1. Essay Analysis of 'The Wasted Life' - Entry 4
'The Wasted Life' is an exceptional short story by Nam Cao, depicting the struggles of a poor petit-bourgeois intellectual before the revolution. The work is not only successful in its content but also in its artistic portrayal, especially in the depiction of the characters' psychology. What makes Nam Cao's character development unique is how he places characters in situations that force them to reveal deep inner conflicts. Hộ, the protagonist of 'The Wasted Life,' is crafted in such a manner. Among the many details shaping Hộ's character, the detail of his tear holds the most profound significance. This poignant moment represents the writer's sensitivity and skill in uncovering the hidden layers of human emotions.
'The Wasted Life' centers on the intense spiritual tragedy of the writer Hộ: his professional crisis and the agony of love. This tragedy will haunt Hộ until the final tear, which serves as his release. In another short story dealing with the theme of poor intellectuals, Nam Cao quotes a French writer: 'People only appear wicked and corrupt in the cold, indifferent eyes of the selfish, and tears are a lens that transforms the universe.' Nam Cao’s own story titled 'Tears' reflects this sentiment. The tears of intellectuals become an obsession for the writer, and in 'The Wasted Life,' Hộ's tears symbolize his awakening and redemption from his fallibilities. This marks a crucial moment in the development of his character.
Hộ is a young, poor writer with high ambitions and idealistic views on his craft. He dreams of creating a masterpiece, winning a Nobel Prize, and having his work translated into every language. Hộ would have had a chance to fulfill his dreams if not for the weight of family responsibilities. After marrying Từ and having children, he is burdened with the duties of fatherhood. He has no choice but to compromise his artistic integrity to support his family. He writes hastily, with little time for revision, producing dull and uninspired work that is soon forgotten.
Hộ would have ignored this if he were irresponsible, but the voice of a genuine writer haunts him. He berates himself, calling himself a 'wretch,' a 'scoundrel,' because of his careless writing. Yet the harsh reality of life offers him no other option. The daily struggle for survival forces Hộ to sacrifice his artistic aspirations to fulfill his role as a man and a father. The tragedy of Hộ is that reality does not allow him to pursue his craft, crushing his spirit and eroding the dreams of a man willing to dedicate his life to art.
Hộ’s professional tragedy pains him deeply, but he must also bear the weight of a second tragedy, the tragedy of love. For Hộ, love is a guiding principle, the highest form of living. It distinguishes humans from animals. He values his philosophy of life: the strong are not those who trample on others to satisfy selfish desires but those who lift others up. This is why he bends down to the pain of his wife Từ, sacrificing his own honor to bring her happiness. It is a noble act that few could accomplish. However, to support his family, Hộ must sacrifice his artistic ideals. Deep down, he understands that this small family is the source of the professional collapse he suffers. So, unintentionally, all his frustrations build up, sometimes suppressed, sometimes exploding uncontrollably. He drinks excessively, spends recklessly, and becomes angry without reason. At times, he shouts at and drives away his wife and children. Hộ is slowly violating the principles of his own philosophy of love.
Hộ might have continued down this path if not for a moment when he got drunk and wandered off with friends. When he woke up, he was horrified to remember that he had likely driven his wife and children away the previous day. He searched for them and found Từ holding their child, asleep on a hammock. Hộ’s tears flowed as he looked at her frail and weary form. He realized his mistake. No, his family was not the cause of his misery. It is where he could still live with dignity. Those tears did not represent weakness in Hộ but served to uphold and protect his integrity. Although life’s harsh realities had prevented him from achieving his artistic dreams, he still remained human in the fullest sense. But if he continued to violate his principles of love, he would lose his humanity. His tears purified his soul and freed him from the dead-end mistakes. This awakening and repentance marked Hộ’s internal struggle against the temptations of life.
In both 'Tears' and Hộ from 'The Wasted Life,' we see the fate of the poor intellectual in the society of their time. Their tears become an artistic 'code' for Nam Cao, symbolizing the meaning of the work. Throughout his stories, Nam Cao revisits the issue of the true artist’s struggle against the realities of life, and one can see reflections of the writer himself in these characters. Through them, Nam Cao critiques society for not allowing intellectuals to fulfill their dreams or contribute their talents, forcing them into a life of futility—'a wasted life.'
In conclusion, Hộ’s tears are not just a detail to express his psychological state but carry profound ideological meaning. For Nam Cao, tears are not symbols of weakness, but a weapon to defend one’s honor and dignity. This insight into human nature shapes the writer’s distinctive creative identity, making him impossible to confuse with any other.

2. Essay Analysis of 'The Wasted Life' - Entry 5
The unique and remarkable short story 'The Surplus Life' was written in 1943. It can be considered one of the key works that helped pave the way for the renowned novel 'The Winding River' by the writer Nam Cao, which was published the following year in 1944. Through this work, the image of the intellectual is depicted in poverty, with their ambitions crushed under the weight of their financial struggles.
'The Surplus Life' tells the story of a poor intellectual, a writer named Hộ. He is an honest man, deeply devoted to his wife and children. Hộ is responsible towards his family, and as a writer, he holds firm beliefs about his profession, always striving to create a truly valuable work that would overshadow all other contemporaneous pieces and potentially earn him a Nobel Prize. However, the harsh reality reveals itself when Hộ faces immense struggles. Despite working tirelessly, he cannot earn enough to support his family or afford medical care for his sickly children.
