Pro: It's easy to treat stains directly by applying it to the fabric.
- Con: Liquid detergents tend to be pricier than powdered versions.
- Con: They typically come in plastic containers, which aren't as eco-friendly.
Even though detergents are formulated with potent chemicals, there's an ongoing debate about whether these chemicals accelerate the deterioration of fabrics. As we've discussed earlier, the primary role of detergent is to lift dirt and grime from clothing, which is then washed away with water. The real cause of fabric wear is more likely the friction and tumbling that occurs in the washing machine, not the detergents themselves.
Environmental Considerations with Laundry Detergent
While detergents do an excellent job of eliminating dirt and grime from our clothes, one must consider the environmental cost. Given the toxicity of certain chemicals used in these products and the carbon emissions associated with their production, it’s understandable why many people are concerned about the environmental effects of laundry detergents.
The carbon footprint of laundry detergents is significant by many standards. Carbon footprints represent the amount of carbon dioxide (CO2) generated during the making, shipping, and usage of a product. According to the Wall Street Journal, the carbon footprint of using the UK detergent brand Tesco can range from 1.3 pounds (0.6 kg) to 1.9 pounds (0.9 kg) per load, depending on the detergent form used. To put that into perspective, an average car emits 1 pound (0.5 kg) of CO2 for each mile it travels. With American families doing an average of 300 loads of laundry per year, this means the carbon footprint of laundry detergents for one year is roughly 480 pounds (218 kg) of CO2, or 10 pounds (4.5 kg) per week. While this may not seem like much, especially compared to the 5 tons of CO2 an average car produces annually, it’s important to remember that this calculation only reflects the laundry detergent’s impact, not the extra energy used by washing machines and dryers [source: Wall Street Journal].
Additionally, the harmful effects of the chemical substances in detergents must be taken into account. According to the EPA, some of the key concerns regarding the chemicals used in laundry detergents are as follows:
- Harmful to aquatic life and algae
- Long-lasting in the environment
- Contributing to the eutrophication of freshwater, especially with phosphate-based detergents (phosphates have now largely been replaced by zeolites, which may be mitigating this issue)
- Potential health risks to humans, including cancer [source: EPA]
Another problem with laundry detergents is their potential to make wash water more acidic. Depending on where the water ends up, it could have environmental consequences, with effects similar to acid rain. Keep reading the next page for some eco-friendly alternatives to traditional detergents.
Switching to more environmentally-friendly laundry detergents may ease your conscience, but it could also lead to changes in body odor. Medical reports have documented cases of patients experiencing strong body odor after changing their detergent. This happens because the new detergent interacts with the body's sweat, altering the natural chemistry of the skin [source: Sargent].
Green Laundry Detergent Options
In light of the environmental concerns surrounding laundry detergents, there are now more eco-friendly alternatives on the market. Many of these detergents are free from dyes and fragrances, and are typically biodegradable, phosphate-free, and cruelty-free, having not been tested on animals.
One environmentally conscious choice is detergent formulated for use in cold water. Studies show that around 80 to 85 percent of the energy used in washing a load of laundry is consumed by heating the water [source: Sabaliunas et al.]. Using cold water not only conserves energy but can also help lower your household energy bills.
Another sustainable option is concentrated detergent formulas, which reduce both packaging waste and the water required to produce the detergent. According to Carol Berning, a spokeswoman for Proctor & Gamble, concentrated detergents result in "less plastic for bottles, less corrugated cardboard for crating, and less gasoline used, because fewer trucks are needed to transport the shipments" [source: Consumer Reports]. Though these concentrated and cold-water options are steps toward greener washing habits, they still contain some chemicals that may pose environmental risks.
For an even greener solution, consider making your own laundry detergent. There are numerous recipes available, typically involving ingredients such as water, bar soap, borax, and washing soda. Homemade detergents are often simpler, using fewer chemicals and reducing packaging waste. However, it's important to note that clothes washed with homemade detergent might require bleaching, and these detergents may not be as effective at removing stains compared to commercial options.
Clearly, laundry detergents are intricate chemical products that are constantly evolving, whether it's enhancing their stain-fighting capabilities or making them more eco-friendly. For further information on laundry detergents and related topics, explore the links below.
