Top 5 Online Stores to Order Christmas Pies for the Festive Season

The holiday season has arrived, making it the perfect time to indulge in a whole tin of pie. While baking a pie can be time-consuming, the convenience of online delivery comes to the rescue. We’ve curated a list of the best online pie shops that ensure your treats arrive at your door just in time for the celebrations. These bakeries provide speedy nationwide shipping and feature both unique specialties and traditional holiday favorites—whether you crave a rich, chocolatey delight or a savory option, there’s something to satisfy every palate.

1. Milk Bar

While Milk Bar may not offer a wide selection, its exceptional flavors more than compensate. The bakery features just two pie options, with the Milk Bar pie being its standout creation. Developed by chef Christina Tosi, this iconic dessert boasts a creamy, custard-like filling crafted from milk, egg yolks, sugar, and butter, all nestled in a crumbled oatmeal cookie crust. Priced at approximately $46, the pie is available for nationwide delivery, and orders exceeding $75 qualify for free shipping.

2. Goode Co. Barbecue

Goode Co. Barbecue, a Houston-based eatery, is renowned for its exceptional pecan pies. These pies are crafted with fresh Texas pecans sourced near the Brazos River, resulting in a decadent, gooey filling that’s unmatched in flavor. Each pie, priced at $59, is shipped in a beautifully designed pine box adorned with the company’s motto, “You might give some serious thought to thanking your lucky stars you’re in Texas.” Thankfully, you don’t need to reside in Texas to enjoy this treat, as Goldbelly offers free nationwide shipping.

3. Bake Me A Wish!

Bake Me A Wish! boasts an adorable name and an even more charming backstory. Founder Josh Kaye, during his first year away from home, wanted to send his mother her favorite cake for her birthday. However, he discovered that no Manhattan bakeries offered mail-order cakes. Seizing the opportunity, he created Bake Me A Wish! to fill this niche. Today, the company delivers a variety of baked goods, including pies, nationwide. Their bountiful blueberry pie, crafted with fresh blueberries, starts at approximately $45. For those who prefer other flavors, options like sour cherry pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, and more are available. Next-day delivery is offered for orders placed before 4:40 p.m. EST, while orders after that time are processed the next business day.

4. Four & Twenty Blackbirds

Four & Twenty Blackbirds, founded by sisters Melissa and Emily Elsen, has taken Brooklyn, New York, by storm with their exceptional pies. Hailing from South Dakota, the Elsen sisters are celebrated for their salted caramel apple pie. They prioritize high-quality, locally sourced ingredients, also offering delights like salty honey pie and bittersweet chocolate pecan pie. While their pies are on the pricier side, costing around $79, the quality justifies the expense. Free shipping may not guarantee delivery by Christmas, but ordering through Goldbelly ensures your pie arrives in time for New Year’s celebrations, with nationwide shipping available.

5. Kermit's Key West Lime Shoppe

For those yearning for the tangy delight of key lime this holiday season, look no further than the origin itself. Kermit’s Key West Lime Shoppe, located in Key West, Florida, crafts its pies using the freshest key limes. Each pie features a zesty filling atop a crisp graham cracker crust, topped with generous swirls of whipped cream. Starting at $79, these pies are available with free shipping through Goldbelly, ensuring they arrive in time for Christmas festivities.