Hộ is portrayed as a man of great dignity, but the poverty he endures creates deep inner turmoil, especially as he watches his wife, Từ, suffer. Từ, a woman with a painful past, is forced to endure the hardships of life alongside her husband. Hộ, unable to write in peace or pursue his creative ambitions, feels humiliated. The financial hardships force him to produce sloppy and hurried work, which quickly fades from memory, leaving him ashamed of his own failure to achieve his earlier dreams.
In such a situation, Từ, who silently bears the hardships, shows understanding and deep compassion for her husband. However, Hộ, as a writer, feels the weight of his existence even more acutely. He often expresses frustration, blaming his family for his woes, yet deep down, he knows the fault lies within himself. He wallows in self-blame, consumed by feelings of helplessness and pain.
The main character in this work is a writer, and through Hộ's life and thoughts, Nam Cao addresses his frequent concern: the issue of artistic creation, his views on literature, and his expectations for the art form. Hộ is passionate about writing. The act of creation is his life's aspiration. Initially, he dismisses material concerns, dedicating himself to nurturing his talent. Hộ reads, reflects, explores, and critiques tirelessly, fully aware that choosing the path of writing means accepting poverty and hardship, but he does so willingly. Writing brings him immense joy, especially when he shares a well-written passage with his wife.
However, as poverty forces Hộ to write carelessly, his once-promising literary career turns into a sad reflection of the state of his life. The writer's despair is evident in his realization that his poverty has transformed him into a 'scoundrel' in the world of literature. This is Nam Cao's critique embedded within the narrative. The author emphasizes that true literary work requires not only skill but also creativity, a constant search for the new, the unique—qualities that only true talent and dedication can produce.
Nam Cao sharply critiques literary carelessness, considering those who write sloppily as dishonest individuals. He asserts that writing is about exploration, innovation, and delivering something new to the reader. It is not about following established templates or creating for commercial gain. Nam Cao stresses that literature should not accept mediocrity; it must be deep, sincere, and creative—attributes that only genuine artistic talent can produce.
The author also defines the role of a writer as not merely a craftsman who follows conventions but as an artist driven by deep internal impulses. Writing is a spiritual activity, a compelling force that urges the artist to create, to express their emotions and thoughts through words, music, or visual art. For Nam Cao, true literature resonates with the reader because it expresses something profound and authentic, something that moves the soul.
Furthermore, in literature, truth and sincerity are essential, but they are not enough. The work must also be profound, original, and creative. Without a new perspective or a fresh voice, a work cannot truly stand out in the artistic world. Nam Cao was acutely aware of the tragic realities of life, finding meaning in the seemingly insignificant, everyday details.
Hộ's struggles with his family, his lofty ambitions, and his deep frustration with his unfulfilled dreams are central to the story. Through these personal conflicts, Nam Cao transforms ordinary moments into profound reflections on life, pain, and the human condition. The narrative invites readers to examine the everyday world around them, to reflect on their own lives, and to seek greater empathy and understanding for others.
'The Surplus Life' has a natural, organic structure. Ultimately, it is a story without a traditional plot, focused more on Hộ's internal struggles and his inability to fulfill his aspirations as a writer. The events described are insignificant on the surface, but they provide insight into the character's emotional turmoil and his deep yearning to create meaningful work.
In the end, Hộ's constant struggle to earn a living and his overwhelming family responsibilities undermine his artistic ambitions. His creative dreams fade as he is consumed by the need to survive. The story poignantly illustrates the conflict between artistic passion and the harsh realities of life, capturing the essence of human suffering and ambition.
Through the depth and originality of the themes, as well as the quality of thought, poetic elements, and lyricism, 'The Surplus Life' stands as a unique and captivating work. It invites readers to revisit the story multiple times, contemplating each line and each idea expressed by Nam Cao.

3. Analysis of the story 'The Superfluous Life' No. 6
Nam Cao is a prominent writer in Vietnamese literature, with numerous works from the pre-1945 period. Among his works is 'The Superfluous Life', as well as 'Chi Pheo', both reflecting the harsh social realities of the time.
In the face of a chaotic society, Nam Cao consistently expressed his deep desire to challenge the social conditions of his time, portraying the society’s complexities and offering profound insights. Every detail in his works reflects the inner turmoil of the characters, revealing both their struggles with life and their battle with the harsh society of that era. The story reveals the brutalities of society at the time, transforming people into victims of the oppressive forces, particularly intellectuals, who were weighed down by the pressures of survival.
Through the creation of contradictory situations, Nam Cao aimed to expose the flaws of society, showing how people constantly faced the storms of life. The harsh living conditions, suffocated by hunger, reflected the larger social struggles, and the character of Hộ served as a poignant critique of the feudal society that prevailed at the time.
With so many aspirations and ideals, yet crushed by society, these dreams and ambitions were suffocated as characters faced the agony of poverty, leading to the inevitable tragedy of the times. In the story, the character Hộ, a writer and intellectual, is overwhelmed by hunger and poverty, causing his once-promising ambitions to fade. He is consumed by guilt, feeling useless and unable to provide for his family. This triggers a deeper personal crisis that stems from his inability to fulfill his dreams within the constraints of his impoverished reality. The poverty and hardship lead to the corruption and degradation of intellectuals, leaving them with no escape.
