Buzz
During the early 1990s, the internet remained an enigma to the majority, often dismissed as a fleeting trend. This was an era when Bryant Gumbel and Katie Couric famously puzzled over the "@" symbol on national TV. So, how could AOL persuade a computer-less America to embrace the intimidating expanse of the world wide web? Their solution was simple: offer it for free.
To usher the world into the digital age, AOL adopted a surprisingly old-school approach. Instead of splurging on flashy TV ads or marketing blitzes like competitors such as Prodigy, AOL opted for a more personal touch—direct mail. This strategy was conceived by Jan Brandt, AOL's chief marketing officer, who joined the company to boost subscriptions. In 1993, she proposed a straightforward plan: distribute free trial discs—first floppy disks, then CDs—via mail. The goal was to convert trial users into paying customers once the trial period ended.
At the time, the concept of the internet was so foreign that traditional advertising methods like commercials, billboards, or print ads failed to convey its potential. AOL's solution was to let users experience it themselves through free trials ranging from 500 to 1000 hours. In an episode of the Internet History Podcast, Brandt emphasized the significance of the physical package in making the campaign a success.
"I was absolutely convinced that sending someone a physical package in the mail—not just an envelope, but something tangible—would compel them to open it. I believed it was human nature to be curious enough to unwrap a small box delivered to their doorstep."
The initial campaign, launched in a smaller market during the spring and summer of 1993, required $250,000 to get started. While typical direct mail efforts struggle to achieve a 2-3% response rate, Brandt's strategy achieved an impressive 10%. Users didn’t just try the free trials—they enthusiastically signed up for AOL’s services, converting into paying subscribers in large numbers. As the campaign grew, the discs began appearing beyond mailboxes.
The strategy took off when AOL partnered with Blockbuster to distribute their discs to customers. Soon, the discs were everywhere—stacked at Best Buy and Barnes & Noble, slipped into magazines, packed inside cereal boxes, and even placed on fast food trays. Wherever people looked, an AOL disc was likely nearby. One of the more unusual tactics involved freezing and thawing the discs without damaging them, allowing AOL to bundle them with Omaha Steaks shipments.
While some of the disc distribution methods were amusing, the sheer scale of the campaign is staggering. At its peak, it’s estimated that 50 percent of all CDs produced bore the AOL logo. This was during a time when CDs were still a popular medium for music and software. Many people received multiple discs weekly, often repurposing them as coasters, frisbees, or simply tossing them out. Yet, the strategy worked in AOL’s favor due to the sheer volume of discs distributed.
Despite spending hundreds of millions—possibly even billions, as Brandt suggested—on CDs (each costing around $1.50), and countless discs ending up as drink coasters, AOL’s growth was undeniable. Its subscriber base exploded, and the brand became synonymous with the internet. Estimates suggest AOL spent approximately $35 to acquire each new customer through these discs. At their peak, they were signing up a new user every six seconds, transforming AOL into a $150 billion company within a few years.
"At the time of our IPO in 1992, we had fewer than 200,000 subscribers," recalled former AOL CEO Steve Case. "By the early 2000s, that number had skyrocketed to around 25 million."
fortfan/Flickr
Ironically, the decline of AOL's trial discs was driven by the very internet they helped popularize. As AOL shifted its strategy, moving away from hourly charges and embracing broadband, the discs lost their relevance amid rising churn rates. Competitors offering faster and more advanced services began to outpace AOL. By 2006, the disc campaign was discontinued as user behavior evolved—though an estimated 2.1 million users still cling to AOL's nearly obsolete dial-up service.
In a surprising twist, these once-ubiquitous discs have now become collector's items, with enthusiasts amassing thousands of them for various purposes. Museums have even exhibited them, acknowledging their role in introducing millions to the internet and shaping the early days of digital connectivity.
Today, AOL's trial discs stand alongside JNCO jeans, boy bands, and Beanie Babies as quirky symbols of the 1990s. While they hold no monetary value now, their contribution to the internet revolution over the past 25 years remains undeniable.
