Buzz
Even if you swear by your family’s homemade treats, there’s something about brand-name cookies that hit differently. Classics like OREOS and Chips Ahoy! have stood the test of time, while others were short-lived but still hold a place in many hearts. Here are the discontinued cookies that continue to spark cravings even after they’re gone.
1. Savannah Smiles
Not to be mistaken for the 1982 film, Savannah Smiles gained a loyal fanbase when the Girl Scouts introduced them in 2012. These half-moon cookies were known for their dusting of powdered sugar and bright lemon flavor. Despite having a longer shelf life than most new Girl Scout cookies, they were eventually phased out in 2019.
2. SnackWell’s Devil’s Food Cookie Cakes
Glane23, Wikimedia Commons // CC BY-SA 3.0Few snacks scream the 1990s low-fat craze quite like SnackWell’s. The brand’s fat-free Devil’s Food Cookie Cakes were sold as a healthier choice compared to regular snacks, even though they were packed with high-fructose corn syrup and carbs. As the low-fat obsession faded and the Atkins low-carb diet took over in the 2000s, SnackWell’s lost its charm. The SnackWell’s brand was officially discontinued in 2022, but despite the rise of other so-called healthy treats, many still long for the nostalgic fudge-and-marshmallow-covered
3. OREO Magic Dunkers
OREO has introduced many limited-edition flavors over the years, but none created quite the buzz like Magic Dunkers. This special edition from 2000 turned milk into a swirl of blue when the cookies were dipped. Though the striking visual effect—taking a year to perfect—didn’t alter the flavor of either the cookie or the milk, it certainly made a lasting impression.
4. Keebler Magic Middles
Keebler Magic Middles—delicious shortbread cookies filled with either fudge or peanut butter—quickly became a fan favorite when they launched in the 1980s. Since their discontinuation, fans have been clamoring for their return, and while Keebler has hinted at reviving them, no official plans have been announced yet.
5. Matcha Joe-Joe's
Matcha Joe-Joe’s are one of the many discontinued products that Trader Joe’s shoppers still miss. These sandwich cookies, featuring golden biscuits and a matcha-flavored cream, were available from 2017 to 2019 before being discontinued.
6. Giggles
Fans of nostalgic treats may recall this snack from the 1980s. Nabisco’s Giggles were sandwich cookies, each with holes shaped like a smiling face. Inside, the chocolate and vanilla cream filling sometimes made the eyes look like they had pupils and the mouth like it had teeth. While the effect may have been more eerie than charming, the discontinued brand still has its loyal followers.
7. Chips Ahoy! With Sour Patch Kids
Chips Ahoy! cookies paired with Sour Patch Kids were never intended to be a permanent addition to Nabisco’s range. This sweet and sour blend received mixed reviews when it made its debut as a limited-edition item in 2020. Those who prefer traditional chocolate chips over tangy gummy candies didn’t particularly miss this one.
8. Burry’s Fudgetown Cookies
These sandwich cookies from the well-known cookie brand Burry’s were a chocolate lover’s fantasy. Featuring flower-shaped chocolate biscuits with a rich fudge filling that oozed from a hole at the top, they were a favorite in the 1960s and '70s. Sadly, these delectable treats are no longer available.
9. Dizzy Grizzlies
Popular in the 1990s, Dizzy Grizzlies were the edgy, extreme sports-enthusiast counterpart to Teddy Grahams. The cookies, shaped like bears, were coated with chocolate and sprinkled with colorful toppings, with the gimmick being that flipping them made them dizzy. These bears were portrayed skiing, skateboarding, and engaging in various other sports that were highlighted in the marketing.
10. Melody Cookies
Nabisco has introduced many iconic cookie brands, though not all have stood the test of time. Many long-time fans still mourn the loss of Melody cookies, which were discontinued in the 1970s. These simple chocolate biscuits had scalloped edges and were dusted with sugar crystals on top. Though they’ve been out of production for years, copycat recipes can still be found online.
11. Newton's Fruit Thins
Introduced in 2011, Newtons launched a baked treat that was closer to a classic cookie than their well-known fruit-filled bars. Newton's Fruit Thins were crisp cookies infused with flavors such as dried cranberries, dried blueberries, oats, and brown sugar. Despite the intriguing combination, the product struggled to match the popularity of the original Fig Newtons, and it has since disappeared from store shelves for several years.