Nam Cao successfully crafts his characters with great sensitivity, allowing them to express their inner thoughts and emotions. The internal monologues of the character Hộ illustrate the psychological progression and his realization of the harshness of life, as he disconnects from his artistic aspirations and fully immerses himself in the harsh realities of his existence.
The poverty not only undermines the intellectual’s spirit but also saps their creative energy, reflecting the despair that pervades the society. The writer portrays the grim social conditions vividly, embodying the belief that art should not deceive like a false moonbeam, but rather be a representation of suffering that arises from the misery of life. True art, as Nam Cao’s works reveal, leaves the reader with deep reflections on life, the future, and the harsh realities of existence.
'The Superfluous Life' is a stark reflection of societal realities, depicting intellectuals who are assimilated into society and plunged into tragedy due to the oppressive demands of survival. The pressures of earning a living trample on true artistic values, and poverty forces artists to compromise their creative integrity.
Poverty leads to the moral decay of genuine artists, who are supposed to create new and meaningful works, not merely follow predetermined patterns. Nam Cao’s portrayal of the intellectuals' degradation in a society steeped in poverty is profound.
In the pre-1945 society, individuals were trapped in the cycle of poverty, leading to moral and spiritual degradation. Even genuine artists faced immense pressure to survive, ultimately losing the essence of their creativity to the demands of daily life.

4. Analysis of the story 'The Superfluous Life' No. 7
The short story 'The Superfluous Life' was written in 1943. It can be considered as a precursor to the novel 'Living a Wasted Life,' which was completed the following year, in 1944. It is no coincidence that both works share autobiographical qualities and their titles reveal similar emotions and creative ideas.
'The Superfluous Life' tells the story of a poor intellectual, a writer. Ho is an honest man, deeply caring for his wife and children, and takes great responsibility for his family. He is a writer with clear ideas and a serious approach to his craft, aspiring to create a truly valuable work that would surpass all others of his time, perhaps even earning a Nobel Prize. However, in reality, Ho endures many hardships. He works tirelessly but still struggles to support his family and provide medical care for his sick children. As a man, husband, and father with a strong sense of self-respect, Ho suffers greatly at the sight of his family's poverty, especially seeing his wife, Tu, who has endured much pain from a past lover, silently enduring hardships for him. He is conflicted and distressed by the family's struggles.
Ho rarely has the chance to write freely, to pursue his creative desires. Despite his noble intentions, he is forced to write carelessly and sloppily just to earn money, producing works that, each time he revisits them, make him feel shame and regret. The torment of poverty, the image of his underfed children, and the embarrassment of his writing, into which he pours so many hopes, gradually turn Ho into a bitter, rough, and indifferent person. He shouts at his wife and children, drinks excessively, but each time he sobers up, he feels deep remorse, more love for his family, and a sense of self-blame. Through Nam Cao’s work, we see that good people with dreams and aspirations, hardworking and honest people, suffer so much, both materially and emotionally!
In such circumstances, people like Tu can only endure and silently support their husbands. But Ho, as a writer, feels the weight of his existence even more, seeing no way out, experiencing a true tragedy. Ho sometimes says his family makes him suffer, but deep down, he knows that’s not the case. He doesn’t know whom to blame, so he blames himself, berates himself, and drowns in his own sense of injustice and sorrow. The main character in this work is a writer. Therefore, through Ho's life and, especially, his thoughts, the story directly addresses a recurring theme of Nam Cao’s: the creative process and his thoughts on literature.
Ho is passionate about his writing. Creative writing is both his aspiration and his life's ideal. At first, he looks down on concerns about material needs and dedicates all his energy to nurturing his talent. Ho reads, reflects, explores, and thinks endlessly. He knows that writing will bring him poverty and hardship, but he accepts it. Writing brings him joy like nothing else. He tells his wife after reading a beautiful passage: ‘Tu, you know, I believe my life isn't meant to be miserable. I have made myself suffer because I love writing so much. But even though I am suffering, if someone offered me a fortune to exchange my position, I wouldn't accept it. Because when I read a passage like this and understand its beauty, no amount of delicious food could compare. It's a joy like no other! How can there be people so talented in this world?’
According to Ho, a truly valuable work—what Ho hopes to create in his entire literary life—must not only reflect local concerns or the superficial aspects of society. 'It must transcend boundaries and limitations; it must be a work for all humanity. It must contain something grand and powerful, both painful and uplifting. It should celebrate compassion, charity, and justice. It should bring people closer to one another.'
This is certainly also Nam Cao’s desire and standard for a great literary work. Literature, to him, is not just a profession but a calling, an internal necessity for both creation and appreciation, a source of both pain and joy, a voluntary pursuit. Literature is a realm of talent, a place for deep, inspired connections. Its noble function is to humanize society and life, making people empathize with one another and grow closer.
Nam Cao harshly criticizes the carelessness in writing, seeing careless writers as dishonest. He writes: ‘Carelessness in any profession is dishonesty, but carelessness in literature is despicable.’ Nam Cao firmly believes that writing and creating art require constant discovery and innovation: ‘Literature doesn’t need skilled workers following pre-established patterns. It only accepts those who know how to dig deeper, explore new sources, and create what hasn’t existed before.’
This is a very accurate and high standard for literature. Writers and artists must, of course, know their craft and understand technique to a certain extent, especially in fields like sculpture, music performance, etc. But writers and artists, in essence, are not workers, even if they are skilled, following models or orders. Literature and art are intellectual activities, expressions of emotions and thoughts that cannot be suppressed, taking the form of words, music, or art. Only genuine literature, which the writer feels compelled to write, can touch the hearts of others and hold real value.
Moreover, in literature, being truthful and sincere is not enough—there must also be depth, originality, and the ability to uncover what has not been discovered before. Without depth or the ability to create something new, without a fresh perspective or unique voice, one cannot truly find a place in the world of art.
According to Nam Cao, writers who produce dull, shallow works that only evoke superficial emotions, ‘repeating trivial thoughts in a flat and overly simplistic style,’ bring nothing new to literature. These are useless individuals, superfluous people. In his work, Nam Cao uses the term ‘superfluous’ to refer to people and lives that are unnecessary and unimportant to society. Only those who are honest, who understand the value of human life and true creativity, can recognize and lament their own superfluity. The concept of the ‘superfluous person’ is a reflection on the emptiness and deadlock of life.
This theme is explored by Nam Cao in various short stories, and later more deeply in his novel 'Living a Wasted Life.' His characters, especially intellectuals, often live deeply in their inner world. To present the inner life of his characters, Nam Cao sometimes uses psychological description directly, but often lets the characters express themselves through 'internal monologue.' In 'The Superfluous Life,' Nam Cao combines both methods: describing the character's actions, relationships, and dialogue, while allowing them to express their inner thoughts (internal monologue).
This approach gives the work a lyrical quality, and many passages genuinely move the reader due to the sincere thoughts and emotional pain of the characters, as well as the author’s own. At the core of 'The Superfluous Life,' there is a poetic quality, a longing for beauty, a desire for a life where people love one another and live meaningfully. Nam Cao, like Chekhov, aspired to write with the same depth. He, too, possessed a poetic soul, a profound love and sorrow for humanity like Chekhov. Just as Chekhov saw the meaning and tragedy of life in the seemingly trivial, meaningless events of everyday life, Nam Cao also portrays this understanding in his work.
The frustrations and emotional struggles Ho and Tu face in their family, the self-assurance that becomes arrogance, the despair and lofty ideals, all collide within Ho’s mind while he writes. These common human experiences, though ordinary, become tragedies in Nam Cao’s hands. Through his talent and sensitivity, he elevates the pain and drama of life, turning the superfluous person and the superfluous life into a poignant reflection on the emptiness and struggle within human existence. Nam Cao’s works encourage the reader to examine the ordinary, to reflect on their own lives, and to live with greater awareness, compassion, and understanding.
'The Superfluous Life' has a very natural structure. It is essentially a story without a traditional plot. The events are minimal. The author briefly touches on Tu’s unhappy past, Ho and Tu’s relationship, and a meeting with Ho’s writer friends. However, the story mainly focuses on Ho’s thoughts and his anguish over being unable to fulfill his passionate desire to write and produce works of true value.
Ho should dedicate all his energy to literature and contribute to his chosen noble career, but instead, he is forced to focus on earning a living, constantly interrupted by the needs of his struggling family. As a result, he becomes coarse and degraded, and his initial dreams gradually fade away. His inner conflict between the aspiration to create great works of literature and the immediate demands of family life is the heart of the story. The depth of the work lies in this emotional struggle, in the quality of Ho's reflections on life and literature, which express the author’s own thoughts on creativity.
It can be said that the characters in 'The Superfluous Life' are representations of moods and inner struggles. The poetic and lyrical qualities that permeate the work create a profound and compelling effect. The depth, originality, and emotional resonance of the theme make 'The Superfluous Life' especially captivating, as well as many other works by Nam Cao, whose natural storytelling style draws readers back again and again, stopping to ponder each thought and sentence he writes.

5. Analytical essay on the work 'The Surplus Life' - No. 8
When discussing the prominent realist writers of Vietnamese literature, aside from names like Ngô Tất Tố, Nguyễn Công Hoan, and Vũ Trọng Phụng, Nam Cao is one that many of us think of. His works have left a lasting impression and reflection in the hearts of readers, particularly his pre-August Revolution pieces. In addition to his works on the theme of peasants, Nam Cao also excelled in portraying intellectuals, with 'The Surplus Life' being a prime example of this theme.
First, let's explore the title of this work. As we know, a literary work is like a writer's spiritual child. Therefore, the title holds great significance, as it not only captures the reader’s attention but also conveys the author’s artistic intent and thematic message. In this case, the title 'The Surplus Life' reflects the existential struggles of intellectuals in a society that offers little hope. While peasants suffer from degradation, intellectuals also find themselves trapped in a world filled with artistic and emotional tragedies.
This society fails to provide opportunities for intellectuals or the literary works they create, as they are burdened with basic survival needs. In life, one may have surplus clothing, food, and rice, yet here the character Hộ finds his life surplus. He feels redundant, insignificant in the face of the world, and alienated even from his own family. Through this work, we also gain insight into Nam Cao’s views on literary creation.
The life of Hộ is analyzed through two major tragedies: the artist’s artistic crisis and his tragic relationship with his family. The first tragedy, the artistic crisis, unfolds before Hộ meets Từ. At that time, Hộ harbored grand ambitions. For an artist like him, hunger and hardship meant nothing. His heart was pure, and his mind was filled with lofty dreams: 'I will spend my whole life writing a single piece of work, and it will overshadow everything else created in the same era. This work will win the Nobel Prize and be translated into every language across the world.'
Through the thoughts of this intellectual, we see a person so passionate about art that he forgets about the mundane concerns of daily life. He is fully dedicated to his craft, a true artist. Among Hộ’s views on literature is the belief that 'literature does not need skilled craftsmen who follow old models; it requires artists who uncover the unknown and create what has never been done before.' He also holds that 'sloppiness in any profession is dishonorable, but sloppiness in literature is vile.' We can affirm that Hộ is a talented writer with noble character and beautiful ideals.
As Hộ’s life intertwines with Từ’s, his artistic tragedy begins. Now, Hộ no longer has only himself to worry about. He has a family to care for, struggling with the burdens of everyday life. His wife is hungry and his children sickly, each one constantly ill or causing trouble. To provide for his family, Hộ writes prolifically, forsaking his dream of a lifetime’s work. Some of his writings, once read, are soon forgotten, yet he must write them because his family depends on his meager income. Hộ is tormented as he goes against his professional ethics and is ashamed of his work. He condemns himself as a 'vile, despicable, and dishonorable' person. He shatters his idealism and falls into tragedy.
We see that Hộ’s tragedy is not his alone but a reflection of the social tragedy of the time. In this society, human value, life, and talent become meaningless. Hộ’s tragedy is the conflict between his circumstances and his personal dignity. He not only suffers as an artist whose talent is stifled, but he also experiences the tragedy of love and family.
Before his downfall, Hộ viewed love as the highest measure of a person’s character. The strong were those who helped others. Từ was a woman abandoned by her lover, who not only caused her suffering but also left her with a child and refused to take responsibility. Từ, pregnant and with a blind mother, was rescued by Hộ. He took her in, caring for her mother and becoming the father of her unborn child. From this moment, we see Hộ as a man full of compassion and humanity. For the sake of love, he sacrifices his grand ambitions to support his family. He agrees to write works that are little more than 'mediocre and worthless' in order to provide for his loved ones. Yet deep inside, he still wrestles with the loss of his great dream.
But when he recognizes his own dishonor and moral failure, Hộ abandons the very love he once valued and the principles by which he lived. He grows despondent and turns to alcohol. He begins to abuse his wife and children, becoming an abusive husband. Despite this, he is haunted by his unfulfilled artistic dreams. Within him, two conflicting selves battle: one is the artist, the other is the man of daily life, one filled with hope, the other with despair. He hopes that alcohol will numb his pain, but it only deepens it, turning him into a violent man trapped in his tragic fate. Every time he sobers up, he feels the weight of his failures, cursing himself for his treatment of his family and calling himself despicable.
This illustrates a great tragedy of intellectuals in that era. Hộ’s life is emblematic of the intellectual struggle: though his great ambition remains in his heart, the society around him only brings him suffering. Once again, the reality of his situation underscores the harsh truths of life.

6. Analysis of the Short Story "The Surplus Life" No. 9
Nam Cao is a renowned realist and humanitarian writer in Vietnamese literature. Throughout his writing career, he struggled to ensure that his 'eyes' could truly empathize with the lives of the oppressed peasants and impoverished intellectuals. 'The Surplus Life' is a short story about an intellectual, a representative example of the 'endless intellectual' and also demonstrates Nam Cao’s exceptional talent in creating and portraying complex characters. One of the notable characters in the story is Từ, Hộ’s unfortunate wife.
In 'The Surplus Life,' the character Từ is not portrayed in great detail, only briefly described by Nam Cao in the latter part of the story. She is depicted as a 'fated woman' with a pale, unhealthy complexion, faint lips, dark circles under her eyes, sunken cheeks, and skeletal hands. Từ appears as a fatigued woman, worn out by the struggles of life, with the beauty of her youth now replaced by the harsh realities of a life marked by hardship.
In analyzing the character of Từ in 'The Surplus Life,' we see a woman who has suffered greatly. As a young woman, she blindly trusted a reckless lover, only to face the tragedy of abandonment. This is one of the most painful and devastating experiences for a decent woman like Từ, who longed for love. The image of Từ after being deserted, clinging to her child while starving, with her blind mother helplessly suffering, is heart-wrenching. She only has tears to offer, crying until her flesh turns to water, wishing to die along with her mother and child.
The character Từ embodies the virtues of a devoted wife and loving mother. She is gentle, understanding, and self-sacrificing. Despite Hộ’s cruelty when drunk, Từ never blames him. Instead, she takes care of him, understanding that his suffering is due to the burdens he carries for her and their child. From the tender gestures, like the warm cup of tea she prepares for Hộ after his drunken stupor, we see a woman full of love and forgiveness, enduring hardships with grace.
Even though Hộ mistreats her with harsh words while intoxicated, Từ continues to love and care for him. She never leaves with her child because, alongside her love for Hộ, she is deeply grateful to him for taking her in during her most difficult and desperate time. 'Từ loves her husband with a devotion akin to that of a dog to its owner,' showcasing her unconditional and sincere love.
At the end of the story, when Hộ awakens from his drunken state and regrets his cruel actions, Từ gently embraces him, saying, 'No, you are just someone who suffers… because of me and you, we both suffer.' This moment reveals her profound love and immense capacity for forgiveness. Từ continues to soothe her child with her tears, keeping her suffering within herself so she can empathize with and understand her husband. It is her love that helps Hộ awaken and change.
Nam Cao’s deep humanitarian spirit is evident in his empathy for Từ’s tragic life and his appreciation for the inner goodness of a woman who, despite her suffering, remains full of love and compassion.

7. Analysis of the Short Story "The Surplus Life" No. 10
In the story "The Bright Moon," Nam Cao sharply critiques the romantic escapism in literature, calling it a "false moonlight," advocating for genuine art to return to the real world. In contrast, in "The Surplus Life," he criticizes shallow realism that merely depicts the surface of society. The character Hộ offers a critical perspective on the book "The Way Back" by a friend, soon to be translated into English: "The Way Back is only locally relevant. Do you understand? People translate it to learn about customs, but it only depicts the surface of society. I think it is very trivial! The trend of ‘realism’ is limited to ‘real’ depictions, just showing the surface of society, which is typical of that kind of realism." Nam Cao’s artistic consciousness, with its deep, modern realism, distinguishes between false literature and true, profound realism that goes beyond mere appearances.
Nam Cao's view on what constitutes "a truly valuable work" reveals his unexpected artistic vision. A truly great work must transcend boundaries and limitations, speaking to all of humanity. It must embody something grand, powerful, both poignant and uplifting. It praises compassion, kindness, justice... bringing people closer together.
The words of Hộ, delivered amid a group of fellow writers over beer, seem to be a profound and progressive artistic manifesto, encapsulating some of the finest artistic declarations today. In the midst of the chaotic colonial society at the time, marked by fascist wars, arrests, starvation... and where writers were also starving, struggling in a market of both genuine and fake literature, it is astonishing that Nam Cao, a relatively unknown writer, could have such deep, sincere artistic thoughts.
Nam Cao emphasizes the core of what defines authentic value in literature: it must be permeated with a grand humanitarian ideal. Art should address the fate of humanity, capturing both the pain of human existence and igniting hope and desire for a life of compassion, justice, and harmony. His notion of literature aligns with that of Chekhov: literature brings people closer together. What a beautiful and profound thought!
Through the character Hộ, Nam Cao also offers a poignant and passionate statement on the exploration inherent in the creative process of writing: Literature does not need skilled craftsmen who follow set templates. It is meant for those who dig deep, seek the unseen, and bring forth what has not been discovered yet. Hộ’s feelings of embarrassment and shame when reading a hastily written piece of his own work—tearing it up and cursing himself—reflect Nam Cao's strict expectations for literary labor and the moral responsibility of the writer. Nam Cao's story "The Surplus Life" exemplifies not just his artistic philosophy but also his profound humanity, revealing the heart of a great artist.
The narrative of "The Surplus Life" may not be filled with dramatic plot twists or striking characters with unforgettable personalities. The story itself might not seem captivating on the surface. Yet, it remains a masterpiece, reflecting a fully matured talent. Nam Cao demands constant renewal and innovation in literature, and his work brought significant, deep transformations to the rapidly developing modern Vietnamese prose. Despite its bold innovations, Nam Cao’s writing does not strive to be unusually unique or striking; it is often simple, natural, and deeply connected to everyday life. This simplicity, however, is the mark of a masterful, experienced writer.
The plot of "The Surplus Life" is rather simple, almost mundane. It unfolds in a confined space: a small bourgeois couple struggles with poverty, yet the tensions never escalate into any major conflicts. However, from these seemingly trivial domestic occurrences, the author raises significant, profound social and philosophical issues. It is the result of Nam Cao's profound engagement with life, keen observations, and thoughtful reflections on his experiences.
Nam Cao’s writing showcases his sharp analytical thinking. His uniqueness lies in his ability to transform ordinary, familiar experiences into insightful, profound reflections. "The Surplus Life" may seem simple, but it tackles crucial issues of the time—individuals versus society, ideals versus reality, art versus human connection, characters versus circumstances.
The conflict in the story is not between protagonists and antagonists, or the ruling and the oppressed, but a deep, ongoing internal struggle within the character. This mirrors the irreconcilable conflict between individuals and societies hostile to human beings. As a result, the story is both deeply realistic in its portrayal of small details and expansive in its philosophical implications. The philosophical aspects here are not abstract or metaphysical, but arise from the harsh struggles of daily life, from the emotional turmoil of an honest and courageous soul seeking truth. This reflective, philosophical tone gives "The Surplus Life" its distinct voice.
In creating the character Hộ, Nam Cao does not focus on crafting an outstanding personality with unique traits like the characters in "Storm," "The Red Book," "Turn Off the Lights," or "Chí Pheo." Instead, he delves into the character’s inner life, highlighting the intellectual’s spiritual tragedy. Nam Cao is unparalleled in his ability to explore and express the complexities of human psychology. His writing reveals an exquisite, profound insight into the human psyche, and in this regard, Nam Cao’s works are unmatched in their sensitivity to psychological depth.
The artistic appeal of "The Surplus Life"—and of Nam Cao’s portrayal of the petty bourgeois—lies significantly in this depth of psychological exploration.

8. Analysis of the work "The Surplus Life" - Part 1
Nam Cao is a renowned writer in Vietnamese literature, delving deeply into realism to portray the suffering of the common people in the old society, from farmers to intellectuals. Most of his works follow the tragic journey of the protagonist, yet they are deeply humanistic, especially through a love for humanity. "The Surplus Life" is such a piece.
Nam Cao (1917-1951), born in Ha Nam Province, lived in a time when the country was struggling, facing widespread poverty. With a strong humanistic artistic foundation, he became aware of the revolutionary spirit early on. He fought in the war while also working as a journalist on the frontlines. Throughout his literary career, Nam Cao had many profound humanistic views, the most famous being: "Art does not need to be a deceiving moonlight; it should not deceive. Art must be the anguished cry from the suffering lives of the oppressed, and the writer must stand in hardship, opening their soul to the world's echoes." He believed that art must be intertwined with human life, delving into painful tragedies to understand and empathize. Some of Nam Cao's famous works include *Chi Pheo*, *The Surplus Life*, and after the August Revolution, *The Eyes*, which marked a shift in his artistic perspective.
*The Surplus Life* was first written and published in 1943, a significant work by Nam Cao that reflects the fate of intellectuals in the years before the revolution. It is often considered a work for all humanity, transcending the boundaries of human compassion, a rare and precious emotion. It affirms that creating art should not be a careless endeavor, but a meticulous work that requires immense dedication, including blood and tears. Writing carelessly is considered heartless, immoral, and vile, as a writer's work is their immortal intellectual child. All these aspects are reflected in *The Surplus Life*, with the protagonist Hộ, an intellectual passionate about literature, who is forced to abandon his dreams to earn a living for his family, plunging him into a tragic, endless cycle.
The story begins with Từ's gaze as she looks at her husband Hộ, filled with love and patience. Hộ is depicted in vivid detail, with thick eyebrows furrowed, a wrinkled forehead, prominent cheekbones, a high straight nose, and slightly bulging eyes. These features give him a "gaunt" and "harsh" appearance, to the point that even his wife, who shares his bed, is afraid of him. Từ, a woman with a tragic past, once cried herself dry and almost died with her newborn after being abandoned by her unfaithful lover. However, her life took a different turn when Hộ, a kind-hearted man who loved literature, took her in, married her, and made her a devoted wife and mother. Nam Cao compares Từ’s love for her husband to the loyalty of a dog to its master. She is a very obedient, devoted wife, never once questioning or opposing Hộ. For Từ, Hộ was not only her savior but also someone she owed her entire life to, and she was willing to sacrifice everything for him.
However, Hộ does not enjoy happiness for long. Despite his humane actions and the love of his wife, Hộ ends up on a different path, one that was not aligned with his ideals. Hộ, being poor as most pre-revolutionary writers were, struggled to make ends meet, let alone provide for a family with a wife and children. He gave up his true literary passion to write superficial works, devoid of meaningful content, filled with trivial emotions and shallow thoughts. When Hộ reads these works, he is filled with shame and disgust, feeling degraded for his lack of integrity in his writing.
Hộ feels worthless in the literary world, where he is seen as a craftsman following patterns rather than an innovator. His self-loathing grows as he struggles with the pain of providing for his family while suppressing his artistic soul. But can Hộ abandon his family to pursue his literary dreams? His conscience and sense of responsibility as a husband and father forbid him from doing so. He consoles himself with the hope that he can make enough money in a few years to allow Từ to run a small business, giving him the freedom to return to his writing. But life, as always, is cruel. As more children are born, their constant cries and illnesses drain Từ, leaving her unable to help with anything else. The household becomes chaotic, making it impossible for Hộ to focus on his writing. In frustration, Hộ often storms out, seeking solace in conversations about literature with friends, only to return home burdened by his sorrow.
As time passes, Hộ changes, coming home drunk and oblivious to the world around him. Từ, patiently waiting, takes care of him, even when he threatens and insults her. In his drunken state, Hộ's words seem like empty threats, almost as if he were scolding children. Yet when he sobers up, he is once again the loving husband and father, and Từ, who has suffered so much, finds it difficult to be angry with him. She believes the tragedy of their lives is due to her own actions, and she even considers leaving, thinking that perhaps Hộ would return to his youthful self if she were gone. However, Từ's love and weakness keep her by his side, caring for him and the children with unwavering devotion.
The cycle continues, as Từ reminds Hộ of the house expenses, which only adds to his frustration. Hộ regrets his spending, realizing that his family has been struggling due to his irresponsibility. He decides to use his salary to buy food for his family, but once again, he gets caught up in drinking with his friends and forgets his promises. The next morning, Hộ wakes up, afraid that Từ might have left him. Fortunately, she is still there, holding their child in her arms, and Hộ is overcome with guilt for treating her so poorly.
Nam Cao's *The Surplus Life* is a poignant portrayal of the struggle between personal aspirations and the harsh realities of life. It explores the human condition, the complexities of family, and the pain of unfulfilled dreams, all against the backdrop of a society in turmoil before the revolution. The story highlights the paradox of human kindness, which, in this case, becomes the very source of tragedy. Ultimately, it emphasizes Nam Cao's belief that art should be created with sincerity and dedication, as carelessness in art is a betrayal of one's conscience and humanity.
The painful life of Hộ and Từ is deeply intertwined with the context of pre-revolutionary Vietnam, where both intellectuals and peasants were trapped in a world of despair. Hộ, a man full of dreams and ideals, was crushed by the harshness of life, forced into a life of suffering due to his compassion for others.
The short story *The Surplus Life* is one of Nam Cao's finest works, a reflection on the social realities before the August Revolution of 1945. It reveals a strange paradox: the characters' humanitarianism becomes the very cause of their suffering. Yet, within this tragedy, the story also portrays the deep love between husband and wife, parent and child, and between humans. Perhaps the most lasting impression is Hộ's profound love for literature, which echoes Nam Cao's artistic belief that literature must never be careless, for carelessness is heartless and vile.

9. Analysis of the story "The Surplus" - Essay 2

10. Analytical Essay on the Work 'The Superfluous Life' No. 3
Nam Cao is one of Vietnam's great writers, whose works have contributed immensely to the nation's literary treasure. His short story 'The Superfluous Life,' written in 1943, stands as a quintessential example of his literary style.
The story vividly portrays the lives of poor intellectuals, whose lofty dreams have been overwhelmed by the harsh reality of poverty. Today, we will analyze 'The Superfluous Life,' a short story by Nam Cao. The work tells the story of a poor intellectual writer, a man who deeply cares for his family, loves his wife and children, and is a man of integrity. He harbors grand ambitions and is genuinely serious about his literary work. He dreams of writing a masterpiece that will surpass other works of his time and win the Nobel Prize.
However, an incredibly harsh reality crushes his dreams. Life seems to have drowned his ambitions. He works tirelessly every day to make ends meet, yet still struggles to support his family. He lacks the money to care for his sick children. He is a man of high self-respect, a husband and father distressed by the suffering of his family, and saddened by the poverty that surrounds them. He feels deep sorrow when his wife, Từ, a woman burdened with the pain of a past lover, must endure this hardship alongside him.
The overwhelming poverty prevents Hộ from writing with peace of mind. Instead, he writes hurriedly and carelessly. His works lack refinement and are often forgotten by readers. Hộ feels ashamed of himself and experiences great humiliation when reflecting on his earlier dreams and ambitions.
In such circumstances, characters like Từ can only endure, showing immense patience and understanding towards their husbands. However, Hộ, as a writer, becomes more acutely aware of the weight of his situation, seeing no way out. His life is a true tragedy. At times, he blames his wife and children for his suffering, but deep down, he knows this is not the case. Perhaps he blames no one but himself, biting into his own sense of frustration and despair.
The main character in the story is a writer, and thus the narrative explores his life, especially his thoughts, through the lens of Nam Cao’s recurring themes. It touches on the issues he often addressed: artistic creation, his views on literature, and the standards he set for his work. Hộ is deeply passionate about writing, and literature is his life’s aspiration. Initially, Hộ dismisses concerns about material struggles and devotes himself entirely to cultivating his literary talent. He reads, thinks, reflects, and critiques with great dedication. He knows that a career in literature will bring poverty and hardship, but he accepts this willingly, for writing is a source of immense joy for him. Every time he shares a well-written passage with his wife, it brings him a sense of fulfillment.
However, the poverty he faces forces him to write hastily, producing works that lack depth and quality, all in an attempt to earn enough to survive. His financial struggles transform him into a 'despicable' writer. This is a key theme Nam Cao embedded in the story, conveying his belief that literature should not be tainted by mediocrity. Writing should be a calling, a necessity, not a mere profession. Hộ’s internal struggle represents Nam Cao’s views on literature — it is not simply a career, but a life force that binds the writer to the world.
Nam Cao criticized careless writers who fail to approach their craft with seriousness and respect. He viewed such negligence as a betrayal of art itself, calling it 'base' and 'dishonest.' He emphasized that literature is about discovery and creativity, and that only those who can dig deep into the unseen can truly contribute something meaningful to the world. Nam Cao argued that 'Literature does not need skilled craftsmen who merely replicate models; it only accepts those who seek to unearth the unknown, to create something new.'
This perspective illustrates Nam Cao’s high standards for literature. A writer, or any artist, must be highly skilled, not just in technique but in their understanding of the essence of their craft. Unlike a craftsman following pre-set patterns, a writer creates from an inner drive, pouring personal thoughts and emotions into their work. It is this 'genuine' literature — uncontainable and raw — that resonates with others, touching hearts and changing lives.
Moreover, in the realm of literature, being genuine is not enough. It must also be profound and innovative, bringing fresh perspectives and new voices. Without depth and originality, literature cannot stand out. Nam Cao keenly felt the tragic dimensions of life, grasping its true meaning through the smallest, seemingly insignificant details of everyday existence.
The painful scenes within Hộ and Từ’s family illustrate this. Hộ’s confidence and idealism, once bold, are now clouded by disappointment and exhaustion. The noble thoughts he once had are torn between aspiration and the harsh realities of life. These conflicts are common, yet through Nam Cao’s mastery, they become poignant reflections on the human condition, highlighting the tragedies of those who are 'surplus,' living lives that seem to hold no true place in the world.
Nam Cao’s works, especially 'The Superfluous Life,' always attract attention. They make us reflect deeply on the ordinary, on the everyday, and challenge us to live with more awareness and compassion. Through his writing, he urges humanity to rise above pettiness, cruelty, and complacency. His works force us to confront the uncomfortable truths about our society. After reading 'The Superfluous Life,' one feels the raw and authentic portrayal of life’s hardships, especially the plight of intellectuals in the past, and the deep empathy for their struggles.

